Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[Greatdutch]

Hi

Clan name great fight!!
Clan id #80jrpr8c
Date war 28th November
Time war 21:10 gmt

The war is in my opinion a mismatch because they have 11 th 11 with warden and bowler lvl 3.
We only have 5 th 11 with bowler lvl 3
So they have 22 chances with Max troops
I think if warden or Max troops are in play they shoot weigh as an th 11 ......don't look at defence....look at the offence.....while matching opponent.
The cheaters are at once finished.

I hope you'll look into this

Waiting for your reply
Best regards Peter

[Sparkles100P]

Clan ID: #V2UUGJUJ
Clan name: Fab Five
War Start Date: 11/28/2019
War Start Time (GMT): war declared 4:20 GMT; war start 23 hours from that
Enemy clan: GVF.77_KOREA (#89YJJG2U)
Comment: War is 5v5, enemy has an extra eagle and 4 extra th11 attacks. Three of their bases are defenseless, which probably afforded them an extra eagle base. So we need an 11v11 triple to win. They have moderate heros (20/20+, and 3 have max warden). This can also double as an answer to the question if warden is weighted enough. Thanks.

[David1937]

Clan :Sunderland #9VOO9LC2

war found at 8.05 pm uk time.

15v15

we have

0 x th11
11 x th10
7 x th9
6 x th8
1 x th7



they have

5 x th11 ( all with either max drags, bowlers, healers, Valks)
6 x th10
9 x th9
3 x th8
2 x th7


whats the point in even trying? What's the point in this thread? No communication, no action, just more mismatched wars and nothing done about it. How on earth do supercell think matching th11 v th10 is an even and balanced war? Shambles

[LSHSpin]

clan ID: 2UG9R22U
clan name: We Rule Rocks
war start: 11/29
start time: 19:20 GMT
Us: 2 TH11
1 TH10
9 TH9
3 TH8

Them:
12 TH11
1 TH9
2 TH8

We have no engineered bases.

[Gr8OdinsRaven]

Our Clan
#cojqujv

Theirs
#p2v9qlcp

Start time 7:15 EST


ANOTHER MISMATCH. 14 th11's on our side in a 30 man war. Opponent has 17 full th11's. As well as 29/30 with wardens. Those low ones have max defenses but th9 layouts, etc which make it almost impossible for a regular 9 to hit it. So we had 28 warden hits compared to 58. How is this improving matchmaking? We don't even want to spin a war because of matches like this.

[Ak7lives]

Clan ID: #2UPG8YYR
Clan name: Wisconsin
War Start Date: 11/28/17
War Start Time (GMT): 12:05 AM
Comment: Finally have the same amount of TH11s(5), but they have all max defense there and that’s what decided it. (5 lvl2 Eagles vs. 2 lvl 2s) plus bigger infernos.

[Balvhunter]

Clan ID:#8RV9JQV0
Clan name: Valinor
War Start Date: 11/28/17
War Start Time (GMT): 23:50
Comment: Very frustrating match to say the least
Our side
- 1 maxed TH10 on top
- 1 TH11 not maxed attack with TH10 defenses (no EA or IT)
- 7 TH 9.5
- 5 TH9

Their side
- 1 TH11 maxed attack and defense
- 2 TH11 not maxed attack with TH10 defenses (no EA or IT)
- 8 TH9
- 3 Enginnered TH11 with Max Guardian
- 1 TH7

1 TH11 attack power matched with 6 TH11 maxed Guardian
1 TH10 full defense matched with TH11 full defense.

Very frustrating to have a war that does not even worth playing.

[Gckcmc]

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

Hey Darian, thanks for continuing research on this. Our clan issue with current matchup:
Invictus Kings, #8GQVGYJY
war started today, 28 November 2017
war started 9:15am PST

we have 9 th11s in various levels of completeness. War is 20 members. We were matched against 18 TH11s. Engineered clan for sure. Would like the devs to see how this continues to match up with MM changes.

Thx
gckcmc

[Greatdutch]

Hi

Clan name great fight!!
Clan id #80jrpr8c
Date war 28th November
Time war 21:10 gmt

The war is in my opinion a mismatch because they have 11 th 11 with warden and bowler lvl 3.
We only have 5 th 11 with bowler lvl 3
So they have 22 chances with Max troops
I think if warden or Max troops are in play they shoot weigh as an th 11 ......don't look at defence....look at the offence.....while matching opponent.
The cheaters are at once finished.

I hope you'll look into this

Waiting for your reply
Best regards Peter

[George90]

Clan ID: #QQ9UPJG
Clan name: LEGENDS
War Start Date: 12/11/2017
War Start Time (GMT): 23:30

we had 1 th11, 10 th10, 10 th9, 4 th8.
they had 5 th11, 13 th10, 6 th9, 1 th8. (Clan id: #8888gg0g)

We also started a war right after this one and we match with this clan: #20gcuc82
we have: 1 th11, 11 th10, 8 th9, 5 th8
they have: 9 th11 (!!!!!!!), 5 th10, 8 th9, 2 th8, 1 th7

The current matchmaking situation is extremely frustrating.. wars are not fun anymore.

I honestly don't know why I bother. You don't seem to care enough. This mismatch situation is old news.. But anyway.. Since my last post we have been mismatched again (of course), but this mismatch is beyond crazy.

Clan name: LEGENDS
War Start Date: 29/11/2017
War Start Time (GMT): 23:05 (we are currently on preparation day with 16 hours left)

We have: 9 th10, 8 th9, 3 th8
They have: 12 th11 (seriously?), 3 th10, 2 th9, 3 th8 (clan id: #CYP2GG8L)

You need to understand that this is destroying the game. Not all clans can participate in clan war leagues. Not all people can buy max accounts like the elite war clans. Any more excuses are unacceptable.