Clan cool down for joining too many clans

[Def4ultpl4y3r]

suggestion since some players in clan war leave they clan then join to your clan to be a spy for the clan war, i suggested to put 24hrs ban to those players leaving they clan before can join in another clan.

and also some players join the clan then after clan war searching they leave again. i know almost all clan leaders experiencing this kind of problem.

How about there be a system where you can't join an enemy clan whilst the war is taking place instead of banning people because supercell hasn't full-proofed the system so people will find a way to exploit the game to get an easier win.

[blazeaxel]

A similar post has been posted here: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...t=Leaving+clan
Many people have opposed it, and you will see why.

[Tollboothwillie]

How about the leadership that allowed the opponent into their clan gets banned for 24 hrs. After all it is leaderships responsibility to keep your clan secure.

[vansimon]

If a clan spies on another clan, that’s what they do.. and leaders should check clan history to see if suitable. Of course I know some players from friendly clans do the spying and chat via external chats. So, not always possible to prevent.
I don’t think players can be banned for spying.... and certainly not for just leaving a clan.

[hosein11]

supercel must make advance setting in clans setting to help leaders and coleaders make clan safe .

[Tollboothwillie]

supercel must make advance setting in clans setting to help leaders and coleaders make clan safe .

How more advanced? You already can close or invite only your clan, how much more is needed?

Again this is where your leadership needs to do their job or else not be in a leadership position.

[Gorf]

Hmmm. I dont see a button that shows the incoming spy’s clan history... other than closing the clan I dont know what else the leadership can do. Maybe Tollbooth can elaborate since he seems to have solved this issue???

[Ajax]

Hmmm. I dont see a button that shows the incoming spy’s clan history... other than closing the clan I dont know what else the leadership can do. Maybe Tollbooth can elaborate since he seems to have solved this issue???

You have to go to an external site such as clashofstats for that (which uses the official Clash of Clans API to get the data).

Or if you are competent enough as a coder, you could write a script yourself which would return the history from the API from any given player tag. I don't imagine many will take this option

[JD4U]

Hmmm. I dont see a button that shows the incoming spy’s clan history... other than closing the clan I dont know what else the leadership can do. Maybe Tollbooth can elaborate since he seems to have solved this issue???

What’s to elaborate? Tollbooth’s clan has solved it. Dozens of clans I have been in have solved it. Tens of thousands of clans have solved it. Stop clan exit/entrance by closing the clan. Send invites to accounts that need to enter. It is a few keystrokes to a toggle switch.

There are websites that will give an accounts history. Clash of stats or something like that will let you look up a player. What a lot of work to check each of a dozen new incoming players?

Or I could have zero if I just close the clan.

You want a button link to clash of stats? You want COC to maintain a clash of stats database and provide that info to players?

Banning suggestions cause problems (see thread above); a very easy solution exists to the issue that started this thread.

Edit: sorry Ajax. I was typing and missed your better response.
Edit part 2. I apologize if I mis-read sarcasm in the post I quoted. The triple ‘???’ gave me impression. I responded harsher than I should have.

[JD4U]

How about there be a system where you can't join an enemy clan whilst the war is taking place instead of banning people because supercell hasn't full-proofed the system so people will find a way to exploit the game to get an easier win.

This might be a good idea. I suspect it is rare clans visit to chat during war and could easily wait until the war is over if they are inclined to be so friendly.