Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[Thegreatpuma]

Clan ID: #ULOY9G9Y
Clan name: TMBG
War Start Date: 8/15/2018
War Start Time (GMT): ~20:45
Comment: HOnestly, this is a joke. They came in with a 19 war winning streak (including 17 straight perfects), we came in with 5 (four of those were perfect). If recent war performance is taken into account it appears to only have been taken into account on our side. Even with a power potion we had little shot at their near max TH9 anchor, while they had it quite easy considering their streak. They either matched us or had us out gunned at EVERY position in the war. We had no prayer. Overall they had us by nearly 70K weight in gold, 17 queen levels and 3 king levels. And as expected we lost 29-30.

US:

Position	TH	King	Queen	Weight
1	9	10	1	57000	No xbows.
2	8	8	-	54000
3	8	5	-	36000
4	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
5	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
6	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
7	6	-	-	29000	Near max
8	6	-	-	24000	low level 6
9	4	-	-	10000
10	3	-	-	5000
		23	1	305000
	6.2	7.6667

THEM:

Position	TH	King	Queen	Gold Weight
1	9	11	19	68000	Maxed d, except walls.
2	8	10	-	54000	Maxed except walls
3	7	5	-	40000	Maxed
4	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
5	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
6	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
7	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
8	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
9	6	-	-	30000	Maxed
10	6	-	-	29000	near max,handful of walls left
		26	19	371000
	6.6	8.6667

[Metaghost]

Clan ID: #2GYR88VP
Clan name: NitroMixers
War Start Date: August 17th 2018 (GMT)
War Start Time (GMT): approx. 03:46
Comment:
What bothers me the most is the waste of time most of these attacks will be. there is no loot and no challenge in facing an opponent with one cannon bases. like, the loot bonus is a key ingredient in upgrades and progression and facing opponents like this is a waste of time. The gaining of war stars feels empty and pointless.

[Saulosi]

Our last 3 wars have been against heavily engineered clans. What changed? We had a 10 war winning streak going. Was that our problem? The only significant base change was one base went from th10 to th11 and gemmed the lab and war troops.

Our clan tag is: #LVRQRR8Q war coalition.
We do 10v10 wars. Our top 2 ( or 3 ) bases are th11. Then 3 th10s, then th9s.
No engineering on our side during these last 3 wars in which our opponents had 2 more th11s than is. Last war their defenseless th11 at #9 had their best attack on our 1 and 2. That's just wrong.

The new th11 was one of my accounts. I sat it for the war search that we just did an hour ago. I was afraid it was being penalized for th11 offense, but no defense. Now we have 2 th11 up top and they have 3 plus an extra th10. Both of their extra bases are engineered / low on the lineup.

For a while it seemed like the matching algorithm was working hard to line up the top bases. If we had a th11 low on the lineup , so did our enemy.


If something changed , change it back.

[Saulosi]

Here I am again. Clan tag #LVRQRR8Q
Current war is 10v10.

We have 2 th11s up top. Neither with an eagle. Level 5 infernos on #1, lvl 4 on #2
Then 2 th10s. Lvl 1 infernos on #3, none on #4
Then 3 near max th9s
Then 1 th10 bozo with level 3 xbows, but th8-9 other defenses
Then 2 low level th9s. Not rushed

Their lineup:
1 is th12 with max eagle, infernos, 5 star giga-tesla, and 1 xbow. Archer towers are lvl 13. Heroes are weak (35,46,16), but war troops max.
2 is max th10
3 is engineered th11 without xbows or infernos. Upgraded war troops
4 is th10 with th9 defense. But th10 war troops.
Then 5-8 max th9s
Then 2 low level th9s.


We are not engineers. We are maxers. How on earth do we get matched with a high level th12 when our top base is a medium th11?

Why have we gone for a month or more with normal pairings with our top bases and now, all of a sudden, 4 wars in a row are screwed up again?!

[KilledbyMe]

Clan Id : SUNBEAM
Clan tag : #9VU8URP8
25 August 02.00 GMT Jakarta (enemy clan tag #89LUVV28

Again and again Mission impossible. Nice work matchmaker

[Kathlee]

Clan ID#2CJPYYJ0
Clan Name The Aesir
War Start Date 8/25/18
War Start Time 2:54 PM GMT
Fought Korean Team Clan ID #9YJGYOU8

Comments: They have won 234 wars but we have won only 126. We were a level 10 clan during the war yet they were a level 13. Their total points were 266694 - 25301. Our total points were 18930 - 19049. They had 36 members to choose from we had 25. Of these factors I believe the number of wars won and the Clan Level are the most important to consider when pairing clans for battles. Our clan is demoralized by repeatedly being paired with clan who are stronger than we are and beat us. Come on guys gives us a fair break here and give us an opponent we have a chance of beating.

[PhedUp]

What can I say. 113 pages of people complaining about war matchmaking and giving some solid examples and it is still going on. We get terrible matchups every war and just got another. I don't think supercell is listening.

[Ajax]

What can I say. 113 pages of people complaining about war matchmaking and giving some solid examples and it is still going on. We get terrible matchups every war and just got another. I don't think supercell is listening.

It has improved tremendously from our POV since this thread started. At that time, we were getting mostly engineered opponents, and were losing a very large proportion of our warts.

We have NOT gone down the engineering route at all, but we have been seeing fewer and fewer engineered clans, and are now winning around half our wars (we never were that brilliant as attackers TBH, although we used to win about 60%).

[ericvon]

Just curious... seems since 2 maintenance breaks ago we have been matched up against engineered clans. We are not engineered at all... was hoping this last break fixed it... but yet again. We are in a 20 v 20. With at least 5 of our enemy engineered. Including a th 11 in the no 20 spot.... smh
Clan ID: #PGUGJP0L
Clan Name: Black Dynasty
War prep start date : August 28th 2018
Battlw day start time August 29th @10:30 am us eastern time... think 2:30pm GMT

[ericvon]

Oops. Think its actually 2:30pm GMT for battle day start. Sorry😜