TH sniping should no longer give shields

[madmonk3y]

I don't see this being a good idea, for the reasons already stated above.

Neither is only holding only 1000k resources in the TH. Wasn't it supposed to be the main building in the game when it was designed? At least make people pay for that shield, a handful of trophies represents nothing.

[Boblo]

Better solution is to make townhalls store a decent amount of gold/elixir, say about 100,000 each or something, not like 1,000 they store now.

Exactly, we need the shield!

[kingleo10]

I don't see this being a good idea, for the reasons already stated above.

Can you or someone else clarify which reasons you are refering to?

[OrangeJJ]

Wow... How could you even suggest this!?! Free shields/killing TH's are part of the game, if that were to be removed, the game mechanics will mess up... Then, it'll be harder to go up trophies, this'll just make people quit even more...

[Pranav]

whats ur problem with farmers it doesn't matter, bad idea. and for the people that aren't farmers just with a bad base? what about them?

[dahimi]

Do you not go to school? I'm very sure we all have school. I am more active than you think, and I am a good donator, I always donate at least 2k a season. I am one of the most active.

Others already addressed this. It takes 40 hours for a level 10 collector to fill. It takes 50 hours for a level 11 collector to fill. Most folks, dunno about you, empty them before they go to bed and empty them again when they wake up. Perhaps you don't.

Regardless that doesn't really change anything I said. You're an active player. If I steal loot from you, you have to steal more from someone else. That is a net loss. In addition you're likely to lose the loot in collectors over a series of small attacks instead of one big one. At least that's how it works for me. When I leave my TH inside overnight, I'll gain a hundred or more trophies over the night.

Neither is only holding only 1000k resources in the TH. Wasn't it supposed to be the main building in the game when it was designed? At least make people pay for that shield, a handful of trophies represents nothing.

This is a very poor argument. I explained to you very clearly how TH sniping does not result in reduced loot due to hiding. So now you've switched to "isn't it supposed to be the main building in the game". The real question is, how would changing it so people were compelled to protect their TH make the game better? If you accept that TH sniping does not significantly reduce available loot, who exactly is the loser here? Is it the people who get free trophies? The people who get free resources? The people who preserve their resources and at the same time reduce the number of unprofitable base attacks?

Sounds to me like everybody wins. So what exactly is your issue with it?

[safy1]

no!
Not
on
your
life!

[madmonk3y]

This is a very poor argument. I explained to you very clearly how TH sniping does not result in reduced loot due to hiding. So now you've switched to "isn't it supposed to be the main building in the game". The real question is, how would changing it so people were compelled to protect their TH make the game better? If you accept that TH sniping does not significantly reduce available loot, who exactly is the loser here? Is it the people who get free trophies? The people who get free resources? The people who preserve their resources and at the same time reduce the number of unprofitable base attacks?

Sounds to me like everybody wins. So what exactly is your issue with it?

Exactly the one described by the OP. That's a cheap (not as in low cost) way of protecting your resources & that's what defenses are for. To say it would ruin the game is really pushing it.
Just because I don't agree with you doesn't make me wrong (and vice versa).

[obeo2k2]

Better solution is to make townhalls store a decent amount of gold/elixir, say about 100,000 each or something, not like 1,000 they store now.

Now this ^^^^^^ is a great idea. It always bugged me that no matter the th level they all hold the same gold/elix

[daz258]

I don't see this being a good idea, for the reasons already stated above.

You are my hero Steve.

Let's get the focus back onto more important issues. Not this!