Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[pb913]

Clan ID: #R2P8JC0
Clan name: Epic Fu
War Start Date: 12-7-17

Comment: Simply look at our past 10-15 matches. Every single matchup they have 3-10 more Th11s than we do. They often have 8-10 heavily engineered accounts (where the defense is more than 1 TH level below...aka TH11 with TH9 def). We have 1 who is working on getting his defenses up. Most of our accounts are in mid transition....where they were max at TH9 or TH10 but just recently upgraded...we forced them all to drop xbows, IT or EA....as we were getting worse matches when they were .5s. Their top 5-6 are max while our top has 1 that is max and a second that is almost max.

How war typically goes.

The bottom 13-16 are 3 starred by the mirror or by someone a few levels above dropping down. The top 6 bases are mostly a wash...with both sides getting 1 or 2 stars....normally both sides have 2 stars (our top TH11s are good attackers). What determines who wins....bases 7-13....whom ever gets 3 stars will win. These matchups have their bases Max Heros/troops with (max IT, max EA, max point, low level splash, max walls) vs our early TH11s with heros between 20-40 (L3 IT, L2 EA, TH10 point and TH10 splash def TH9/TH10 walls).


We've recently adjusted by having another clan bring over their top TH11s....and we started kicking out any TH10 that couldn't 2 star a TH11 or 3 star a TH10. That's ruthless, especially since their mirror is often a higher level than they are...but hey....that's what SC want's.

[gemcrafter]

#8GU8PQLL. All Out war
matched dec 7 approximately noon gmt

we are not engineered. 6 th10 6 th9 3 th8. We have ZERO th11. They have 4 th11, all with warden (bases 1-2-8-9) 3 th10 3 th9. Then low fluff bases.

Come on SC, only took 18 min to match, how is this even fair? I’m so tired of these matches. Not fun.

[freezerclasher]

Is it worth considering adding a war timer on accounts that do not have defences for the TH i.e. A TH11 with no eagle will have to build the eagle to be eligible for war

[KDrive]

#2RJ90VLJ
GROWN 2 OLD
12-6-17 and current 12-8-17
1800 cst start time.

The last war matchup was a 20 person war which included a couple th10s. A few engineered th11s and the rest actual th11s. We were matched against ALL fully maxed th11s. Current war is a mismatch as well.

[Pluribus]

#2GP09JGUR

War start 12/7 at 930 PM EST
War end 12/8 at 930 PM EST

We have 1 TH11 they have 3 th11s.
They filled the bottom 3rd of their roster with garbage th7s and 8s. We have a th8 at the bottom of our roster the rest is th9s and a few 10s.

[GrudgeTaker]

Clan ID: #Y9LJC2Y9
Clan name: Clan Warriors!
War Start Date: 07/12/17
War Start Time (GMT): 18:30ish
Comment: 15v15 war, we have no th11s at all, their no1 is a maxed th11 with maxed warden, maxed heros, maxed infernos and maxed artillery. They also have a th11 at no13 with maxed laloon and warden. THIS CANNOT BE RIGHT.

The war team with th11s beat the team with th10s, did anyone else see that coming? My patience with this game is wearing thin.

[JohnBob70]

#2QY8QVG
Adults United
War Match Date: 08.12.2017 21:34 GMT +1 (cet)
War Start: 09.12.2017 20:34


15v15. Opponents have 3 engineered th11s with 3 good th10s.
We had one real engineered th10 (spooky), but have recently added most defences.
we also have one th11 without infernos.

We have tried mix and matching, but pretty much to no avail. I have been playing for over 4 years and warring was the only reason for staying in the game. I have 4 accounts.
We usually war 3 times a week, but have had engineered stinky war matches 95% of the time, since the last 2 updates. Certainly, your tweaks have killed wars. I think we have one war win in the last 13 maybe. We used to be pretty good! Personally , for me, this last war draw was the last straw for warring, until you guys fix the war matching.

Our best players have had enough and have either stopped playing or are ready to quit. Tbh: it may already be too for a lot of players anyway, but you guys have the stats. I just see all the dead bases.

Does anybody remember when wars were fun?

Surely a th11 with low experience and one set of max troops are easy to spot?

At least you are super careful with Boom...

Cheers
Shaggy, Scooby, Scrappy and Spooky

[Colin94]

Clan ID: #PJ8Q00QJ
Clan name: Muskie Tears
War Start Date: 09.12
War Start Time (GMT): about 0:30 am
Comment: they have 5 maxed th11 and we have only 1 max th11, 4vs5 eagles, they have much more bases with max heroes ...

[BCGolden]

Clan name : golden victory
Clan Id: #2uqply9g
War start date : search started December 9
War search started @ 12:09 am Pacific time
Comment:
Since your last "improvement" to war matchmaking, we have seen a drastic change in the match ups. For the worse.
This war in particular. . My clan has 7 town hall 11, and we are up against 17 enemy townhall 11. And they all have max heros.
This match up is so incredibly unbalanced.
Ever since your previous "improvements" our th11 being outnumber 2:1 or 3:1 has been a regular occurrence.

[BCGolden]

Wow reading all these other people post the same matchmaking problems I am shocked supercell has done nothing to fix it. What a joke. I've had probably half a dozen members and friends who have all been playing since day 1, quit the game. So frustrating that supercell is just killing their own game.
You have taken the fun out of wars. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if the player community took a huge hit and most players quit.