Julian's idea for CLAN REWARDS!!!!! DETAILED and IN DEPTH analysis/proposal!!!!!

[cinder013]

Read the title of my post!

[BrainZ]

Oh my god! Best idea I've ever seen in the forums!

[xrumer]

I like this idea a lot.

[Julezwatts]

Read the title of my post!

Thanks! Glad you like it!

Oh my god! Best idea I've ever seen in the forums!

Thanks for your support!

I like this idea a lot.

I'm glad you like it!

This is a really good idea! I like everything about it.

Thanks!

although your idea seems great, and it is!, it should benefit every single player. Kids go to school, their playing time is limited. Parents go to work, their playing time is limited. the only players who will take advantage of this are CoC junkies, people who play all day. imagine kids wanting gems so badly yet they can't because parents limit their playing time to just one hour. it will only cause frustrations. yes, i do have a son and we both play. i think ideas like this are really great but we need to consider a lot of factors involving our playing habits. perhaps we should have this during school summer breaks or xmas season holidays rather than a whole year round promo.

Well, you're often going to have a balance in the clan- if you're in an active clan, you'll generally get active players, where if you're in more of a leisurely clan, you won't have a whole lot of members who are on 24/7.

Again, great idea, but maybe the badges like highest pusher should be determined according to the players trophy record. Someone could drop in trophies before the season ends and then push all the way back up to recieve the reward. I think it'd be better if the award were to be decided according to improvement in trophy record.
A "most upgrades" badge wouldn't really be fair, for low members have a lot more to upgrade and the costs are cheaper. i dont really think there is a way around this issue.
Same with the "richest member title."
A "best recruiter" i think should be an automatic reward given that the system keeps track of how many members the elder or co recruited. It'd be nice if the message that appears in the clan chat said "(members name) was invited by (elder or co's name)". It would really help in the statistics in the best recruiter. Of course to avoid exploitation by a member repeatedly joining and leaving. The reward would only take in members invited that have never been part of the clan.

Well, 'most upgrades' is going to be replaced with 'highest XP', because, while newer members upgrade more, the more expensive/lengthy upgrades yield more XP to higher level players, which allows this to be balanced out. Best recruiter COULD be automatically awarded, but you always get member who are getting their siblings/friends to join whom they didn't actually invite via global. And good suggestion for the highest pusher award- I'll add that in.

[Predator1]

You seem to have forgot what happens when the leader awards 1 reward then takes it of , of a guy and then awards it to another this be abused by some to give gems to everyone?

[Julezwatts]

You seem to have forgot what happens when the leader awards 1 reward then takes it of , of a guy and then awards it to another this be abused by some to give gems to everyone?

This was clarified multiple times: LEADER AWARDED BADGES DO NOT CARRY A GEM REWARD.

[Isaacium]

Great idea! A couple of suggestions:

1. Instead of unlocking multiple rewards at ten people, how about a system where rewards are proportional to the number of people in your clan? Maybe one reward per 10 people?
2. How about one person can only earn one gem award per season? Some rewards could have more gems than others.

[platypusdude]

This is perhaps the best idea I have seen on the forums. Nice job going into detail. The really are no flaws that I can see, keep up the great work!

[Julezwatts]

This is perhaps the best idea I have seen on the forums. Nice job going into detail. The really are no flaws that I can see, keep up the great work!

Thank you for the support!

[Julezwatts]

Thanks for all the support guys!