The ‘recruitment tool’: what is happening under the hood?

[Ajax]

Why isn’t possible to return a kind of old global chat?
Why isn’t possible to release a internal chat with friends or a private chat?
There are some a good solutions for this.

In CLASHLAND channel says a different global chat for us. If is true, it’s a good news for us.

It is not true.

There are no "good solutions" for the issues that caused the closure of global.

[DarthPez]

Global Chat will not be returning. Asking for it over and over again will not bring it back. Creating an internal/private chat would defeat one of the main reasons why we removed it in the first place. We really don't want to have to deal with reports of people getting private messages of "are you female? Do you want a bf?" or scams of "do you want a free TH13?"

Ok Global Is Not going to return.
When will the recruitment systyem be fixed?
How long is the leaning curve on this system? ( it has been 5 months. How many more months
Does SuperCell think this is working as advertised?
When the learning curve is done, do we think the system will provide plenty of recruits?
What is the goal of this system?

[ClasherAK47]

Ok Global Is Not going to return.
When will the recruitment systyem be fixed?
How long is the leaning curve on this system? ( it has been 5 months. How many more months
Does SuperCell think this is working as advertised?
When the learning curve is done, do we think the system will provide plenty of recruits?
What is the goal of this system?

Nobody knows
Nobody knows
My wild guess here is yes its working as SC expected it to work, its still learning or trying to learn
Nobody knows
When this tool was announced back in october they said "Better Players, better Clashing"

[bostone]

Global Chat will not be returning. Asking for it over and over again will not bring it back. Creating an internal/private chat would defeat one of the main reasons why we removed it in the first place. We really don't want to have to deal with reports of people getting private messages of "are you female? Do you want a bf?" or scams of "do you want a free TH13?"

It got removed due to policing issues? I'm just curious, how hard is it to hand our permanent bans to obscene or fraudulent chatters? Also, how hard would it be to implement a global chat for say th9s and higher? That would mean less spam accounts on global and the ones that do cause an incident would never be back again.

You guys have to do something though, clans are dying. I'm witnessing this 1st hand.. I will give u links to 2 of to prove it if u dont believe me. 2 clans, combined 1100 wins, down to drain because of this nonsense. This removal of global feels like a noose tightening around clash of clans neck. The lack of urgency to improve the useless recruitment tool isnt helping anything either.

[toofinedog]

Global Chat will not be returning. Asking for it over and over again will not bring it back. Creating an internal/private chat would defeat one of the main reasons why we removed it in the first place. We really don't want to have to deal with reports of people getting private messages of "are you female? Do you want a bf?" or scams of "do you want a free TH13?"

Why do people continue to ask about Global? You’ve got yet another and fairly recent official comment right here. Is the lack of a chat leading to the death of clans? No, but I’m sure people’s defeatist attitudes about it being gone doesn’t really help. The intent seems be be focused on making the current tool better. Yes, it’s pretty horrible in my opinion, but be optimistic about the future of the game instead of hinging its destiny on a removed, toxic chat. Clash Royale has a pretty good system for finding new members, and there is no chat external from clans. I don’t recall if it was suggested here or in the QOL thread, but *I* think the tool should have dynamic tags “advertising” the clan in clan search based on total donations and/or frequency of war, etc. If a dynamic tag system were to be applied to the Clash of Clans recruitment tool for clans AND players instead of the current “choose your own” tags that don’t currently seem to work, I think that would be a significant improvement. Does that mean clans won’t invite players whose dynamic tags don’t indicate activity? Yes, but that’s how it should be. I don’t want to invite inactive people, and those people still have the option to seek out a clan that suits them on their own.

[Zera041]

Personally (personally is key) I (TH13) started rebuilding a level 5 clan this January and with the help of my friend (TH11) who isn’t incredibly active but is loyal we filled our clan with 50 loyal active members in about a week with the tool. Now we are doing very well, with a solid leadership team (some of my friends list did indeed have problems in their clans as their clans were dying out, perhaps due to the failure of the tool) and great members ranging from TH8-13. I just invited those who had a fair amount of attacks won this season and weren’t super rushed. When starting the clan, I noticed most of my invites were successful I.e the tool was working but now that we are “established” most of my invites seem to pass into the void haha. Very strange plateau. Nonetheless, I’d say that the tool worked for us. It may be because I’m a shiny TH13, idk. But I doubt that was the sole reason

[toofinedog]

Personally (personally is key) I (TH13) started rebuilding a level 5 clan this January and with the help of my friend (TH11) who isn’t incredibly active but is loyal we filled our clan with 50 loyal active members in about a week with the tool. Now we are doing very well, with a solid leadership team (some of my friends list did indeed have problems in their clans as their clans were dying out, perhaps due to the failure of the tool) and great members ranging from TH8-13. I just invited those who had a fair amount of attacks won this season and weren’t super rushed. When starting the clan, I noticed most of my invites were successful I.e the tool was working but now that we are “established” most of my invites seem to pass into the void haha. Very strange plateau. Nonetheless, I’d say that the tool worked for us. It may be because I’m a shiny TH13, idk. But I doubt that was the sole reason

That’s an awesome success story. I think if I “lowered my standards”, I’d have success, but I simply don’t want to. I don’t want to settle for players with low Heroes, because high Heroes are indicative of everything being decent in my experience. That’s not the only thing I look at, but it is one of the first things, and I’d like to be able to filter by Hero level to make the process easier for me.

[ClasherAK47]

I noticed most of my invites were successful I.e the tool was working but now that we are “established” most of my invites seem to pass into the void haha. Very strange plateau. Nonetheless, I’d say that the tool worked for us. It may be because I’m a shiny TH13, idk. But I doubt that was the sole reason

Congratulations on getting your clan stable using the tool, but do not expect anything from the tool now because in your own words "most of my invites seem to pass into the void"

I am trying to recruit from my main account sitting in legends Level 232 (i know it doesn't mean anything but still), 2007 war stars and FiN 520,827 yet all my invites are not as fruitful as yours.

[DarthPat]

If they would just remove players with full inboxes from search, it would be a start. So frustrating to spend so much time looking for a good match for our clan, only to receive full inbox message...

I even get search results including presumably banned players...

[ClasherAK47]

If they would just remove players with full inboxes from search, it would be a start. So frustrating to spend so much time looking for a good match for our clan, only to receive full inbox message...

I even get search results including presumably banned players...

System is still learning that's why.......

/sarcasm