Julian's idea for CLAN REWARDS!!!!! DETAILED and IN DEPTH analysis/proposal!!!!!

[Nellybelly]

Ok, real feedback coming...

So I like it for 3 reasons.

1. I would win most if not all of the automatically given awards. Free gems!!
2. Help promote the social part of CoC and make it better and more interesting
3. Make clan mates more loyal and better donaters

I think this should be considered by SC as a way to improve the game.

[Julezwatts]

I love this idea! Want to see it and reap the rewards

Thanks! I'm going to add a 'why this would be good' part into section one a little bit later.

its so tempting just to post a 1-star... cuz its a long post lol... but that's unfair...so i'll read it l8r and give it a real rating. nice job with detail doe!

You'd better not...
Anyways, if you don't want to read it, just read the bold text. As I said at the beginning, the bold text carries the main message of the thread.

Nice idea. It would strength the social aspect in clans as well.

Thanks! I hope you'll take a look at the 'why this would help' section (1.3)

[Julezwatts]

Ok, real feedback coming...

So I like it for 3 reasons.

1. I would win most if not all of the automatically given awards. Free gems!!
2. Help promote the social part of CoC and make it better and more interesting
3. Make clan mates more loyal and better donaters

I think this should be considered by SC as a way to improve the game.

Exactly! Nelly gets it. I just added a few sections to part 1. Sections 1.3 and 1.4.

[Julezwatts]

Yes free gems!! I will get them all lol!

Serious feedback later gotta go to class.

Haha. Thanks for the support, and the real feedback.

[Nellybelly]

Haha. Thanks for the support, and the real feedback.

Exactly! Nelly gets it. I just added a few sections to part 1. Sections 1.3 and 1.4.

Your welcome. Although the furst post was more of a bump than anything else. Plus I was trying to say I liked it without typing to much since I was in a hurry.

I though of a way someone could exploit this, they would just need a lot of friends/devices. So they create a clan called Pigs and ten or more friends join and then they take turns getting the gems. Of course you must have a lot of friends/moblie devices to do this.

Which makes me realize that all clans could exploit this by rotating who gets the gems.

If this happens there will be a new type of clan: Awards clan. It is for getting gems and taking advatage of the system.

Not sure how we can fix this, but will need to find a way.

[Julezwatts]

Your welcome. Although the furst post was more of a bump than anything else. Plus I was trying to say I liked it without typing to much since I was in a hurry.

I though of a way someone could exploit this, they would just need a lot of friends/devices. So they create a clan called Pigs and ten or more friends join and then they take turns getting the gems. Of course you must have a lot of friends/moblie devices to do this.

Which makes me realize that all clans could exploit this by rotating who gets the gems.

If this happens there will be a new type of clan: Awards clan. It is for getting gems and taking advatage of the system.

Not sure how we can fix this, but will need to find a way.

I did think about that when making my original post, however, the amount of gems that are available to be won really isn't that much when you take into consideration the amount you are liable to gain from obstacles or achievements, so there really is very little overall risk for the amount of gems available.

[justinhu]

Oh Julez, You've done it again and again

[TheLadyAnne]

This is an awesome idea! It would really add some life back into the daily grind for long time players.
I have one question and a comment.

Question: Would a single member be able to win more than one award? For example, could the highest donator also win best pusher?

Comment: I think people always try to find a exploit "free" gems. Although you have a addressed exploits in your original post, someone has already thought up "award clans." So if for some reason the gem thing didn't work out and they weren't awarded, I still think this idea is golden! I would love to receive some free gems because I was the highest donator but the pretty badge next to name would also make me happy

With or without the gem awards, I totally dig this idea.

[Nellybelly]

I did think about that when making my original post, however, the amount of gems that are available to be won really isn't that much when you take into consideration the amount you are liable to gain from obstacles or achievements, so there really is very little overall risk for the amount of gems available.

Yeah. Wasn't to worried about that. Just wanted to point it out.

Just had a depressing thought...

[Julezwatts]

This is an awesome idea! It would really add some life back into the daily grind for long time players.
I have one question and a comment.

Question: Would a single member be able to win more than one award? For example, could the highest donator also win best pusher?

Comment: I think people always try to find a exploit "free" gems. Although you have a addressed exploits in your original post, someone has already thought up "award clans." So if for some reason the gem thing didn't work out and they weren't awarded, I still think this idea is golden! I would love to receive some free gems because I was the highest donator but the pretty badge next to name would also make me happy

With or without the gem awards, I totally dig this idea.

I have updated the FAQ section, and it answers your question.

Yeah. Wasn't to worried about that. Just wanted to point it out.

Just had a depressing thought...

Just a note:
I have updated the FAQ section (2.4) which now contains the answers to questions that I have been asked. Please see the FAQ's before posting a question.