Get tips on your base, and give other people tips!

[Awesomisticality]

Mine got skipped, any comments?

I took a look at your base and i think you achieved your goal. Honestly, i have absolutely no idea how to attack this base. The only thing i think you could fix is:In the compartment with the cannon and the giant bomb, you should switch the gb with the cannon so that hogs won't run past it when they trigger it. good luck with your base

[verh]

Mine got skipped, any comments?

Personally I think that the first one would work the best.

[halfbreed]

I took a look at your base and i think you achieved your goal. Honestly, i have absolutely no idea how to attack this base. The only thing i think you could fix is:In the compartment with the cannon and the giant bomb, you should switch the gb with the cannon so that hogs won't run past it when they trigger it. good luck with your base

Thx for the input. From what you are saying, it sounds like you are talking about the first design out of the 4, correct? Easy enough fix

[Awesomisticality]

Thx for the input. From what you are saying, it sounds like you are talking about the first design out of the 4, correct? Easy enough fix

Yup

These 10 chars are invisible

[Awesomisticality]

Thx for the input. From what you are saying, it sounds like you are talking about the first design out of the 4, correct? Easy enough fix

Also, on the third one;the funnel between the cannon and the archer tower at the bottom and top.
Giants would rather attack the wall right next to it to busting into the section with the wiz tower rather than go around and hit the spring trap
Hope this makes sense

[halfbreed]

Also, on the third one;the funnel between the cannon and the archer tower at the bottom and top.
Giants would rather attack the wall right next to it to busting into the section with the wiz tower rather than go around and hit the spring trap
Hope this makes sense

Yeah, no worries, makes perfect sense. I haven't had enough wall until now to mess with funneling tactics over long distances between non-walled defenses, so I wasn't sure if that would happen or not. I guess I could swap the wiz towers with gold storages if I wanted it to work.

Anyway, sounds like you guys like the first one. I'll probably go with that one to start with, but then maybe try one of the others for a week or so to see how they perform.

[nathannathan1232]

[IMG][/IMG]
Where would you guys attack from? also what would you switch? thx!

I use barch, so I'd attack where the elixir is (bottom left of top right)

I might consider switching the WTs with the ADs
the elixir storages are close together. Moving some where the DE drills are might help

Overall a 9/10

Can I be a volunteer?! I consider myself a good base designer if you know what I'm saying.

You are almost at that 500 post mark! Sorry, but I don't want to break the rules. You are almost there, and when you get there you can definantly join! 😀

Is anyone else here a base design OCD? I just can't stand bad base designs(except when I'm attacking)especially with improper junctions, lol

Lol. I am one of those people.

Bout time this thread gets stickied? Its rocketed in popularity, and its regularly monitored and controlled. Adding a sticky to this will prevent about 90% of any more trash threads just about rating a base, where they can post their post their base in a constructively criticized group here...

That would be nice. I hope it happens. 😀

Wow, i made a huge long PM to send to Nate, but his in box was full...
P.S:My friend used to change his base design more than he changed his underwear(you know who you are...)

Oops! I'm really sorry! It should have auto saved. I will clear my inbox right now.

[nathannathan1232]

Mine got skipped, any comments?

sorry. I have a lot of posts to look at, so a few might get missed. I will look at it though.

For the people that were interested I had to switch the CC and BK with cannons because where they were messing up the giant pathing which really messed the base up, now someone just needs to attack from the th side to make sure it works down there. If anyone can think of a way to make the CC more centralized please let me know, I'm going to see how it works tonight but I'm planning on moving the CC and th between the middle mortar and bottom right wall so it's more in the middle.

I would move the clan castle in. You could put it where the WT is, and move the WT up.
Moving the giant bombs might help. Putting them all together doesn't do much with this kind of base.

overall I'd say its a 8/10, although it's hard to tell.

[nathannathan1232]

I'm about to finish upgrading to TH7, so I've tried to come up with a few slightly unconventional bases that I hope throw off attackers.

First one is more of a traditional vault. If I'm understanding troop AI right, it should usually take 4 wall breaches to get to the creamy center.

this one is good! The core however is a bit big. Overall I'd say its a 8/10
The air bombs are a bit too close together.

The other designs are hard core funneling designs. Not sure how effective they can be at TH7. Seems like they would work well against Giant/Healer, but be quite weak against barch or BAM attacks. Interested to give them a try anyway.

I don't really like this one that much. I'd rate it a 7/10.

Same idea, different core.

A bit better then the last one. It's a 7.5/10

I can also enclose one end of the funnel on each side to encourage WBs to mis-target. Can do this with either funneling design.

It's ok. 7.5/10.

Thoughts?

I put my comments in bold. I like the first one best.

[Boltflare]

Thoughts on this?
Haven't lost more than two gold storages in a single attack(cc level 5 wiz)
Destroyed by hogs though.....
I have improper wall junctions.