My clan wars suggestion(10 stats)!!!

[nikcha87]

1.Only 50/50 (full clan) can do clan wars.
2.Leader can challenge any clan for battle that it is not already in war.
3.Opposite clan leader can accept or decline war.
4.When opposite leader accept war that 2 clans are in war and nobody can leave clan while war is in progress.
5.Every player has right for ONLY 1 attack against 1 player of opposite clan.
6.Leader of clan who attacked opposite clan will choose whitch player in his clan will attack opposite clan player.
7.Defending clan has right for revenge against attacker while he is ONLINE.Game will disconect automaticaly player and he will wait until revenge is complete.We dont want to loose precious time....
8.Clan war is over when 1 clan has theoreticaly win (51% of succes in attack or revenge).
9.Clan who won more those attack/revenge battles in finaly score wins clan war and recieved "clan war points"
10.That "clan war points" will calculate at the end of the league and clans who have enough clan war points will get reward in gems.

Write your comments of my suggestion below. Mine IGN -nikcha lvl121 Th10 in clan "Srpski blejači".

[966souchou]

1.Only 50/50 (full clan) can do clan wars.
2.Leader can challenge any clan for battle that it is not already in war.
3.Opposite clan leader can accept or decline war.
4.When opposite leader accept war that 2 clans are in war and nobody can leave clan while war is in progress.
5.Every player has right for ONLY 1 attack against 1 player of opposite clan.
6.Leader of clan who attacked opposite clan will choose whitch player in his clan will attack opposite clan player.
7.Defending clan has right for revenge against attacker while he is ONLINE.Game will disconect automaticaly player and he will wait until revenge is complete.We dont want to loose precious time....
8.Clan war is over when every player of two clans has finished attack/revenge.
9.Clan who won more those attack/revenge battles in finaly score wins clan war and recieved "clan war points"
10.That "clan war points" will calculate at the end of the league and clans who have enough clan war points will get reward in gems.

Write your comments of my suggestion below. Mine IGN -nikcha lvl121 Th10 in clan "Srpski blejači".

Clan wars is a commonly suggested feature, but this has some new features. Interesting.

Some parts might not work though, like the "full clan" thing. Most clans aren't full.

[PhilISuppose]

1.Only 50/50 (full clan) can do clan wars.
- almost no clans are full 50/50
2.Leader can challenge any clan for battle that it is not already in war.
3.Opposite clan leader can accept or decline war.
4.When opposite leader accept war that 2 clans are in war and nobody can leave clan while war is in progress.
- so people who want to leave just rage and swear until they are kicked?
5.Every player has right for ONLY 1 attack against 1 player of opposite clan.
6.Leader of clan who attacked opposite clan will choose which player in his clan will attack opposite clan player.
- this isn't a good method. It would be a massive advantage to the attacking clan.
7.Defending clan has right for revenge against attacker while he is ONLINE.Game will disconnect automatically player and he will wait until revenge is complete.We don't want to loose precious time....
- I don't think being attacked while online is a good idea. As a clan leader I would never choose this sort of clan war.
8.Clan war is over when every player of two clans has finished attack/revenge.
- So a clan war might never end?
9.Clan who won more those attack/revenge battles in finally score wins clan war and received "clan war points"
10.That "clan war points" will calculate at the end of the league and clans who have enough clan war points will get reward in gems
- I guess there has to be some sort of reward, gems seems unlikely

Write your comments of my suggestion below. Mine IGN -nikcha lvl121 Th10 in clan "Srpski blejači".

Feedback above, there are countless better Clan Wars threads, with more details.

[minimaddog]

1.Only 50/50 (full clan) can do clan wars.
2.Leader can challenge any clan for battle that it is not already in war.
3.Opposite clan leader can accept or decline war.
4.When opposite leader accept war that 2 clans are in war and nobody can leave clan while war is in progress.
5.Every player has right for ONLY 1 attack against 1 player of opposite clan.
6.Leader of clan who attacked opposite clan will choose whitch player in his clan will attack opposite clan player.
7.Defending clan has right for revenge against attacker while he is ONLINE.Game will disconect automaticaly player and he will wait until revenge is complete.We dont want to loose precious time....
8.Clan war is over when every player of two clans has finished attack/revenge.
9.Clan who won more those attack/revenge battles in finaly score wins clan war and recieved "clan war points"
10.That "clan war points" will calculate at the end of the league and clans who have enough clan war points will get reward in gems.

Write your comments of my suggestion below. Mine IGN -nikcha lvl121 Th10 in clan "Srpski blejači".

no just no no offense but people have WAY better ideas than this.. no just no

[nikcha87]

I think that clan wars has to be privilage for only full clans that has high amount of loyal players to clan and his leader so my opinion is that it isnt problem for making full clan,the problem is to make or find GOOD clans with LOYAL players in them. I forgot to mention that shield wont work against two clans while they are in war. Also clan war can automaticaly end when it is theoretical win for 1 clan, clan leader dont need to wait all guys to finish attack/revenge. That will save time... Also you mentioned some kind of advantage for attacking clan... That is not big deal while opposite clan leader in the beggining has choise for accepting or declining war, so you need to have clever leader who have eyes to see are he is facing with similar clans players...And 1 more yes you tell me that i will arrest my clan players and put him in some kind of jail while clan wars are...you must be joking...i never loved deserters in real life so i dont like them in the game and thank God i dont have them in my clan . Best regards .

[CaesarII]

This will take an extreme amount of activity that most clans don't have.

What if one member of your clan becomes inactive, so you can't start a new clan war with anyone else and nobody can leave because one member is inactive?

Needs to be better thought out

[nikcha87]

I will change that 8 term that tells when the clan war is over... I probably think that it will be many abuse in game if clan need to wait every player in clan to finish his attack or revenge, so i propose to make clan war done when it is teoreticaly win for 1 clan (51%) of succes. Clan leader in that case can finish war and clan is available for another wars. Now you dont need to have whole players activity...

[PhilISuppose]

I think that clan wars has to be privilage for only full clans that has high amount of loyal players to clan and his leader so my opinion is that it isnt problem for making full clan,the problem is to make or find GOOD clans with LOYAL players in them. I forgot to mention that shield wont work against two clans while they are in war. Also clan war can automaticaly end when it is theoretical win for 1 clan, clan leader dont need to wait all guys to finish attack/revenge. That will save time... Also you mentioned some kind of advantage for attacking clan... That is not big deal while opposite clan leader in the beggining has choise for accepting or declining war, so you need to have clever leader who have eyes to see are he is facing with similar clans players...And 1 more yes you tell me that i will arrest my clan players and put him in some kind of jail while clan wars are...you must be joking...i never loved deserters in real life so i dont like them in the game and thank God i dont have them in my clan . Best regards .

Can you go back to writing points or use some paragraphs. This is really painful to read.
(And I assumed it was replying to me? since you just replied to the thread and not the post)

Look at the top 100 clans, I doubt that even 1/4 of them have 50 members.

No shield when at war? That's terrible. Why would anyone choose to do this?

You said players can't leave during a war - what if I don't want to be in the war? Or even in the clan anymore?
I will just rage until the leader kicks me out. (I don't like deserters either, but if I am saving 7M gold to upgrade something huge, why would I want to be in some war with no shield?)

[nikcha87]

Can you go back to writing points or use some paragraphs. This is really painful to read.
(And I assumed it was replying to me? since you just replied to the thread and not the post)

Look at the top 100 clans, I doubt that even 1/4 of them have 50 members.

No shield when at war? That's terrible. Why would anyone choose to do this?

You said players can't leave during a war - what if I don't want to be in the war? Or even in the clan anymore?
I will just rage until the leader kicks me out. (I don't like deserters either, but if I am saving 7M gold to upgrade something huge, why would I want to be in some war with no shield?)

Clan wars is supposed only for serious clans, only in that case we will reduce neagative effect of creating many clans that has low ammount of players or inactive players....These top clans will have in every moment 50/50 coz many players will fight to join them....About shield i meant ONLY for two clans that are in battle(shield will normaly work in multiplayer attacks)....If you dont want to be part of clan wars you still have oportunity to be in anoghter clan or in feeder clan of your own that is for farming only.

[looktrick1979]

What an extremely complex update the clan war update will be.


When it happens everyone will be at war. Clan war could be as easy as just measuring what clan in a bucket has the most attack and defensive wins.