Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[kmilovc]

En si siento que el emparejamiento de las guerra de clanes están muy debalanceadas, muchos Th 11 suben específicamente lo que necesitan para en por ejemplo: la provisión 16 el clan contrario le saque 3 estrellas al primero de nosotros, da rabia por qué a la final la guerra son para los clanes que se dedican a competir en guerra de clanes y los demás que solo quieren jugar aguantarse muchas derrotas.

[kh1980]

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

Hello Darian:
#P2Y9YVV2
Jesus Saves
War starts tonight about 9:12 Eastern
They have 3 eagles to our 1. They have 4 serious th11 offenses. We have 2.5. I’m stumped on this one. We do have a win streak of 5 to their 1.
Thanks!

[KingAroth]

Fair match up no engineered bases on each side. Weight is about the same. This war will be a draw.

Clan ID: #QP2YLPPY Clan name: Star Brawlers War Start Date: 05-20-18 War Start Time (US EST Time): About 5pm
US
Rank	TH Level	BK Level	AQ Level	GW Level	Weight	Gold 1	Gold 2	Gold 3	Gold 4	Town Hall
1	8	10	0	0	55	13750	13750	13750	0	13750
2	8	10	0	0	55	13750	13750	13750	0	13750
3	8	10	0	0	55	13750	13750	13750	0	13750
4	8	10	0	0	53	13250	13250	13250	0	13250
5	8	8	0	0	52	13000	13000	13000	0	13000
6	8	7	0	0	48	12000	12000	12000	0	12000
7	7	5	0	0	40	13332	13334	0	0	13334
8	7	1	0	0	38	12666	12667	0	0	12667
9	7	3	0	0	36	12000	12000	0	0	12000
10	5	0	0	0	19	6332	6334	0	0	6334
Totals	7.4	6.4	0	0	451	123830	123835	79500	0	123835
THEM
Rank	TH Level	BK Level	AQ Level	GW Level	Weight	Gold 1	Gold 2	Gold 3	Gold 4	Town Hall
1	8	10	0	0	55	13750	13750	13750	0	13750
2	8	10	0	0	52	13000	13000	13000	0	13000
3	8	8	0	0	51	12750	12750	12750	0	12750
4	8	8	0	0	51	12750	12750	12750	0	12750
5	8	6	0	0	48	12000	12000	12000	0	12000
6	8	5	0	0	48	12000	12000	12000	0	12000
7	8	5	0	0	47	11750	11750	11750	0	11750
8	8	5	0	0	47	11750	11750	11750	0	11750
9	8	4	0	0	44	13666	13667	3000	0	13667
10	7	0	0	0	10	3332	3334	0	0	3334
Totals	7.9	6.1	0	0	453	116748	116751	102750	0	116751
	Notes:
	This war will be a draw. Both sides scored 30 stars. Our 2 war winning streak ends their 5 war winning streak ends.

[Shadowythecat]

Chicos excelentes, solo desearía que Supercell interviniera ahora

[hurtnot]

idk why we r getting mismatched from last 3/4 wars ..against our 2 eagles we got 7 eagles last war ,and this war also we took no eagle still opponent is having a max th 11 with eagle !!and moreover top 4 in opponent are th 11's and we having only 2 th 11s at top

i hope Supercell make things easy for us now we already lost 4 wars back-2 back because of mismatch!

Clan Name: EYED LIED
Clan Tag :2GOGUGRL
War start Date :22/05/2018
War start Time: around 1:30 am (IST)


Thank's for Taking the initiative to assemble data SUPERCELL is Going Through hard times we can see That for sure :/

[BoBoTheGoat]

Fair match up no engineered bases on each side. Weight is about the same. This war will be a draw.

I don't think you understand the purpose of this thread.

[KZVG55]

Despite all the efforts of Supercell to curb Engineering, sites like these are a slap in the face:

https://www.allclash.com/upgrade-pri...for-clan-wars/

Something needs to be done to better protect and encrypt the game's data. Or perhaps add multipliers to weight that are unknown to people.

Please, somebody take note of this post as I feel it is one of Engineering's top resources. There may be more out there.

[KingAroth]

I don't think you understand the purpose of this thread.

I don't? Please explain why by showing the statistics of a fair match up (my opinion) is somehow a misunderstanding of this thread. What I am only supposed to show only bad match ups? Complain? Kinda of a narrow view isn't it? I have been compiling data for each war regardless of it being fair or unfair. Regardless of the outcome to provide data to Supercell or others so that you can see more than the complaints but an unbiased opinion or facts of how the match making system is effecting my clan. Yes I provide more than what is required but the top of my post does give what they are asking for in the OP:

"We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment: "

The bottom part of my message is my comments.

[Leifgurdson]

I tried to post it in the ideas section, but seemingly my language was to crude, so abbrev. repost here:

Start asking ingame!
If I had to bet less than 1% will post in this forum - so you will take a lot of time to collect useful information (maybe never, because of regular changes to the matching algorithm).
We are currently in a CW preparation phase, lowest enemy is a full-blown lvl 9, our lowest are lvl 7 and lvl 8... Happens to us all the time, most of our clan stopped doing clan wars because of this.

AFAIK I am the only one of our clan posting in this forum, and I will not make a habit of regular reporting. And even if I would - would not give you data on the 99% that are just frustrated ingame...

So: Start asking (maybe before wars - in prep phase? to not have war outcome influence the result?) how fair the match is seen... The throw AI at it to analyse the data...

[Leifgurdson]

Despite all the efforts of Supercell to curb Engineering, sites like these are a slap in the face:

https://www.allclash.com/upgrade-pri...for-clan-wars/

Something needs to be done to better protect and encrypt the game's data. Or perhaps add multipliers to weight that are unknown to people.

Please, somebody take note of this post as I feel it is one of Engineering's top resources. There may be more out there.

Thanks for the link... Seems like SC is out to punish all people that try to research everything... Explains a lot of CW matches we had in the past.