New Townhall Ability- Houses Troops for Defense

[Nmills]

Why are you being so stubborn. Just look at the poll results, you're the only one who voted yes. Or read the feedback, everyone has told you its to similar to the clan castle. if your just going to ignore peoples feedback and continue to insist you are right and everyone else is wrong when people disagree with you then there isn't much point in you asking for our opinions.

[looktrick1979]

Why are you being so stubborn. Just look at the poll results, you're the only one who voted yes. Or read the feedback, everyone has told you its to similar to the clan castle. if your just going to ignore peoples feedback and continue to insist you are right and everyone else is wrong when people disagree with you then there isn't much point in you asking for our opinions.

What is your problem. 5 people voted. Who cares if a million people voted against it!

[jack2globaltitans]

If case you didn't notice SC you have major problems with the unfairness that is occurring at higher cup levels. Players are extremely frustrated that they lose 30 cups but can only gain 2-3 cups. Then on top of that the defense losses are killing the game. Looktrick is trying to make a suggestion to improve this situation. Just simply saying no or its ruled out doesn't fix the problem. Maybe consider the concept and trial it.

[Fr3nchfry]

WAAAAAAY TO OP!!!!! Besides thats the whole reason for the clan castle is to have back up troops. If you want them to only be used in defense then dont use them in raids. And I would much rather spend gold on walls and defense than this. No offense but very bad idea.


-Fr3nchfry

[looktrick1979]

WAAAAAAY TO OP!!!!! Besides thats the whole reason for the clan castle is to have back up troops. If you want them to only be used in defense then dont use them in raids. And I would much rather spend gold on walls and defense than this. No offense but very bad idea.


-Fr3nchfry

I think the vast majority of players will not like this idea because they are below townhall 9. THAT SAID, I THINK THE TOP LEVEL PLAYERS WOULD EMBRACE IT.

[Ytiev]

I think the vast majority of players will not like this idea because they are below townhall 9. THAT SAID, I THINK THE TOP LEVEL PLAYERS WOULD EMBRACE IT.

Champs be like: Defender: YESH! Attacker: No not another thing to try to lure out..... Wahhh

[Nmills]

What is your problem. 5 people voted. Who cares if a million people voted against it!

Nobody likes this idea but you. The poll is 8 against 1 those results are prety conclusive. take the hint, your idea is bad. What do you hope to gain from argueing against everybody else on the forums.

[looktrick1979]

Nobody likes this idea but you. The poll is 8 against 1 those results are prety conclusive. take the hint, your idea is bad. What do you hope to gain from argueing against everybody else on the forums.

What do u hope to gain by trolling?

[looktrick1979]

Hi and welcome to the forums!


Supercell ruled out this idea(s) because this would cause raids to become harder because you would have to try to lure the troops in the town hall. Please read all the ruled out ideas before posting next time (here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines)


~UltraDragonMaster
P.S. proof of that
Battle Related:

*Ability to assign 5 or so of your own troops to defend Town Hall, same AI as CC, smaller radius

In regards to your "AI is similar to CC, or smaller radius" I changed the nature of the update. See below and in my message.

The townhall would be a defensive building. The AI would be vastly different to the Clan Castle. Troops would defend only when the townhall is targeted. Troops like archers would shoot from the very top of the townhall. Once a troop is targeted by militia, it is targeted untill the attacking unit is killed or the militia troop is destroyed.

[Xandathrii]

So TH becomes CC v.2? To have a TH With an defensive abilitie would seem ok, but not With troops like that. Id rather put one Archer on a tiny Tower on top of the TH each Level from TH7-TH10, giving TH10 4 Archers :-)