Clan Games - March 16th to March 20th - Details inside!

[Vook]

Please try to communicate better in future, if you communicate.
I wouldn’t mind no previews/details before an event, than details that change with little communication.

This

It's not very proffessional from a Community Manager to ninja edit an official post and not say a beep about it

It's the only source of official information ... if we can't trust him, then who can we trust?

[dodgson]

A couple of observations:

1. So I posted the information that was originally on this board about the rewards. I wake up this morning and have to apologize to my clan-mates. I'm not sure why you changed it but the original offering was much better.

2. Only 4 of our 12 options are for the main base. Technically 2 of them could be used on the main base (attacking up a TH level and clearing obstacles) but my 2 bases are TH11s and I never have obstacles. We just got over the Builder games, not sure why you are essentially giving us another. Punishment for our complaining about the last one?

3. Now we have nothing at 18k and have a lower cap for our points. That means that those of us who are most active might not be able to push the clan to the book because it is the max tier. Please go back to the 18k/30k for books and something like a potion for max at 50k. It was a much more rewarding system and exciting our players that were less inclined to participate in Clash at all.

[dodgson]

So after seeing everyone's feedback, we've decided to make one more change to the rewards. We've removed the 50K point tier and moved those rewards down to the 30K tier.

Who on earth were you responding to? I, like many others, came on to praise what you had originally posted. The new set of rewards is terrible for my clan. If anyone said they didn't want a book of heroes at 18k and a book of building at 30k than they are different than every single active player in my clan. To say I'm incredibly disappointed at this change is putting it mildly.

After all the complaints about the builder games you made no changes. After I saw a lot of praise for this one you listened to one or two people? I just don't get it.

[Edited to add - I am fully reading through now and see they made a horrendous update to the rewards and then responded to feedback. I'll keep my original post as is.]

[dodgson]

3) The other option I guess is to give the information, then refuse to change it after improvements are suggested, just to avoid being bashed for changing it. I don't really like that option. There might be good reasons to change it, such as a simple mistake in typing up the original notes, noticing an unplanned negative aspect after releasing the notes, hearing feedback from the community, etc.

What improvements were made? The new rewards (both actual rewards and the tiers) are much worse. We lost a book of building at 30k and lost the ability to get the book of heroes at 18k. We also lost 1k per person. This is a disastrous change. What's more, it is for a 4 day clan games, why couldn't they keep it the same and update the next one? It isn't like a new update was coming out. I certainly think they should keep that mostly under wraps.

[Edited to add - I am fully reading through now and see they made a horrendous update to the rewards and then responded to feedback. I'll keep my original post as is.]

[Vikingchief]

Two observations about this version of the clan games:
1.) There seem to be an awful lot of Builder hall challenges relative to regular base challenges. Didn't we just have a builder only games? Currently 9 of the 12 challenges visible in my clan are for the builder hall ?!?
2.) Half the challenges are of the 1 hr variety instead of longer times (i.e., 8hr+). Any reason for this? The 1hr challenges are far more difficult to complete than others, and the point values don't seem to reflect this any more.

More regular base challenges please! More long-term challenges please!

yes, supercell don't make a little mistake of similar kind (many orders of maginitude smaller and a somewhat different principle to) the one you just made, dont give us rubbish 1 Hr need to gem main base challenges versus standard builder base challenges, and them make 70 of chalenges builder base only, rather give us standard main base challenges, but make builder base 1.5 or 2X points they normally are.

honey, vinegar, flies etc.

A slight adjustment and yiu will have more people playing BB tasks, and enjoying it, or as least grumblijg as they do it.

Positive incentives have more stronger long term benefits than negative incentives.

Dont make main hall challenges worse than usual, make BB better, we already have a Baselkonventionen from previous clangames.

[Vikingchief]

Can someone explain to me why new rewards are worse than the old ones? Maybe i missed something? Lower tiers and ruin of gold option? How are the old one better?

[Vikingchief]

If Prutser had a bat signal I would be shining it right now.

Just joking.

sort of.

Reefus probably a safer bet.

[ThisMe]

I lead a clan. I check here to send the reward/tier info to my clan mates, like lots of others.

I assumed that the OP was true, so I sent it to my clan and didn't realize that the info that I was originally given had been totally changed until I looked at the tiers. So I come here to check, and the OP doesn't even say it was edited, that vital piece of info is buried in dozens of pages.

At least I now know that I can stop relying on information posted here from SC. It will save me some time, at least.

[Vikingchief]

guys supercell made a call they though was good for smaller clans I guess, I dont know If the rewards are much worse, can someone explain jow the rewards are objectively worse?

[lincolnq]

So you guys changed the rewards and individual cap to 2k at the last minute? Last I checked the rewards were different and I shared that link with my clan.

Well, thanks for making this Clan Games worse?

#WorstClanGamesEver (including Builder Games). What do you guys think?