Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[MrT22]

Clan uk adult army #8LJ9QQLC
war search 8 November around 10pm

comment just please ease look and tell me how

[NeoGen]

I have finally accepted defeat, the terrible MM has worn me down and I have decided to resign my commission, I hope the MM, improves but after losing 12 of the last 15 wars, I’m not going to hold my breath, we used to win a lot, but now it’s just defeat after defeat, I’m tired of facing multiple engineered TH11’s, as leader I became totally demoralised and enough is enough, it wasn’t broken, so why try to fix it.

[weedeater]

Yeah I agree match making is broken right now and I am getting close to quitting wars. We have lost more wars lately then ever and it's just because the enemy always get an extra eagle or infernos. Can't recover in 10-15 man wars with an extra eagle or infernos we always lose by 1 star or percentage. Even though it looks like a close war we never really had a chance we are just good so we still try but it's demoralizing each and every search I just hope for an even match and we always get the finger. Our war search today if you care to check was at 7:28 pm central standard time our clan is The War Dungeon #LLOCUQY is our tag. They have an extra eagle in a 15 man war and it's 2 maxed th11s nothing else can make up for this even though they are still stacked against us just give us the loss already....

[Petr1Kotlar]

july 24:

"As we have said in the past, one of our most important goals in matchmaking for Clan Wars is to ensure that each Clan is more evenly matched against the other."

LOL

Im pretty sure this is a "talk your mouth out and go to hell" threat.

SC crew on Bahamas enjoying engeneered gem green sun at beach, drinking pinacolada and laughing in our fair face.

Sell the game to somebody who actually knows programming!

more evenly? like: 20 th11 vs 6 th11... 6 eages vs 3 eagles ...fire lavaloon vs th8 troops, rly even...

[freIam]

Start time November 9 ( today) 22:45 gmt
Clan farmergeddon
tag #89VQV2R

I could post a mismatch every other day. It is getting ridiculous.
this war th breakdown th11/10/9/8: we 0/0/12/8 they 1/0/11/8
That th11 has got a maxed eagle, maxed infernos and max xbows.
we have no .5 or engineered bases.
we probably won’t be able to even 2 star that base. He will have no trouble nuking our Top th9s.

[Randalws]

Clan ID:cquc8ly8
Clan name: avengers 8
War Start Date:11/7/17
War Start Time (us central):10am
Comment:I was matched up against a th11 when I am just a th9, was against higher level defense and offense

[Phoenixni]

#LPVRVJ8C
Red Twig
Start: 7/11/17
End: 8/11/17

Too many th 9 at bottom

[ScottDJ]

I have never felt the need to join a forum to express my views, however the latest tweaks to the war matching have driven me to vent our clans frustrations. Clan TAG #989RQV08 vs #LQO2PORC

I don't mind having to overcome an extra th10 or an extra TH11 as per the previous way matches were decided, but since the latest tweak to war matches we are coming up against engineered clans more than ever. I do not think heros and walls should be included to flag that we havnt maxed at the previous th level. Who is going to wait to max walls and heros?/ as long as all the other defences are maxed at the previous level plus 80 percent of troops and spells, that should be enough not to have a flag against you. In this latest war we were matched against 5 TH11 5 TH10 4 TH9 and 1 TH8, vs our 4 TH11 4 Th10 2 TH9 2 Th8 and 3 Th4.. Most of oppo were maxed TH11.. Number 13 vs our TH4 was a Th11 with max air troops that flattened our max TH10 at number 4.. What chance have you got against that... We have been playing this game for over 3 years and we are on the brink of throwing in the towel.. Supercell support doesn't care when we raise a complaint against a poor war match.. I am just trying this forum to advise supercell you have handed wars back to engineered bases good and proper.. At least on the old system the Th11 @ 13 on oppo would have had a big penalty making him equivalent to a low Th10.. not a flag that all of us have got due to low heros and walls from not maxing at previous th level.. Someone please tell me what Supercell are doing about this, please revert back to the old system as it wasn't brilliant, but a damn sight more fairer than the new one.

[ChiefTuk]

Haven't had time to post before, but here's an example of our most common type of mismatch:

Clan ID: #2CR0QQC
Clan Name: Bellum Tigers
War Search: 11-6-17, 03:30 GMT

Heroes are BK/AQ/GW
Us:

TH10 40/40/x Fully max
TH10 24/36/x Nearly maxed troops, max defenses
TH10 32/30/x Nearly maxed troops, lvl 1 infernos, 2 lvl 3 xbows, lvl 12 point defense
TH10 25/28/x Mostly max troops, lvl 1 infernos, 2 lvl 3 xbows, lvl 12/13 point defenses
TH9.5 20/25/x lv 6 hogs, lvl 5 golem/valks, lvl 3 hounds, 2 lvl 3 xbows, lvl 11 point defense
TH9 27/28/x max troops, max defense
TH9 25/21/x max troops, max defense
TH9 20/18/x max troops, lvl 2 xbows, lvl 11 point defense
TH9 10/10/x max troops, lvl 1 xbows, lvl 11 point defense
TH8.5 11/20/x lvl 3 valks, lvl 1 witches, rest of troops maxed, lv 11 point defense
TH8.5 6/7/x lvl 4 drags, lvl 4 hogs, rest of troops TH8 level, lv 11 point defense
TH8 9/x/x lvl 3 drags, lvl 3 pekka, lvl 4 hogs, lvl 1 valks/golems, max defense
TH8 8/x/x max offense, max defense
TH8 6/x/x lvl 3 drags, mostly TH7 defense (fresh TH8)
TH7 x/x/x with TH6 offense & defense (no dragons be here)

Them:
TH10 21/24/x max troops, max defense
TH10 24/40/x max troops, lvl 3 infernos, 3 lvl 4 xbows, lvl 12 point defense
TH10 10/10/x TH10 GoLaLoon, lvl 1 bowitch, lvl 1 infernos, 3 lvl 3 xbows, lvl 11/12 point defense
TH10.5 10/15/18 Max LaLo, max bowitch, max valks, lv 7 cc, 3 lvl 4 xbows, lvl 12/13 point defense
TH10.5 26/30/15 max LaLo, Max bowitch, max valks, lvl 7 cc, maxTH9 defense
TH10.5 22/29/14 max lalo, max bowitch, lvl 7 cc, 2 lvl 3 xbows, mostly lvl 11/12 point defense
TH9 13/21/x max troops, except witches, max defense
TH9.5 7/5/x lvl 5 drags & lvl 3 lava, lvl 6 loons, other troops weak, 2 lvl 1 xbows, lvl 11 point defense
TH8.5 8/8/x max th 9 lalo, lvl 4 drags, other troops weak, th9 anti air defense, ground mostly th8
TH10.5 6/3/x lvl 4 drags, rest weak, 2 lvl 1 xbows, 4 lvl 6 ad, th8 point defense
TH9.5 6/5/x lvl 4 drags, rest weak, 4 lvl 7 ad, mix of th8/9 point defense
TH8.5 6/3/x lvl 3 drags, lvl 4 sf, 4 lvl 7 ad, rest of defense TH8, weak splash
TH8.5 10/3/x max TH8 offense with lvl 4 sf, max th8 defense
TH8 10/x/x lvl 3 drags, rest of troops mid th8, max defense
TH8 x/x/x lvl 2 drags, rest weak, 3 lvl 5 ad, rest missing or low level defense


On paper, they had an easy path to 41 to 43 stars, with a better chance at a perfect war than us. The TH10.5s proved to be mediocre attackers & their overall war plan was sloppy. They gave up after we tripled their #2 & #3, thanks to them putting up common ring bases. We wound up winning by 42-35.

The more common result is we lose by a star or two. I'd guess we face this type of lineup about a quarter of the time. We are running some lopsided, so I can't complain about facing clans running more lopsided TH9s or having an extra full TH10 or two at the top. The ironic thing is the one time I put my very lopsided 10.5 in war, we faced a straight up maxing clan. Last month, we lost 3 in a row to this type of lineup, despite my holding our more lopsided bases out. It's almost as if my max TH10 is being counted as hyper-engineered...

[ChiefTuk]

I've also avoided this thread because most of the comments are real downers. There will always be matchups that don't favor your clan, folks. If SC matched strictly by TH level per lane, clans would start focusing on running only fully maxed bases to gain advantage. Having your mid TH9/10/11 facing fully maxed equivalents wouldn't feel much better than facing engineers does. I find it hard to believe that clans who were winning more than 70% of wars before aren't doing so now, unless they were really poorly thought out engineer clans.

Pay attention to your base designs! If you have people running common war bases, you are just asking for it. We've won more than a few wars because I discourage my clan from using bases found on the Internet as their war bases. Instead, I either pass them my old bases or tell them to copy an opponent's base when I see a good, original layout in war.

Good base designs are as important as good attack strategies. It's not simply maxing defenses, it's maximizing the defenses you have!