February 2019 - Clan War Leagues Top 10 Ranking List

[SirNeoGeo]

We are talking about Champs 1 with max TH12s though.

I think the base layout can still come into play in some cases. The 1% 0 at star may be a better chance to 3 star than the new base that is one rank higher. Rank doesn't really matter if the bases are both truly maxed so it is just a layout difference. The 20% 1 star probably would not make as much sense to hit in Champs 1, but could still be a layout decision if the attacker thinks he can 3 star the 1 star base vs a possible 1 star vs the new base. Also once a base has been hit the clan castle troops and traps can be somewhat revealed.

[SirNeoGeo]

Looks like only 2 repeats from last top 10 (5 & 8). So can we add them to the overall combined top 10.

[ayih]

This top 10 list has been a dumpster fire.

For years, we've used total stars to select which clan did a better job. Then they added % destruction as a tie breaker.

In the scwl, a clan is rated based on total stars. How many stars you get determines where you are next season.

Yet the last list was based on "net stars" and this list is based on "wins". Is this an official list? Or is this list a pet project of darian to pick what he thinks is the top 10? Can we expect the same level of inconsistency and "wheel reinventing" for the scwl tournament? Like dang.....this is seriously some biased unprofessional looking lists.

Well that's my feedback. I don't plan on looking at another 1 of these lists any time soon. Players trying to kick a field goal while the stadium moves the goal post while the balls in the air.

[sentiblue]

I think total star count is a very easy and indisputable metric to measure the championship guys.

With win counts, each CLW has a maximum of 105 wins and 315 stars.
With wins count as a determining factor, it's quite easy for legend league to get 105 wins. But here we don't show the number of wins, it has to go with star count.

Thing is... the top clan's star count is nothing compared to my clan. Yet we are no where near the top10 list.

[Rajputro]

Ranking clans based on wins and using stars then percentage to tie break is the right way.

Let’s hope same is applied to CWL winner determinations, should also remove the extra 10 stars per win.

[OnyxDS]

I think total star count is a very easy and indisputable metric to measure the championship guys.

With win counts, each CLW has a maximum of 105 wins and 315 stars.
With wins count as a determining factor, it's quite easy for legend league to get 105 wins. But here we don't show the number of wins, it has to go with star count.

Thing is... the top clan's star count is nothing compared to my clan. Yet we are no where near the top10 list.

You've worked this out wrong. The total stars in the list does NOT include the 10 for winning a war.

And total star count isn't used by itself because a few clans didn't try, and gave away 45-0 victories. Their opponents would have too big an advantage if it was just done by stars

[GlisteningViper]

Well at 235 total, thats 2.25 stars per hit, or 3 starring 1 in every 4 bases fresh.
Pretty decent

Still waiting for @onyxds to post the entire list so i can review.

[BlazeStormz123]

This top 10 list has been a dumpster fire.

For years, we've used total stars to select which clan did a better job. Then they added % destruction as a tie breaker.

In the scwl, a clan is rated based on total stars. How many stars you get determines where you are next season.

Yet the last list was based on "net stars" and this list is based on "wins". Is this an official list? Or is this list a pet project of darian to pick what he thinks is the top 10? Can we expect the same level of inconsistency and "wheel reinventing" for the scwl tournament? Like dang.....this is seriously some biased unprofessional looking lists.

Well that's my feedback. I don't plan on looking at another 1 of these lists any time soon. Players trying to kick a field goal while the stadium moves the goal post while the balls in the air.

Agree. Since the matches are random, we don't know which clans got easy matchups, which ones got tough ones. With more and more clans joining champs1 this problem is just going to rise. Dark Looters faced a th11 in their first war. Tbh this top 10 list doesn't really represent the correct top 10. The proper method will be like the one used in real CWL with league and knockout tournaments.

[raja1]

You've worked this out wrong. The total stars in the list does NOT include the 10 for winning a war.

And total star count isn't used by itself because a few clans didn't try, and gave away 45-0 victories. Their opponents would have too big an advantage if it was just done by stars

It took supercell so much time to add wins as first criterion. Although, it is still not fair for groups with lesser number of clans. They should take average stars instead of total stars.

Hopefully they will add this during regular cwl also. Second tiebreaker in regular cwl should be the result of match between two tied clans. I feel this bonus 10 star system is just bogus and easy to be manipulate.

[zxparesh3]

Is this list for only Champions League? Or this is across all leagues?