Should TH Sniping be Removed?

[Gunnermatt]

The answer is alway the same:
Is SC will more make profits at mid and long term by removing TH snipping and free shield?

If the answer is yes they will remove it sooner or later.
If the answer is no they wont change anything.
If the answer is maybe they will wait until they are really sure.

no, if they remove th sniping many casual gemmers/farmers will quit which is where the majority of SCs revenue comes from

[Raff]

To have 100,000 gold and elixir, plus 500 DE at TH10... it would seem to be really hard to get onto your feet when entering the next TH.
And also it does say in the description of the Town Hall that "Destroying an opponent's Town Hall wins you the battle and you get one star." 1 star = shield. Because 1 star > 40%.

[BonbeeTyrael]

It shouldn't be removed but there should be more incentive to keep it inside such as 25,000-35,000 of each resource inside it instead of 1,000.

[daz258]

It shouldn't be removed but there should be more incentive to keep it inside such as 25,000-35,000 of each resource inside it instead of 1,000.

No, there should be reward for defending it. Not punishment for leaving it out. Halls are halls, not storages.

[BonbeeTyrael]

No, there should be reward for defending it. Not punishment for leaving it out. Halls are halls, not storages.

That's true but it's already been suggested and shot down.

[daz258]

That's true but it's already been suggested and shot down.

Shot down or not, if SuperCell consider it a 'problem' it is the best way to resolve it.

Give players a chance to make loot defending it.

Adding more punishments rather incentives is putting nails into a coffin.

[PR77]

Shield should start at 40% regardless if we take out the TH or not

[Funguy]

Just make a poll for crying out loud and not the same thread again and again.

[Stepneo]

Its not a punishment by leaving outside if total 4 storages plus townhall storage equals amount to 10mill gold and 10 mill elixir.

Storages increase in the form of a townhall and every player decide whether they want put inside or outside.

For me i put outside when i am farming to get cheap shields. Because this is how the game is. Personally i don't agree with putting th outside but since many are doing this and supercell allows this, i just follow what the rules are.

[Peewee]

I agree that's why they give us defense to protect th and resources

Shield should start at 40% regardless if we take out the TH or not