My idea for clan wars! (With pictures for a better guide) (Please read)

[Saltin]

First, I would like to say that I love this idea. There is only one thing that I think it could improve on.

I was thinking that once this gets implemented, that every clan should get FIFTY clan war Points.
And it should cost TWENTY FIVE clan war points to declare war on a clan. (Only the Requesting clan should have top pay the Twenty Five Clan points. The clan that accepts the request should only have to pay a fee of TEN clan points)

Given the exception that the clan denies the clan war request, no clan war points will be spent.

---

These are all of my current thoughts that could improve the matter. Thank you for reading.

~Marbs

Hi Marbles Thank you for your feedback and for also suggesting an idea for my thread, it's an interesting idea,
But, there's one huge concern though, What happens if your clan war points run out?? Does that mean that you won't be able to go into wars anymore??? If that's the case, then unfortunately that's not the best idea out there. Players will probably get angry because all their fun is over, they were only able to go into wars only 2 to 3 times. Is the there any way that you can earn clan war points. Please give me more detail on this idea and again thank you for suggesting an idea!

[Marbles0923]

Okay, thank you for the feedback on my idea. I had not considered that yet.
One thing that could definitely be useful if (Yes) they could earn Clan War points in yet another way than winning Clan Wars. I think that a Member-Leader could donate 100,000 Gold/Elixir for one Clan war Point. They could also donate 10,000 Dark Elixir for possibly 10 Clan War points. It is a long process, but it could definitely create a "Twist" to the game.
As I do think that Clan Wars would be a FANTASTIC idea, this could make it something to work for, instead of just being able to ask someone to go to war. Because I know that many people will be eager to go to war with another clan, and with this included, they can work for it. And I am sure that trading in Resources for Clan War points would be a main goal for many Clan Members.
Thank you for the consideration of my idea.
~Marbs

[BluStar]

What if they decline? Do you get the 25 points back?Just curious.

[BluStar]

Okay, thank you for the feedback on my idea. I had not considered that yet.
One thing that could definitely be useful if (Yes) they could earn Clan War points in yet another way than winning Clan Wars. I think that a Member-Leader could donate 100,000 Gold/Elixir for one Clan war Point. They could also donate 10,000 Dark Elixir for possibly 10 Clan War points. It is a long process, but it could definitely create a "Twist" to the game.
As I do think that Clan Wars would be a FANTASTIC idea, this could make it something to work for, instead of just being able to ask someone to go to war. Because I know that many people will be eager to go to war with another clan, and with this included, they can work for it. And I am sure that trading in Resources for Clan War points would be a main goal for many Clan Members.
Thank you for the consideration of my idea.
~Marbs

Maybe change that to every 1000 donations (as a whole clan) you get 15 points?
Because i think your way is a bit exspensive.

[Marbles0923]

It is supposed to be expensive...
The more expensive, the more dedicated you are while working towards it!

[RomanKing]

Hey Saltin if you would like to check out my clan wars idea to add more stuff, go ahead, its in my sig.!

Confuzed1,seeing that your really passionate about this, take a look at mine, and try to find any loopholes

[Saltin]

Hey Saltin if you would like to check out my clan wars idea to add more stuff, go ahead, its in my sig.!

Confuzed1,seeing that your really passionate about this, take a look at mine, and try to find any loopholes

Lol I already read it, it was before I made an account so I couldn't reply
But I'll go there to share my thoughts about your idea

[TheGreatKing]

I love it! Awesome idea!

[JSpong]

This is my first time looking over a clan wars thread, based on the date I assume there are many more threads out there, but alas; I very much approve of a lot of the matchmaking concepts, but let me put in my opinion.

In regards to the actual matchmaking search, it cannot be based on trophies simply because it is not an accurate form of comparing strength and ability. Elite farming clans would destroy some other clan in their trophy range full of players who don't quite completely understand the concept of the game, yet. I VERY much approve of the attack delays, thus negating any chance of gem abuse, however, being offline and shields should not take in effect. ie: Clan full of gemmers all manage several attacks while online, all players buy a two day-week shield. Now this is very extreme, obviously, but I almost guarantee this would happen eventually and it would mean a cheap easy win. I honestly believe the best form of attacking, like I said, is to not have shield or online barriers, but more so based on attacks per x hours. ie: Each player in a clan can do up to 5 attacks per 12 hours, thus making the attacking completely equal. The only advantage in this case would be a slightly more active clan taking the upper hand, but that is quite fair.

In regards to the actual clan matchmaking, perhaps on top of the overall trophy range, there should be town hall statistics kept in check, as in clan A with 30 th 10s, 15 th 9s, 5 th 8s cannot attack clan B who have the same amount of trophies with 45 th 7s. Now, of course the accept/decline option takes all of the matchmaking issues into reality, I feel a lot of disinterested clans may waste players times by just declining everything. Once a clan makes a certain decision to war on another, that clan should have to accept within x amount of hours, otherwise the clan will be thrown into war regardless.


Lastly, an option for clans to do several wars if they wish and the ability to turn off wars altogether if the clan approves.

I posted this in a similar clan wars thread so I figured I may as well repost my ideas here. All of what I said basically still applies but I also like your idea of having to revenge the players who already attacked you.

[Saltin]

I love it! Awesome idea!

Thank you for the support!