Sick and tired of these mismatch wars when including smaller TH’s in the lineup

[DaFonz2]

They need to fix this. We’ve got a war with 4 TH10’s at the top of a 10vs10. Across from us is 4 TH11’s all with decent level wardens. Top guy has half max troops & a good portion of TH11 defences (5 bows, 4 inferno, etc) The bottom 4 in their clan are purposely rushed 6,7,8 bases that they’re obviously using to lower their weight. No walls, lvl 2 wiz for biggest troops and lvl 1-2 defense structures and all unranked with no donations. We’ve got actual players with 8’s, 7’s & 6’s. It’s not fair to leave them out because it draws these unfair matchups against clans that use these low level TH’s to their advantage. They want to war and have fun too but it sucks that coc has made it so having new upstart players is a disadvantage.

[Chang405]

How about splitting up into two teams alternating every other war. One team can be between Th8-10 and the other team can be Th9 and below. It is well known that the larger your TH spread (you are taking Th6-10) the higher the chances you will get a mismatch.

[DaFonz2]

I’m saying why can’t coc go back to recognizing the TH levels of the lineup in some degree and matching up accordingly like they used to so we can have large wars with varied TH’s. So we don’t have to alternate. We don’t have large numbers and usually run 10 or 15. Alternated would mean a lot more 5’s and no one likes that.

[SuperStorm103]

I'm at the point where I don't think roster really matters much in deciding who you will match. Your roster really only effects how long your searches are.

Its the value placed on accounts and working with averages that cause all the issues. We rand a mostly un-engineered roster for a long time and saw decent matches. No sign of defenseless bases (though we still matched some clans with engineered bases) and all wars were winnable. Now, as others are reporting, we have started matching clans with defenseless bases, low setting engineered 11's (not the quasi kind).

Our roster is still pretty lightly engineered, and we have matched every style of clan there is. CWL/NDL, Engineered, roster engineered, and rushed. It doesn't matter. Our current 25 vs 25 is a prime example of a junk match (as you can read in my /facepalm thread).

We have 12 th9's and a th8 at the bottom of the roster. the opposing clan has 6 th9's, 5 th8's, 1 th10, and 3 th4's at the bottom of theirs. Apparently Th11-Th9 clans running 25 vs wars are rare.....

[DaFonz2]

Well 4 TH10’s vs 4 TH11’s is just plain stupid. They’re using power potions too, so top Defense in war is their #1 and the top 8 strongest weighted attacks using their power potions are theirs in a 10 vs 10. Who wants to play that game?

[StormHeart]

We are seeing that too. We have been taking only 10vs10 all 9s and 8s. They always have more nines then us. They bring 1 or 2 TH6 to 4 to war.

I'm getting a TH7 ready to answer that. Lower weight for us and something that can kill those tiny bases so our 8s can work on something more worthwhile.

War that ended tonight was exactly that way. They even had a TH10 at the top of the map. We beat them 30 to 20. :P perfect war for us, they just folded and gave up. They couldn't attack but sometimes they can attack and it makes for an impossible war to win.

[AFrostyBlaze]

what kind of progression do you have on your 10s?

max 10s can often draw th11s since the weight is similar or 10s without infernos will often draw engineered 11s.

seems unlikely to me that 4 10s would mirror 4 11s so i'm guessing at most, only one of them have an eagle?

[SuperStorm103]

They couldn't attack but sometimes they can attack and it makes for an impossible war to win.

Very much this. I have found a great solution for dealing with defenseless bases when your lowest base is a th9. You may need to engineer a 6 year old child, but when we see these in the wars, I just let him do the attack. He has fun! And, I have fun watching him attack (must be pretty entertaining for everybody else as well)........WTH is Storm doing?

[frainlll]

Like before I said, 40% roster rush base ,higher th level, like junk bases, no def and no offense will make a big advantage on top. I am 100% sure.

[SuperStorm103]

Like before I said, 40% roster rush base ,higher th level, like junk bases, no def and no offense will make a big advantage on top. I am 100% sure.

But at a cost. And the cost for the clans we have been facing is to high. They are giving up 1 or 2 extra freebie stars that they cannot get back against our well defended top of the map.