Announcing Town Hall level 12 - This time the Town Hall strikes back!

[oldsalt1981]

Given your current location 'Next to Schrödinger's cat' It is impossible to say whether you are dead or alive and therefore whether your complaint matters or not.

I reply, therefore I am.

[ElfLiya]

some content to the YouTubers ? And apart from these leakes is there anything else that we would see in the next update?

if they do it's because to give youtubers time to crate that video. then make the video public once supercell revealed it. even if they know more then the public they won't betray supercell and their partnership with supercell.

[mcleo]

How can it promote engineering ( emphasis being on the word promote) ?

In TH9 you can choose not to build Xbows for example
In TH10 you can choose not to build infernos
In TH11 you can choose not to build the eagle
In TH12 you canNOT choose not to build the new weapon, you have to build the basic weapon level.

So let me ask again how can it promote engineering ?
Personally I think it will help against engineering somewhat, sure chances are it won’t magically completely solve it either however promote engineering, that sounds a bit odd to me. (Emphasis somewhat)

PS this pure speculation on my part based on what we know so far.

unless it will be required to have all previous th lvl defenses (IT, XBows, etc) the launch of th12 will result in more engineering. Seriously, it all of the sudden makes sense to build a defenseless village all the way through th12, get all your iffense max and be able to demolish all your enemy bases weighing as a th10 or th11, lol, and your opponent maxing everything doesnt stand a chance when your th12 goes BOOM. And you seriously ask why people are concerned about engineering?
i closed a war today, had a oppenent th11 at position 15 in a 15vs15 war, weighing as th8, he had max offense ans 3 starred both our 1 and 2 positions, maxed th10. Supercell should fix that before launching anything new if you ask me

[2222]

if they do it's because to give youtubers time to crate that video. then make the video public once supercell revealed it. even if they know more then the public they won't betray supercell and their partnership with supercell.

Well, that’s how it is supposed to work. Unfortunately, sometimes they aren’t careful enough and they reveal information that they aren’t supposed to reveal yet.

[Satyajit6464]

unless it will be required to have all previous th lvl defenses (IT, XBows, etc) the launch of th12 will result in more engineering. Seriously, it all of the sudden makes sense to build a defenseless village all the way through th12, get all your iffense max and be able to demolish all your enemy bases weighing as a th10 or th11, lol, and your opponent maxing everything doesnt stand a chance when your th12 goes BOOM. And you seriously ask why people are concerned about engineering?
i closed a war today, had a oppenent th11 at position 15 in a 15vs15 war, weighing as th8, he had max offense ans 3 starred both our 1 and 2 positions, maxed th10. Supercell should fix that before launching anything new if you ask me

Really big issue seriously supercell need to do something about this . It is war killer.

[ElfLiya]

Well, that’s how it is supposed to work. Unfortunately, sometimes they aren’t careful enough and they reveal information that they aren’t supposed to reveal yet.

it's fine, mistakes happen. if it wasn't intentional im sure they'll understand, plus it gives more hype

[Kaptain Kat]

unless it will be required to have all previous th lvl defenses (IT, XBows, etc) the launch of th12 will result in more engineering. Seriously, it all of the sudden makes sense to build a defenseless village all the way through th12, get all your iffense max and be able to demolish all your enemy bases weighing as a th10 or th11, lol, and your opponent maxing everything doesnt stand a chance when your th12 goes BOOM. And you seriously ask why people are concerned about engineering?
i closed a war today, had a oppenent th11 at position 15 in a 15vs15 war, weighing as th8, he had max offense ans 3 starred both our 1 and 2 positions, maxed th10. Supercell should fix that before launching anything new if you ask me

No, I am most certainly not asking why people are concerned about engineering. I’ve even emphasized some words so it would be clear what I’m talking about.

You’re missing the entire point of my post.

If you engineer a TH9 you wouldn’t drop the Xbows right ?
If you engineer a TH10 you wouldn’t drop the infernos right ?
If you engineer a TH11 you wouldn’t drop the eagle right ?

Well with the TH12 upgrade you have no choice. You MUST build the defense weapon unique to that TH because it’s integrated in the TH. You get it for free. Well the first level at least...

Is it an ultimate fix to end all engineering ? Of course not (I already said that)

It is However one step in the right direction. So I stand by what I said, it doesn’t promote engineering. (or make it worse).
It will help make the situation better.

[Gueede]

No, I am most certainly not asking why people are concerned about engineering. I’ve even emphasized some words so it would be clear what I’m talking about.

You’re missing the entire point of my post.

If you engineer a TH9 you wouldn’t drop the Xbows right ?
If you engineer a TH10 you wouldn’t drop the infernos right ?
If you engineer a TH11 you wouldn’t drop the eagle right ?

Well with the TH12 upgrade you have no choice. You MUST build the defense weapon unique to that TH because it’s integrated in the TH. You get it for free. Well the first level at least...

Is it an ultimate fix to end all engineering ? Of course not (I already said that)

It is However one step in the right direction. So I stand by what I said, it doesn’t promote engineering. (or make it worse).
It will help make the situation better.

I vote that we put all new defensive structures on top of the town hall. Infernos on top of TH10? YES! Infernos, X-bows AND Eagle on top of TH11? SIGN ME UP!!! It's basically the only option at this point, let's just do it and be done with it

[ElfLiya]

No, I am most certainly not asking why people are concerned about engineering. I’ve even emphasized some words so it would be clear what I’m talking about.

You’re missing the entire point of my post.

If you engineer a TH9 you wouldn’t drop the Xbows right ?
If you engineer a TH10 you wouldn’t drop the infernos right ?
If you engineer a TH11 you wouldn’t drop the eagle right ?

Well with the TH12 upgrade you have no choice. You MUST build the defense weapon unique to that TH because it’s integrated in the TH. You get it for free. Well the first level at least...

Is it an ultimate fix to end all engineering ? Of course not (I already said that)

It is However one step in the right direction. So I stand by what I said, it doesn’t promote engineering. (or make it worse).
It will help make the situation better.

but if everyone already has it at level one will it mess with the lower level ? i don't think so. but it's a start at least. as you said it's a step in the right direction

[Kaptain Kat]

I vote that we put all new defensive structures on top of the town hall. Infernos on top of TH10? YES! Infernos, X-bows AND Eagle on top of TH11? SIGN ME UP!!! It's basically the only option at this point, let's just do it and be done with it

Oy that will look awful and hinders base design quite a bit...
wouldnt there be more elegant solutions I wonder