Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[TheWhaler]

20171123 gewichtvergelijking war.PNG

Another day, another war ended and another bad match it was.

#LVC9J8LR v #2CJ99LL8

[shafez]

Clan ID:#Q2RUC9UY
Clan name:CO LEADER B
War Start Date:NOV.25
War Start Time (GMT): ABOUT 11:00 GMT
Comment:defenses balanced between us and them but they have heavier and unfair defensless accounts with lots of maxed troops
I thought Warmatching bases on offense now but they have much higher offense than us
OUR CLAN : 2 AQ45 , 1 GW20
ENEMY: 4 AQ45, 3 GW20 ,
they have also some AQ's40's and we have AQ 20's
Heroes make big difference to win war not the troops.

[nobeone]

Clan ID: #LQLQ228J
Clan Name: A New Hope
War started: 25/11/2017 c.09:15
Comment: We have had a series of good matches by which I mean our non-engineered against similar non-engineered, this has allowed us to build a decent (for us) win streak of 7, but now we are matched against an engineering clan. They have a 9.5 at #4, our #4 is a early to mid th10 but has been 'good' and put down infernos, they then have a couple of engineered th11, one with max dragons and th9 lvl defence minus X bows, another lvl 4 dragons and th8 type defence. We may still win, but I don't want to be matched against people trying to game war mm, I want to be matched against similar clans to our own, something I know supercell said this new war mm should deliver.

[rendog131]

Clan ID:#28LYUG0UC
Clan name:lone wolf
War Start Date:11/25/2017
War Start Time (GMT): 5pm GMT
Comment: Running 5v5 wars. So far we have had a disadvantage every war. So we ran a breakdown of what we had been matching against. 3th11s, 1Th10 and 1TH9. Yet this search took almost and hour and matched us with 5 th11s. All with lvl 2 eagles, All the defenses and max troops. 4 out of the 5 players have max heroes. How is basically being down 4 war attacks in a 5v5 fair. 2 of our bases have no chance of defending and they have no hope of 3 starring the opponents base. So it looks to me that we have 6 attacks for 5 bases and they should have 8 attacks for 3 bases.

[Seattlebrew]

Clan ID:2G8QC9YP
Clan: Seattle Brew
Start date:11-24-17
Start time:2:40 gmt
Enemy team fast and furious J8LJOCGG

We have
Th11: 5 two with eagles 3 with infernos
Th10: 2 w/ no infernos
Th9: 3 one with barely any defences.

They have
Th11: 9 two with eagles 5sets of infernos all with Grand Warden. Four of them with no defenses. The bottom 4 with some sort of troop advantages.
Th9: 1 no defenses.

We've typically only get matched with engineered clans as of lately. Sometimes we win but as of lately we've been outmatched by the enemies extra th11 attacks. It seems that either you need to be a max th11 or an engineered base to compete anymore.

[TheWhaler]

Clan ID: #LVC9J8LR
Enemy clan ID: #PJUPQ02Q
Start date (search) 25/11/2017, war date 26/11/2017
War start time 22:00 CET (I guess 21:00 GMT)

I wish I could insert a picture which says a 1000 words, but it's wrong size.
Weight comparison we are (of course) higher.
Offence wise they overpower us heavily.

I'll give a breakdown.
We have 1th11, 7 th10, 8th9, 2th9, 2th7 where 1 th10 is a bit rushed and th11 at 90% th10 lvl
they've 3th 11, 10th10,5th9, 2th7 where 1 th11 is rushed and the other is defensles (as it goes) same for 5 engineerd th10's.
The problem is not always in the defense levels but also in the fact a th10 and 11 carry 25 more troops and more spells then corresponding th 9 en 8's so it makes it much easier for them.

Having said that I do believe we actually stand a change, though their nr1 th11 is a strong base so not easy to get stars for us there.
Lex

[NovoClash]

Current 10 v 10spin is now on 8 hours+. Seriously SC?!?! MM so rigged there isn’t a match in the entire world for so far 8 hours on just a 10v10 spin!! Are you intentionally making your game unusable to the people who have played for years!?!? Nuts. #LC2QUYJ9

[coc4um]

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

Clan id:#8JOJCO9U
Clan name: ShaveMyPekka
War start date: Nov. 25 2017
War start time: approximately 6 pm

[coc4um]

Enemy clan: team flowcoat (#L9OOP82Q)

[Umerqr]

Clan ID: #Q2ULGQRQ
Clan name: Dark Legendz™
War Start Date: 24-11-17
War Start Time (GMT): around 8-9 GMT
Comment: This was the war we lost recently to a mismatch. Since past 4 wars we are losing to a mismatch. The opponent either has at least 1 more eagle artillery than us. In this war we faced 1 extra eagle. I can say we can handle th10 mismatch and we have had, since this new mechanism of urs. We are being mismatched like hell. I don't know what to do anymore... finish all .5s? I have tried everything and we are always short of 1 artillery. Always losing by 1 star or some percentage because Supercell decided to match us up with an extra artillery! 3rd last war we lost we were matched upto 2 extra th11 artilleries. How is that even fair? If u r gonna match us with other engineered clans, sure go ahead but dont put us on a great disadvantage on top th11s. We are not exceptional at th11 attacks that we would triple any th11s we see. Our log has been red cuz of the mismatches and we have never had this long losing streak. Our clan stats are 225-76-0 and total 301. Last 4 wars lost, out of which 3 were mismatched. We may not be great at this game but ur matchmaking is surely giving us a hard time. My clan is suffering a great deal. Many have quit my clan, many are unsure if they are gonna stay. The 4th mismatch is already here and I'm praying that we win this by sheer luck. Supercell has been very kind to us with these matches anyway. Please have a look at our clan's mechanics or whatever its called. Fix this mismatching