FEATURE REQUEST/ENHANCEMENT:View who donated what troops (avoid non-requested troops)

[Isignedup]

When viewing the contents of the clan castle be able to see who donated what - meaning one would be able to see who donated non-requested troops (or just be able to thank those that donated if the player was not actively online at the time of donation). Clanmates can request specific troops already which is great, but there's nothing to ensure that what is requested is what will be received and many bad players often don't respect such requests anyways. There needs to be an easy way to know what players may be donating non-rquested troops to others and messing up their game play. There are several gray squares shown when viewing the contents of your clan castle, maybe instead of grouping similar troops together - use each square to show the combination of a particular troop donated by a particular clanmate. Might also consider indicating who is donating what to a given request in clan chat for all to see (no need for the leader or elders to verify the contents of everyones' clan castles) - perhaps appending a list of what was donated by who in the the requests themselves and leave them in clan chat for all to see.

[Boblo]

Yeah i agree we should have this feature in the game and witch is why i added it to my clan combo thread a while ago back If you want to check it out it is in my signature

[michaelscottdm]

I'm a co-leader in my clan, and it is a huge problem when people donate gobs and WB and everyone says they didn't do it. This would be a great feature, but one idea, allow co-leaders or leaders to figure out who donates what, so we can kick the people who donate WB.

[Xcite]

When viewing the contents of the clan castle be able to see who donated what - meaning one would be able to see who donated non-requested troops (or just be able to thank those that donated if the player was not actively online at the time of donation). Clanmates can request specific troops already which is great, but there's nothing to ensure that what is requested is what will be received and many bad players often don't respect such requests anyways. There needs to be an easy way to know what players may be donating non-rquested troops to others and messing up their game play. There are several gray squares shown when viewing the contents of your clan castle, maybe instead of grouping similar troops together - use each square to show the combination of a particular troop donated by a particular clanmate. Might also consider indicating who is donating what to a given request in clan chat for all to see (no need for the leader or elders to verify the contents of everyones' clan castles) - perhaps appending a list of what was donated by who in the the requests themselves and leave them in clan chat for all to see.

Or just check out my Clan Castle Filter idea at this thread here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ltering-Option



- Xcite

[opum2]

I agree because when I'm either not looking or offline, I can thank the person who gave the troops. Great idea!!

[ianclasher163]

Agreed. It would be nice if the details of the donations showed up in chat or something, maybe after the request was filled so as to not fill up the chat. Or if the request was not filled completely, the details would be shown when the player requests again, something like that.

[George1971]

Information on who donated troops should be available, not for any of the polled reasons, but for the benefit of the clan knowing what is going on in the clan.

when I've seen poor donations happen, it is not because someone is an idiot or malicious, but because they didn't really understand.

Alternatively, or additionally, there should be a clan notice board where the clan rules and etiquettes on donations can be written plain for everyone in the clan to read.

[XxDjPewdsxX]

I agree because when I'm either not looking or offline, I can thank the person who gave the troops. Great idea!!

Agreed. It would be nice if the details of the donations showed up in chat or something, maybe after the request was filled so as to not fill up the chat. Or if the request was not filled completely, the details would be shown when the player requests again, something like that.

Information on who donated troops should be available, not for any of the polled reasons, but for the benefit of the clan knowing what is going on in the clan.when I've seen poor donations happen, it is not because someone is an idiot or malicious, but because they didn't really understand.Alternatively, or additionally, there should be a clan notice board where the clan rules and etiquettes on donations can be written plain for everyone in the clan to read.

This idea is good, but.......WHY DID YOU BUMP A 1-2 YEAR OLD THREAD?

[George1971]

This idea is good, but.......WHY DID YOU BUMP A 1-2 YEAR OLD THREAD?

Wasn't me, but one answer could be:

This forum is very poor at identifying the best threads. Often, google searching the site finds the best threads. Better to revive a good old thread than to start yet another clone thread.

Replying to a Google-discovered thread should not be discouraged, because if one person finds the thread with Google, so will others.