Pls🙏 more clan options/features and troup donation log

[Stady507]

Hi guy's its about time to give us more clan options. I would like to have more tools, titles(maybe "Warchief") to determinate who is the dude in charge to organize the CW.
A punishment system would be cool to so we can punish people who does not attack during CW without kicking them out or maybe a reward system where we can give reward's to those pep's who realy do a good job...
A clan troup donation log would be a great idea cuz it is realy hard to spot those guys who donate the wrong troups.

That sayd... I ask to pardon me for my bad english. Its not my 1st language (Italian/Gernan here &#128521.
👋

[SoulCalibreSkull]

Punishment? More like inhumane abuse. No thanks, do you realize what the wrong sort of people would do if given a tool like this. Its like setting up nuclear bombs all over the world and giving the remote button to a monkey.

[Mrlk]

Op tbe tools are already in tbe game the leader decides who runs the war and as for punishment if bases have opted in for war and dont attack they deserve kickng no other tool is required for these things as for a reward system that's sounds unfair unless its for the entire clan as theres many things that help to win wars not just one person

[Stady507]

Im strictly ignoring those two replies because i think you guys are wrong but i dont want to start a debate wats wrong or not.

This said... I would adress my request to the devs/creators or who is reading this hoping to get more Titles to give (because 2 is just to less). And maybe to get a option to see who donate wat troup( seriusly guys is it that hard implement a funktion where i can see who donated me wath troup?) .

[Sakat]

I agree with the troup donation log or a way to select what troops you want, so you can't get something else. Would be good that troops put in defense CC (in CW) are counted as given troops too.

[Stady507]

I agree with the troup donation log or a way to select what troops you want, so you can't get something else. Would be good that troops put in defense CC (in CW) are counted as given troops too.

Nice idea 👍

[Kaledonian]

Im strictly ignoring those two replies because i think you guys are wrong but i dont want to start a debate wats wrong or not.

This said... I would adress my request to the devs/creators or who is reading this hoping to get more Titles to give (because 2 is just to less). And maybe to get a option to see who donate wat troup( seriusly guys is it that hard implement a funktion where i can see who donated me wath troup?) .

I agree with the troup donation log or a way to select what troops you want, so you can't get something else. Would be good that troops put in defense CC (in CW) are counted as given troops too.

Read the stickies at the top of the page.

Donation log is ruled out. Probably due to it taking up unnecessary & expensive server space.

War donations will never count towards "friend in need" as it's open to abuse.

[Sakat]

War donations will never count towards "friend in need" as it's open to abuse.

It could still count in the normal stats, but not the achievement. In my clan most of the time it's the same 3-4 players that are filling the CC in CW. Would be good to have it counted at it's important for the clan performance.

[JohnnyPC]

Im strictly ignoring those two replies because i think you guys are wrong but i dont want to start a debate wats wrong or not.

This said... I would adress my request to the devs/creators or who is reading this hoping to get more Titles to give (because 2 is just to less). And maybe to get a option to see who donate wat troup( seriusly guys is it that hard implement a funktion where i can see who donated me wath troup?) .

So you're ignoring replies that disagree with you? Those two replies make good points.

All 3 of your ideas have been discussed in countless threads over the past few years. I've been very active in this forum over that time, so I believe the general consensus is:

1) The existing clan ranks are sufficient. No need to over-complicate this feature.

2) Punishment or rewards for performance are an issue of clan management and not Supercell's problem.

3) A donation history log is ruled out by Supercell. Please read this sticky post at the top of the forum:
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...rum-guidelines

[Ajax]

No need for the bump/necro.