Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[Pluribus]

#PQ9992RJ
War start 945 pm EST 12/26
War end 945 PM EST 12/27

10 v 10 war
We have two th11s and they have 6 th11s.

Again, Supercell, when are you going to figure this out?!

Update after 12 hours. As expected every one of our bases has been attacked and they have 26 of 30 stars without using any of their top 3 attacks. Whuch means they have 6 top attacks to pick up 4 stars. Completely and utterly ridiculous that Supercell continues to allow these matchups.

[DRVN]

Clan ID: #LJJGVQUG
Clan name: Onyx Orcas
War Start Date: 25/12
War Start Time (GMT): 00:20
Comment:

Breakdown:

TH11: 3 VS 33
TH10: 10 VS 8
TH9: 23 VS 8
TH8: 10 VS 1

This adds up to 46 vs 50.

But if you’re facing 3 vs 33 for th11s, please tell me that’s a joke.

[thebenst]

Clan ID:#LQPJLQUU
Clan name: Skilled101
War Start Date:12/7
War Start Time (GMT): 02:36
Opponent Clan: PLM Lights - #9VUJUQYY
Comment:

War breakdown:
Skilled101 - 3x th10s (level 3 infernos) 9x th9s & 3x th8
PLM Lights - 1x th11 (Max Eagle & Level 4 Infernos) 3x th10's (2 with level 3 infernos, 1 with level 2)

We do have higher heroes for the most part across the board. However, in the words of Darian, we are trying to avoid wars that "feel wrong" and this one feels very wrong. We often war against clan that have an extra th10 with infernos (since we typically have higher heroes) and that is understandable. We have even warred against clans with TH11's matching our 10s, but none with max eagles...

In general we have been getting pretty even matchups now that we have been going 100% fair play (meaning we completely max out our bases before going to the next town hall level. However, this war feels like we are being punished for playing that way and our opponent who is simply rushing to the highest th level they can and dropping the biggest defenses they can have a big advantage in this one...

[sirhanr]

Clan ID:#RJV0RP9Q
Clan name: YARIII
War Start Date Dec-26
War Start Time (GMT): 18:40
Opponent Clan: MAHADEV - #UU9PY9QY

Comment:
just another episode of ridiculous war matching 30x30:

us :14x TH9 bases ranged between fresh to fully maxed out , plus 7x TH8 bases, rest are th7 and below
opponent: 2x TH10 maxed defense and inferno towers and xbow, and maxed offense of th10 ... 11x TH9 bases from maxed out to pretty good th9, plus 7x TH8 bases ... inaddition, opponent base 29, is an enginnered TH10 with dragon and 11 space spell (which can be maxed out to dragon 5 and lightning 7 using the new power potion) ...


Why supercell computer has problem in counting .... we r th9 and below, why matching us with two maxed th10 ???.... i just cant understand... where is the fun... opponent has 4 deadly TH10 offence attacks against lower base of th9 ..... like we r forced to lose war ..... we r group of strong th9 players(and some th8 ) ... all are fair bases, nothing engineered .... why is this keep happening?

supercell are u really reading these posts? Do u care about your players? If so , please repond ... at least let us know that there is something happening ....
without fair war, i dont have reason to play the game .... i almost lost hope .... please fix soon before losing what is left of players

[penguin3d]

Clan ID: #20R2URL
Clan Name: G-Mac
War Start Date: December 18, 2017
War Start Time(GMT): 04:47am (I think . . .)

Note: if you want war start information, make it available in the "War Stats" page for the war in question so you don't have to rely on our translation skills

Problem: We have 3 th11 8 th10, th9 and below may count, but that is auto 3* territory for both sides. They have 11 th11. Our th10 vary from max th9 armies up to max th10 armies/heroes. Our opponent has 11 wardens, and every one of their th11 has some form of max army, whether it be lavaloon, bowlers, miners, whatever. Many of their lower th11 villages have max xbows and/or higher level infernos making it difficult for the appropriate attackers at the bottom to 3*. All in all, offensively, they have us out gunned, and defensively it is fairly even, if not tilted slightly in their favor. Doing the math, this was an uphill war. looking like it will end 51 - 55. When things are evenly matched, we come within 1* or it comes down to %, so this was a stomping.

I had started and stopped the search several times to avoid this very issue, but lost track of time during the last search. TBH, I would rather war search fail to find a match than hand us a match like this.

And we got 3 more stupid matches since this one. I’m done posting feedback, it doesn’t seem to be helping and honestly I’m not having fun in war anymore. Ill play the clan games and work my heroes up to 50, that should keep me entertained for a bit. But, as long as war matching stays this way, I am done with it.

[frainlll]

This adds up to 46 vs 50.

But if you’re facing 3 vs 33 for th11s, please tell me that’s a joke.

It's true and not joke as my check. All of opponent are rushed th11 and lower troops and hero with bad skills.
But OP clan won the war, so it's not match up. Wrong post here.

MM shows up again it's balances on 145:144. Very close.
Good Job! MM

[penguin3d]

It's true and not joke as my check. All of opponent are rushed th11 and lower troops and hero with bad skills.
But OP clan won the war, so it's not match up. Wrong post here.

MM shows up again it's balances on 145:144. Very close.
Good Job! MM

Silly question, but how are you able to come up with those numbers?

[nobeone]

Clan ID: #LQLQ228J
Clan name: A New Hope
War start: 27/12/2017 c.22:30 UK time
Comment: we are balanced all defences placed, they have two clearly engineered th10 and th11, giving them 2 extra th11 attacks than us (6 v our 4) and they have 2 more th9s than us, not the fairest, but my real beef is meeting engineered when we are not, tyvm for listening

[CaptainMayhem]

Clan ID: #8008JL9Q
Clan name: MOOSE KNUCKLES
War Start Date: 12/27/17
War Start Time (GMT): 4:30 am Roughly if my calculation is correct
Comment:

Us: Them: #98UGYOUJ
2 Th11s (1 Max O/D 1 not quite max O/D) 6 Th11s (2 Close to max O/D 1 Max D wo eagle and very strong Offense. The others vary.
6 Th10s (2 Max the others working towards maxing) 3 Th10 (Only 1 w non max Infernos)
11 Th9s (All working towards maxing) 10 Th9 (None max w varying degrees of offense/defense)
1 TH8 1 Th4 (Not positive but dont think its max not that it matters)

This isn't the worst match-up but it is a match-up in their favor. Sure they will struggle th9 vs th9 but they have the engineered hits to make up for it. We will have to use 1 th11 hit to take out their number 3 th11 which is too much for a th10 to three star. That leaves us with 3 hits vs their top 2 assuming we dont need a th11 dip to clear the one th10 w infernos. They should be able to wipe out everyone of our th10s and below and still have 4 hits minimum to use against our top 2. Their top 2 is slightly stronger than our to boot esp on defense. So unless they are complete ♥♥♥♥ attackers this will be tough war to win. Their war log looks decent..Most wars above 95% total destruction. We have definitely won wars like this so I am not disqualifying us but the margin for error is small due to the match-up.

[DRUSSW]

UK Adults
Id#pyj92luu
Date 28/12/2017
Time GMT 16.00
COMMENT ..... SERIOUSLY?????WARS ARE A JOKE PEROID !