My idea for clan wars! (With pictures for a better guide) (Please read)

[clasher2000]

Good idea i wouldnt change everything unless the thing with the 2 days cooldown. Clans could attack clans all they want when they finish a war but they gems for wining would be given every 2-4 days when you win. For example ''lietuviai'' wins and gets 25 gems and 2 days alter they win and then get 25 gems every 2-4 days.

[Ollyhicks]

​sounds quite good I think in some form, clan wars should be brought in soon.

[InfinityGamesMSF]

Only clan leaders should accept war messages. Why? Cause he/she is the leader deciding whether to take his members to battle. It's like ur own village your troops wait for you to deploy them and pick the battle the troops don't pick a random battle.
I feel as if you should have atleast 10 members. Why cause you could have any amount of troops when you start a battle in clash.
Also you should be able to attack anyone. Why cause it's the leaders responsibility to choose a good war. But there should be an option to filter who requests to war with you

Also think of clan wars a bit more realistically. For example I live in USA and am a citizen (kinda like elder) but I can't declare war with other countries. The president or leader should make the decision to war and also should be responsible enough to pick a war they could handle. And USA could have 100 members (not true) and Canada may have 150 (not true either) but USA may still be able to win. (Not sayin they would or wouldn't plz no hate cause I picked Canada

[boombadaboom]

The only problem I have with is the match system because of people who abuse the trophy leagues (farmers) and high town hall people that don't donate because them a town hall 9 who never donates could be paired up with somebody with a town hall 6 who always donates. I think this matching system would be better if it was paired up according to town hall lvl because even if you are a town hall rusher (somebody who upgrades town halls before all else) you still had a chance to upgrade further whereas the town hall 6 never had a chance.
Good idea though; very discriptive and great for light reading :-)

[ty1014]

I think leaders and co-leaders can declare and accept when they want, but elders should have it differently. I Think that if a leader can not decide whether to accept the war or not, he can put it up for a vote. Only elder may vote for the war or not.

[101112131415]

I know that this was thought up a while ago but shouldn't it be co leaders and leaders that can accept or request a clan war



great idea well thought out

[101112131415]

I think leaders and co-leaders can declare and accept when they want, but elders should have it differently. I Think that if a leader can not decide whether to accept the war or not, he can put it up for a vote. Only elder may vote for the war or not.

Sorry didnt see your message lol

[pastahaha]

Q

Over the past weeks, I have been planning an idea for clan wars, and I finally got my thoughts and ideas on it. So I thought it would be nice to share it to you guys

Okay, I'll start. I have seen many clan wars ideas out there, some are good and some are not so good. I wanted to make my own version of how clan wars would work and this is how it turned it.

The introduction and beginning of starting a war-
-The beginning of idea my idea would be on how to start a clan war, and here are my results

Note! - The text I highlighted in red is IMPORTANT, please read those parts. If you complain about a component you don't see because you didn't read, than that's your fault

Of course you can still make suggestions for the things highlighted in red.

-Things highlighted in green were suggested in the replies below

Starting a war!


With this new clan wars update, this is how the button might look like. I'm not a pro at editing, so Supercell and decide on how they design it. But this would be a way it won't distract anything in your screen and you'll be able to get a clear view of your village without distraction of that new button. Tell me if it's too big or if it overwhelmes your screen in your opinion.
So, lets click on the button!

Read this part highlighted in red, it's important!
Note - ONLY clan leaders and elders and declare a possible war. Members will not be able to do this, and this is from the perspective of my clan leader

Okay, so there's many things that are happening here. Before you start a war. You can have the option to chose a random clan OR you can search any clan you may want to attack

But, If the clan is currently on a war, than you WILL NOT be able to declare war on that clan until the season is over.
-The "Declare war" buttons that are highlighted in gray will show that that clan is already under war
-The buttons in red will signify that that clan is open to request a war

-You cannot request a war with a clan that has more than 250 trophy difference

The reason the the picture above me has a huge clan trophy difference, this is because it is ONLY an example

The reason you'll see my clan here being much lower is because it is just an example

-You clan MUST have 40 or more people to be able to start a clan war

• With that you must have at least 10 elders in your clan

Note- Seasons are only 2 weeks, but can be shorter depending on how fast the war ends, which I'll explain further on when the battles starts

Clan war requests-


Note - If someone requests to start a war, the war WILL NOT start right away. The other clan has to accept your request. If they decline, then you're not fighting with them.

ONLY leaders or elders can accept this war. Like I said. Members will not have the resposibility to start a war. If members had the privilage, then it would be easily abused, so I'm not gonna allow that

Please leave feedback if I should change this or not

This is what the messages would say if they requests are either accepted or rejected


If they accept


As you can see here, the clan I requested for example "Quamtam's rage" has accepted your war request, now you MUST confirm the message before the war starts. This alert WILL NOT be timed, so the leader or elders can have enough time to confirm it or not. You'll also get a notification on the clan wars section so elders and leaders can be notified easily

As I said again, this notification wont be timed, so any elder or leader has enough time to accept it or decline it.


This is if they reject


If they reject, than you have to find another clan to battle with, because they rejected and made their decision. There is no turning back at this.

Also if a clan rejects a war, there would be a 5 day cool down before you cant request again, so that clans wont spam other clans with requests
(Tell me if I should change this)


Now lets go back to the perspective if they were to accept your request



PLEASE READ THIS PART, IT IS IMPORTANT
If they do accept, you'll see a notification in the clan wars section. When you click the button. It'll bring you to this page. Now the war has officially started and here's how it would work

Attacking system
-There would be a system earlier where I explained that clans cannot go to war together with more than a 250 trophy point difference, this would avoid the abuse of lower lvl clans being destroyed!

Important! - When you are attacking a player from another clan, you cannot randomly tchoose a player you wanna attack. This would lead to the abuse of higher lvl bases destroying lower lvl bases with ease.

Important! - When a new members joins a clan that is ALREADY in a war, the WILL NOT be able to participate in that current clan war. This would avoid the abuse of making clans loose because members will just screw their war up (Hoppers). If a members joins a clan while at war, he has to wait UNTIL the next war season. The same thing will happen if someone leaves a clan and rejoins. All members are required to stay in their clan to participate in the war.

So this is how the attacking system works, you can only attack a player that is 5 lvls within your village lvl, so the system can be fair!
(Tell me if I should change this)

Edit! - Someone just suggested this, and I think it's a very good suggestion. The current issue was "What if there's no one in the 5 lvl range in you, does that mean that on one can attack you?"
This is what will happen, if there is no one within the 5 lvl range of you, you will be able to pick the person CLOSET to you, whether it's 6 lvls apart or 30 lvls apart
(Let me know if I should change this)

Read this next part below you, it's important!

-When the clans are now at war, one person will attack another player from a clan
Next, when the player gets attacked, he or she WILL have to revenge the person that attacked him.
But, this is how they get out of a war. The results will be looked at upon from the attack and revenge and the player with the WORST results will be OUT

This is what I mean
-Let you get attacked and you get three starred, now you will revenge the player, BUT, lets say that you lost the revenge.
This means that you got the worst results from the match, and you will be out!
-But, if you were the one that got the better results from the attack and revenge, then you will stay in. The person that got the worse results will be out.

Here's an example -
Lets say that I attack "Darwin" From Quantom's web (Example)

#1 - I attack Darwin and I lost the battle, I only got 35% damage in total (I did not get one star, I lost)

#2 - Darwin will log back on to see that I attacked him, now HE WILL have to revenge me, so let's say he did.

#3 - Darwin revenges me and he almost Three stars me, he gets 97% and almost completely destroyed me.

#4 - After the revenge and attack are over, the system will look over who got the better results

And the player with the worst results, which is me, will be out (Eliminated from the war)

This is how it would work everytime someone attacks you, and people will start getting eliminated (out) of the war.


Important! - There could be a possible issue of inactives, in where they get attacked and they cant revenge since they aren't simply active anymore.
The idea would be to add a 24 hour limit, in which once the defendant does not revenge the attacker in 24 hours, the win will be automatically be given to the attacker while the inactive is out! This way there would be no left out with missing revenges
(Let me know if I should change this)

Note - If you are out, then you cant participate in the war for the rest of the season. You will only be able to attack normally (From normal match - making)

Who will win??

-The first clan with all the people out loses and the one with remaining players will win.

Offline and online - Someone requested this below and I thought it be good to add it. What he basically suggested was to be able to attack players that were online as well. But here's the catch, if you attack someone that is online, you can take NO resources. If you attack an offline player, than you'll get the resources of a normal attack

(Let me know if I should change this ^^^)

Again, a clan war season lasts two weeks, but it can be much shorter depending on the time it take to defeat one clan
(Tell me if I should change this)

Let me show you a defense as an example


This is ONLY an example, no one attacked me from "Quantam's web" lol
Here is an example of me winning a defense.

-This would mean that I would have the option to revenge him now
-Lets say I get three stars on revenge, so who is out?
"THE PLAYER WHO ATTACKED ME"

Note - Clan wars can last up to a few hours or up to the entire two weeks, depending on how active they are
-Again, clans must have 40+ people to participate in a clan war.

Final results


Like I mentioned, the first clan to get all it's people out loses. The clan with remaining players wins

There would be a small reward on the winning clan - Each member will only get 25 gems

What will the losing clan get? NOTHING

Thanks for reading this and please leave feedback if I should change anything, thank you!

Note- Once a war ends, you have to wait 2 days before you can join another war, this can prevent the farming of gems.
Tell me if I should change this though

The end.....

-Some suggestions that were already said, these suggestions I have thought over and might be adding them onto the idea in the future. It has to depend if more people agree with these suggestions or not.

Suggestion - 50 gems might be too much, consider that because supercell won't be happy to give out that much gems

My thought - I thought over this, and I confirmed to change it to 20 gems, you were right about this part, supercell probably won't be happy to give out that much gems, so thanks for telling me




Suggestion - One thing that could be abused is clans destroying low lvl clans when the request

My answer - I also thought over this, and I changed it that you cannot go into a clan war with more than a 500 clan trophy difference (Total clan points). 500 is enough IMO




Suggestion - Clans can drop trophies and farm easy gems after they win a clan war, something might have to be done about this

My answer - This is why I introduced the cooldown before having to start another war. When a war ends, there would be a two day cooldown before you can request for another war. This might avoid the possible farming of gems for winning a defense




Suggestion - The accepting and declining after a clan accepts a war is not necessary, since you already requested to go into war with them and they accept, this won't really do anything in the game

My answer - Hmmmm, this may be a good point. The reason I added though is to really confirm that you want to go into battle with them, but "confuzed" does have a good point here though



Suggestion - Attacking should work like match - making instead of choosing a specific person you wanna attack

My answer - This might be a good point, but the reason I like the current idea is because since this is a clan war, people should have the right to choose who the wanna attack, of course, they are ONLY allowed to attack people within a 5 lvl range. This would avoid lower lvl bases being creamed by higher lvl ones
Overall again, "Confuzed" has a good thought, and I am thinking over on if I should add it. I might need more people's opionions though

So this is a great idea. but I have some modifications. firstly, there should be a clan wars page ( leader only) and then there you can select the clan you can war with which is in your trophy range, with maximum 500 more or less trophies than your clan. Next, co leaders should not be allowed to decide, but add a shortlist. in the war, players from both sides can attack eachother anyhow, but then whenever smn is destroyed there shud be a war page which shows alive and smahed bases! Keep it up, and how do you start a thread?

[Saltin]

Wouldn't say gems for the reward!

Thanks for the suggestion alasdair!
You think 20 gems is still too much? IMO I think that amount is fine, not to much or not to little
I'll let you guys think on this, should it be gems like currently or should it be a small reward of elixir, gold, and DE?
Thanks for the imput!

You have done some work there.
Nice.
Why the hell i posted ''nice''?
Idk.
Post done.

Haha thanks Ranmange
Or was it?

I don't think that you should half to accept a war. In real life if some body starts a war, the other person cannot decline it like a cellphone call. You should be able to declare war and not wait for a response. Other wise it might take FOREVER to start a war.

Great thought there Geogalaxy
I actually thought at first that this wouldn't be too much of a problem, but now it looks like it could cause problems.
I'll be sure to add what you said later
PS - I'm writing all of this right before school lol

Good idea i wouldnt change everything unless the thing with the 2 days cooldown. Clans could attack clans all they want when they finish a war but they gems for wining would be given every 2-4 days when you win. For example ''lietuviai'' wins and gets 25 gems and 2 days alter they win and then get 25 gems every 2-4 days.

​sounds quite good I think in some form, clan wars should be brought in soon.

Thanks for the support!

Only clan leaders should accept war messages. Why? Cause he/she is the leader deciding whether to take his members to battle. It's like ur own village your troops wait for you to deploy them and pick the battle the troops don't pick a random battle.
I feel as if you should have atleast 10 members. Why cause you could have any amount of troops when you start a battle in clash.
Also you should be able to attack anyone. Why cause it's the leaders responsibility to choose a good war. But there should be an option to filter who requests to war with you

Also think of clan wars a bit more realistically. For example I live in USA and am a citizen (kinda like elder) but I can't declare war with other countries. The president or leader should make the decision to war and also should be responsible enough to pick a war they could handle. And USA could have 100 members (not true) and Canada may have 150 (not true either) but USA may still be able to win. (Not sayin they would or wouldn't plz no hate cause I picked Canada

Excellent thoughts here infinityGames!
All of these are very good suggestions you have made, and I'll reconsider what I have wrote in the OP to make sure if I can add something you have said in the post. Thanks!

The only problem I have with is the match system because of people who abuse the trophy leagues (farmers) and high town hall people that don't donate because them a town hall 9 who never donates could be paired up with somebody with a town hall 6 who always donates. I think this matching system would be better if it was paired up according to town hall lvl because even if you are a town hall rusher (somebody who upgrades town halls before all else) you still had a chance to upgrade further whereas the town hall 6 never had a chance.
Good idea though; very discriptive and great for light reading :-)

Yeah this has been a problem before and can be definitely a problem
A maxed TH 9 clan can all drop trophies like you said all the way to lets say 800, then wreck a low lvl clan and win very fast.
This is one of the ones that I've had the most trouble thinking on, and I'll be sure to think bout it in the future
Thanks for the support!

I think leaders and co-leaders can declare and accept when they want, but elders should have it differently. I Think that if a leader can not decide whether to accept the war or not, he can put it up for a vote. Only elder may vote for the war or not.

That is a great suggestion! I really like the voting feature you mentioned, so elders cannot just acceot a war the battle starts right away
This is one of my favorite suggestions, and since I'm in class right now, I cannot add it too the OP because it's almost time to transition lol
I'll be sure to add it whilst at home
Thanks for the imput!

I know that this was thought up a while ago but shouldn't it be co leaders and leaders that can accept or request a clan war
great idea well thought out

This is a very good suggestion 1011112131415!
The only problem we may have with this and the reason I didnt add it to the OP is because leaders can go inactive, and after you find out, there is no more leader ship in that clan
Co - Leaders can be very active though, because they were given co leader through loyalty and this in the first place.
I do understand that elders accepting might be a little dangerous in some cases, elders you cannot trust can accept or reject a war without having any talk with the rest of clan.
What do you guys think about this, should it be elders too or only co leaders and leaders?
Thanks for the imput!

Sorry didnt see your message lol

lol it's a'll good

Q So this is a great idea. but I have some modifications. firstly, there should be a clan wars page ( leader only) and then there you can select the clan you can war with which is in your trophy range, with maximum 500 more or less trophies than your clan. Next, co leaders should not be allowed to decide, but add a shortlist. in the war, players from both sides can attack eachother anyhow, but then whenever smn is destroyed there shud be a war page which shows alive and smahed bases! Keep it up, and how do you start a thread?

Great suggestions here pastahaha!
I'll be looking over these suggestions to see if I can add one to the OP
Thanks for the imput!
PS - To start a thread, you go to the sub forum you desire to put your thread in (Make sure it's the correct sub forum), when you go to that sub forum, scroll down to the bottom and there should be a button called
"Create new thread"
Hope that helps

[Nellybelly]

Was reading this cause I was bored and I noticed something:

With that you must have at least 10 elders in your clan

Why? I don't get why this is needed. Please explain.

Otherwise I still like the idea.