TH sniping should no longer give shields

[kingleo10]

This, will not only stops Th outside. I'd imagine people try everything not to lose Th before a 50%.

Let the talents designing great bases protecting TH begin!

[Yette]

This, will not only stops Th outside. I'd imagine people try everything not to lose Th before a 50%.

Let the talents designing great bases protecting TH begin!

Dream on. They are not redesigning the game because a few people are trying to compare the che+p shielding to th sniping. I had my th out last night, got sacked for 140k 80k and 500de once with no shield given, a bolter hit me for 800 DE, and then leveled for 200k 200k 1500de right after that. Would be a loss of a millionk of each and 5000 de if some of you get your way... If sc makes the changes that many of you are asking for it will destroy the game. Derp!

Feel I need to add, this account I use is always on. At least on for 12 hours a day. Youre not attacking me but for a small window anyway so if you do this many people will leave a builder free to spend gold, buy de as needed to use and never, ever have loot for you to raid. I see most quitting all together over it.

[Kirky]

I really don't see the problem which "needs" to be fixed.

There are plenty of bases to be attacked at lower trophy levels.
If noobs want to get gems at higher levels they can.
If an attacker wants to take all the resources in a base they can try.

OP appears to be equating cheap sheilds at low trophy levels with the revenge change at high trophy levels. Yes both result in a sheild but the effect of that shield on other players in the game is very different.

[nfsox98]

I'm really confused about what the problem is here? I have said it before and I'll say it again: Sniping a town hall has NOTHING to do with CHEETING the game and getting free cups and shields. If you snipe a town hall it does not prevent you from 3 starring the base or getting all the loot. All it does is give you a league bonus. One of the worst arguments in the game as of now is this stupid idea to take away the ability to place your town hall outside walls. I mean its completely and utterly pointless to add a feature that would do this into the game. This thread should be closed as it is a pointless back and forth argument.

[Growler]

Just wait until you all get attacked repeated overnight and lose large amounts of resource with no shield.

Even a few failed attacks when you trophy chase make a dent in the resources you have, and those attackers didn't even mean to fail on you,then multiply that many times over when people couldn't care less about the trophies you have unless they are handed to them on a plate.

I wish people on here would stop and think before they let their overactive imagination run away with them and get carried away with their own (imagined) cleverness.

How is this even a topic of discussion? It is either shortsighted farmers trying to appear clever and offering a sop to the rampant che@ters at the top, or it is those bitter rampant che@ters at the top lashing out.

If these idiotic and ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed suggestions are implemented not only will they cause serious problems to newcomers to the game, it will have a hugely detrimental effect on the game as a whole for anyone that doesn't pay large amounts of money to play it.

[Rastis]

I could write a long post, but Growler covered it pretty well up there ^.
Don't force everyone, current trophy hunters and farmers alike, into an awkward trophy push oriented playstyle. This would eliminate around 50 % of the available base designs out there, as well as limit or change the playstyle of a large amount of people. I guess people who are fully or almost fully maxed out might also wish for this, since they probably have had an awful time grinding resources for the TH10 updates months and months back - hoping the TH10 situation is a bit better now. This change would make farming more miserable for everyone else.

And for the n:th time, TH sniping is not the same as cheap shielding (presumably somewhat fixed) used at the higher cup ratings.

[Radu]

Just wait until you all get attacked repeated overnight and lose large amounts of resource with no shield.

Even a few failed attacks when you trophy chase make a dent in the resources you have, and those attackers didn't even mean to fail on you,then multiply that many times over when people couldn't care less about the trophies you have unless they are handed to them on a plate.

I wish people on here would stop and think before they let their overactive imagination run away with them and get carried away with their own (imagined) cleverness.

How is this even a topic of discussion? It is either shortsighted farmers trying to appear clever and offering a sop to the rampant che@ters at the top, or it is those bitter rampant che@ters at the top lashing out.

If these idiotic and ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed suggestions are implemented not only will they cause serious problems to newcomers to the game, it will have a hugely detrimental effect on the game as a whole for anyone that doesn't pay large amounts of money to play it.

Please be nice, here is no idiotic suggestions! You want free shield? Sorry you have to buy one!
Topic is with Townhall outside you have in 10 minutes a 12 hour Shild.
And revenge not works, guess why? Someone gave him Shild... This have to change!

[vl0071]

What a hypocrite.

A farmer who have benefited from the current game mechanics, seeks to deny new players/farmers the same mechanism. You might be able to defend yourself now that you have a high TH and high defenses but lower level players do not have this option.

[hastur]

Lower level players have great options... they can easily spend their loot, so it's not available for the taking....

I have a TH7 account, and with a few hours raiding, at most, I can get enough gold / elixer for the next project, empty the coffers, then log off. No real need to have my TH available for sniping. My TH9 has the opposite problem... can't spend it quick enough, so there's always more than 1M of each in storage. TH8 is the only hall level where you need to store loot, but your defenses aren't quite good enough to defend it from a lot of raiders.

[Rastis]

Lower level players have great options... they can easily spend their loot, so it's not available for the taking....

I have a TH7 account, and with a few hours raiding, at most, I can get enough gold / elixer for the next project, empty the coffers, then log off. No real need to have my TH available for sniping. My TH9 has the opposite problem... can't spend it quick enough, so there's always more than 1M of each in storage. TH8 is the only hall level where you need to store loot, but your defenses aren't quite good enough to defend it from a lot of raiders.

So if you can't get rid of your resources fast enough on TH9, doesn't that also mean you need to store loot, like you described the TH8 stage to be? And not sure about you, but around 6 weeks into TH9 my base still occasionally gets levelled by late stage TH9s and TH10s, although I went from a maxed TH8. The long build times pretty much make you sit and wait to spend loot, so I don't mind losing some trophies over a 12 hour shield. And yes, we know that TH7s have an easy time to make profit. I'm pretty convinced vl0071 referred to new players who are relatively clueless when he talked about "lower players".
The whole idea of removing the TH shield is just about the biggest pile of bogus I've come across so far.