“New “Cool off time for war hoppers

[Flfe02]

Hi , I just have a quick suggestion that could bring game much way better and happy to the clash community, ... well as right now if a clan member abandons clan during war time he cannot start a new war with new clan until war timer goes away , well in old times during wars if someone left a war was hunt or persecuted do to treason... but I see no point hunting down those that abandon war , but I do see that if someone leaves a clan during war , it should be nice to have that player also can’t join other clans until war timer ends , that way we get more clash players to be more dedicated to clan wars and this way those that let clan know the consequences, people are tired of hoppers and is hard to get good players... thanks and hope u can make those changes to improve this game

[PapaTroll]

There does need to be a penalty.
Not sure a firing squad is needed.

[TankSinatra]

Take only as many new guys (AKA, "risks") as you can afford to each war. Not ideal I know but if you're trying to be a serious clan in a game aimed at the casual market, SC isn't going to make it easy for you.

[JFSoul]

I have a few other recommendations:

What should the penalty be for this type of player?
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...type-of-player

[SkyValker]

.... but I do see that if someone leaves a clan during war , it should be nice to have that player also can’t join other clans until war timer ends.....

OP - you are right, this is a pain. However, your suggestion prevents people going to visit another clan to get cc troops.
Sometimes people go to a sister clan, to donate from another account (or have a family of clans, and just want to go and visit a friend)
Or, if all else fails, go to a 'request and go' clan to get troops for a war raid

You will often find that simple solutions have unintended consequences

Personally, I like the ideas in JFSoul's thread above (and in particular some suggestions from Tomville....!)

[c0mical]

I don't think it needs a penalty. A timer is shown on the profile. It can then be handled as seen fit

[joshsgrandad]

I have a few other recommendations:

What should the penalty be for this type of player?
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...type-of-player

HaHa.. I read through a lot of that thread. Was before my time here. But chuckled at the innocence of it all. The days before the Zombie Apocalypse, when the virus got loose, and the clash world turned to engineering ( can even get an engineering link into this one Ripple). I agree with OP, hoppers are a menace. I struggle to comprehend how they get into another clan, with a war timer running. Are people really that desperate for members. What do they think will happen when their war gets tough?.

It doesn't tend to happen with our clan, but if we had a mass exodus, I would really have to ask questions, as most of the accounts in our wars are my accounts, and a majority of the wars is done with a 2 man army. And we are both addicted.

2 things do get me tho.. We had to abandon the opt in/ out tool that SC kindly included on player profile page, as it appears to be too difficult for some people to use. Whats that about?.. Other thing is, I put out a clan mail stating next war day, and people "opt in" on clan chat, then come war day they either don't turn up, attack without back up troops, or use the war to raid, in the hope they will gain a big reward at the end.

[TankSinatra]

2 things do get me tho.. We had to abandon the opt in/ out tool that SC kindly included on player profile page, as it appears to be too difficult for some people to use. Whats that about?...

Yeah what's with that? I get a lot of "I'll be out the third week of March, and if you war Sunday I can be in but not if it starts after 4:15". How about you keep your opt current champ, I'm not keeping track of everybody's vacation schedule. If you're green you're probably in war, if you don't attack there's probably a consequence.

[JFSoul]

HaHa.. I read through a lot of that thread. Was before my time here. But chuckled at the innocence of it all. The days before the Zombie Apocalypse, when the virus got loose, and the clash world turned to engineering ( can even get an engineering link into this one Ripple). I agree with OP, hoppers are a menace. I struggle to comprehend how they get into another clan, with a war timer running. Are people really that desperate for members. What do they think will happen when their war gets tough?.

It doesn't tend to happen with our clan, but if we had a mass exodus, I would really have to ask questions, as most of the accounts in our wars are my accounts, and a majority of the wars is done with a 2 man army. And we are both addicted.

2 things do get me tho.. We had to abandon the opt in/ out tool that SC kindly included on player profile page, as it appears to be too difficult for some people to use. Whats that about?.. Other thing is, I put out a clan mail stating next war day, and people "opt in" on clan chat, then come war day they either don't turn up, attack without back up troops, or use the war to raid, in the hope they will gain a big reward at the end.

You play the game long enough you will eventually "see it all." Haven't experienced a clan hopper who we let in war and didn't get war attacks done in over a year now, but I can see it happening to others. Cheers.

[JFSoul]

Yeah what's with that? I get a lot of "I'll be out the third week of March, and if you war Sunday I can be in but not if it starts after 4:15". How about you keep your opt current champ, I'm not keeping track of everybody's vacation schedule. If you're green you're probably in war, if you don't attack there's probably a consequence.

LOL...that is awesome. I've seen that too, even after going adult only in my clan.