[QUOTE=ChiefSaral;11814131]
We won the war despite of the huge difference!
Yehawww!!😎
[QUOTE=ChiefSaral;11814131]
We won the war despite of the huge difference!
Yehawww!!😎
Clan ID: #ULOY9G9Y
Clan name: TMBG
War Start Date: 7/28/2018
War Start Time (GMT): ~03:00
Comment: While we have an overall hero advantage, they have an anchor that is impossible for us to three star, and we will be lucky if we 2* it. Their top 5 easily take out our top 10, so on paper they should win. I am wholly unsure why the matchmaker felt that our heroes, small TH8 advantage, and TH6 advantage should make up for a lopsided anchor base.
Us:
Position TH King Queen Weight 1 8 10 - 54000 2 8 10 - 53000 3 7 4 - 39000 4 6 - - 30000 5 6 - - 30000 6 6 - - 30000 7 6 - - 29000 8 6 - - 27000 9 6 - - 22000 10 3 - - 5000
Them:
Position TH King Queen Weight 1 9 8 7 59000 All TH8 defenses upgraded to TH9 level. Only new TH9 defense purchased is l7 Archer tower. Army camps upgraded. All troops open, Hogs, Valk, Golem, BD upgraded to max TH9 along with most elixir troops 2 8 7 - 52000 3 7 1 - 34000 4 6 - - 28000 5 6 - - 27000 6 6 - - 27000 7 6 - - 26000 8 6 - - 25000 9 4 - - 10000 10 4 - - 27000
Last edited by Thegreatpuma; July 28th, 2018 at 06:42 PM.
Black Box #GRLQ98G8
war starts 12 pm July 31
War ends 12 pm Aug 1
The opponents bottom base is a maxed out th11 with 1 archer tower 3 cannons 1 mortor all th8 lvl and mid to low heros. He has max camps and high level troops. Including the new items.
He can easily take out our top bases and fill the war path with troops our mid to low bases can't not kill easily. Ie max electro drag.
Paving the way for their near max th10s to go after 3 thru 8. It's practically a free win. It's the cheapest strategy in the game.
Clan dozers #YPPV88Q8
Started 31/07/18
Ends 01/08/18
Really bad mismatch. probably the worst we've seen for a while, the other Clan are true engineers not just rushed.
Us: 3 X Th12, 1x th11, 4xth10 (of which 2 are brand new upgraded), 2xth9, 1 xth8, 2x th7, 2xth5 (,fillers as we were short 2 for a 15 war)
Them: 3 X Th12, 3 X th11, 5 X th10, 1 X th9, 1 X th8, 2 X th7. All of the th11 had max troops and a gw, the th10's had bowlers.
Our th8 was opposite a th11!
Ridiculously bad mismatch!!
We were just in. 50v50 war that is the most lopsided I’ve seen. We were outnumbered in th12, th11, and th10. Much of this, of course is due to engineering. We made it up in th8, but that obviously won’t cut it when 60 percent of the clan is th10 or higher. I assume you prefer to see villages that are balanced between offense and defense. That is, I assume you want to penalize engineered bases so they don’t impact war as much as they do today.
Heres how to do it:
1) dont allow potions in wars
2) normalize ratings for offense and defense. That is, maximum weight for offense would be 10,000 and maximum weight for defense would be 10,000
3) calculate the war weight of each village as max(offense,defense) + min(offense,defense) * .05
that is, a village counts for its max between offense and defense plus 5 percent of the weighting for the other category. That way, an unbalanced village is actually a penalty in wars.
It is important to take potions out, as that would allow a defensive weighted village to up its offense unfairly during war.
Sir darian :any tips for getting fair matches?
Yet another mis-matched war!!
What's going on? Have supercell messed with the war mm again? Because if they have please, please stop it and revert it!! We've now had 4 bad matches in a row!!
None of our bases are engineered yet we're being matches to the worst engineered clans I've ever seen!! We're getting fed up of seeing engineered th11 at the bottom of the war map where we have th8's and 7's.
Current war mismatch (our last 3 before this one were mismatched too)
Clan tag #YPPV88Q8
Start date 08/08/18
End date 09/08/18
Us..4xth12, 2xth11, 2xth10, 4xth9, 1xth8, 1xth7, 1xth5.
Them.. 5xth12, 5xth11, 2xth10, 3xth9.
I can only assume the goal is to make us give up wars because that's how we feel right now..like giving up. None of our bases are engineered so why are we getting these dreadful mismatches???
Current mismatch took over 3 hrs to find.
We 're expecting another loss just like the three wars prior to this one simply because they have more high lvl attacks than we do.
It's soul destroying going into these wars knowing we won't win unless there's a miracle? Please stop them.
Just curious if anyone else is now having bad war matches with a lot of engineers again all of a sudden? You know, TH11s with th9s weapons but max troops, or max troops in war thanks to potion use?
Anytime we bring a th12 in war, the random spin is terrible. Feels as bad to us as it did before it was "fixed". Before th12 we started getting good matches. No engineers. Sweet. Almost a good match like an arranged war. Now it is that sad matching again that turns you off random spins.
Others getting this now, or you matching good? Just curious.
If the matches are good for you, are you bringing in 12s?
We have 5 th12’s and the matching lately has been good for us. We get anywhere from 4 to 6 other th12 matched against us. Regardless, all wars have been close with all th11 down 3 starred (30 person wars) and a battle at the top.
TH12
Playing since 1 Jan 2014
In my previous clan, matches have been fairly equal. We take 1-2 (mostly 1) TH12s. Enemy also has 1-2 (more 2 than 1) TH12s.
Some time we have more TH12 (2 to their 1) but their TH9s are all maxed defense including walls (some max 9 heroes). Our 9s are weak.
We're casual though. Our lineup was anything between 1-1-3-8-2 to 2-1-4-7-1.
I don't know if you take more than 2 TH12s.
Anyway it's pretty equal. That was until a week ago since now I wasn't in that clan.
