Get tips on your base, and give other people tips!

[Kjeldinator]

The turtle

Note: I only have 2 elixir and 2 gold storages upgraded. And I care much, much less for elixir at this point.



The star



see notes^

Input/flaws/weaknesses?

Top one looks great, but someone with lots of wb's crushes it i think sonce it mainly relies on the wall placement.

second one looks good too, not fully symmetrical and you should swap botom mortar and wiz tower for better trianglar splash.

top: 8.5/10

bottom: 8/10

[Retin]

I were unable to make it 100% symmetrical with only 3 teslas and for those who wanted to fit that 3rd elixir storage somewhere. I could make it even though, and just have an open spot, or place a bomb there. There is enough walls ^_^

[lewisrennison]

Watcha think?

[Kjeldinator]

Watcha think?

At your level, ther is no base that can withstand an attack from someone same level, defiantly not from higher players, it doesn't matter what base you got, but it looks good, but put the cannon thats more outside in frotn of the mortar, it will protect the mortar better, good luck with your journey!

[GabyTse]

I think the defenses are too focused in the north. And I don't have enough walls to protect my storages so I let them act as tanks. Tell me what you think about it.

[ClanX]

Screenshot_2014-04-03-20-59-41.jpg
What do you guys think?

[nathannathan1232]

What do you guys think about my base?

My Thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post1660112
Attachment 33223

The pic in the thread doesn't work.

Farming base

There are a lot of exposed junctions
The ADs are exposed
There are improper junctions

overall 7/10

Attachment 33236This is something a bit different, helping me climb really quite fast though, what do you guys think?

There are some improper junctions
The top isn't defended that well

overall 9/10

Attachment 33257

hows this one? another the trophy base

The clan castle is lurable
the ADs aren't even
There are improper junctions
Don't put builder huts in the corner with a trophy base

overall 6.5/10

The turtle

Note: I only have 2 elixir and 2 gold storages upgraded. And I care much, much less for elixir at this point.


I would try moving the top WT so it's to the right a bit, and can cover multiple storages
The mortars are exposed
there are improper junctions

overall 7/10

The star


The WTs are very uneven
I would move a mortar where a gold storage is in the core. Probably switch the bottom mortar for the bottom gold

overall 7/10


see notes^

Input/flaws/weaknesses?

I commented on each one.

[nathannathan1232]

Watcha think?

Tbh I would start over

The town hall shouldn't be covered by walls
The mortar should be centered, not the cc
Don't line up your collectors and mines

Overall 5.5/10

I think the defenses are too focused in the north. And I don't have enough walls to protect my storages so I let them act as tanks. Tell me what you think about it.

What's the goal of this base? It's a farming base, but the storages aren't protected.

Screenshot_2014-04-03-20-59-41.jpg
What do you guys think?

It's not symmetrical
Why do you have empty compartments if there aren't traps?
There are improper junctions

overall 7/10

[GabyTse]

Sorry... Didn't know what I was doing. I hope this base is at least a little bit better. I only farm gold and elixir.

[MattCoC]

I have a maxed TH7 and am working on a pure trophy base/war base for the upcoming clan wars. I've only ever been a farmer so this is a pretty new exercise for me and kinda fun. I like to look for some core ideas, and tweak them. I used this TH7 trap base as my inspiration - http://clashofclansbuilder.com/plan/350659

I like that it leaves some mystery as to where the teslas are and allows for some decent funneling opportunities. One of my big gripes is that the clan castle is easily lurable but I was having a hard time fixing this problem without it feeling like my town hall was too exposed.

Anyways curious to hear some thoughts.