Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[Vikingchief]

Darian has asked us not to enter debate or discussion in this thread, as it will drown out the valuable info very quickly.

[KZVG55]

Apologies for the earlier trolling (couldn't resist) but here's a suggestion: a good red flag for heavy Engineers is when there is suddenly a town hall 11 far below his 9,10 comrades. Usually the Bowler, Lavahound, Balloon, Miner are maxed (any if not all of them).

There should be a way for matchmaking to specifically also identify these players. Sometimes they appear in the 4-7 range in a 15-20 man war below lower town halls (they are usually below a max 9 or 10). Sometimes they appear even lower down depending on their lack of defense.

Maybe try to implement an additional parameter into matchmaking that will link up these TH11s with an opponent with a near-max th11 defense. If they have maxed key troops it's only fair to meet near max defense and not bully a th10 in war.

[Shipwreck77]

Our latest match is terrible! Our clan tag #99RV8GJ2

Enemy tag #22QPVL9G

Our line up 15 vs 15

Town hall 11 with eagle
Town hall 11 no eagle
3 -7 town hall 10 with infernos
8 town hall 10 no inferno
9-11 town hall 9
12 and 13 town hall 9 no xbows
14 town hall 8
15 town hall 7

Enemy line up

1 and 2 town hall 11 with eagles
3 and 4 town hall 10 with infernos
5 town hall 11 warden no infernos 4 xbows
6 and 7 town hall 10 no infernos 2 xbows
8 town hall 11 warden xbows no infernos
9 to 11 town hall 9 with xbows
12 town hall 9 no xbows
13 town hall 10 with town hall 8 defences 2 big wizard towers
14 Town hall 8 with only 2 wizard towers
15 town hall 8

[dfox]

Clan- #LU8RORV New World
War starts at 11am gmt 21st March 2018.

10verse10 war
US
th11 4 strong with eagle ( strong heros)1 strong without eagle(strong heros), 2 new without eagle( 1 has strong heros the other 35/30/5)
th10 2 mid strength (mid heros)1 new (mid heros)

THEM
TH11 8 strong with eagle (all strong hero)
th10 1 max, 1 near max (both strong heros)

The problem with this matchup is they get an easy 25 stars and we get an easy 22 stars.
Both sides will need to 3 star near max th11 bases to improve on those figures .
Ultimately we need to 3 star, 3 near max th11 just to match there easier attacks.

So basically.....
They have stronger heros, way more max attacks, way stronger defences.

[Flatwing]

It seemed up to the last update, that the mismatching was fixed. The last two wars we are getting engineered idiots again. Last war defenseless from 10 to 15, extra engineered 11 sitting at number 4 with a level 10 warden. This one has an extra th 11 with maxed troops , mid level defenses, 40/41/20, so they have an extra warden/ eagle . None of their 9 s have xbows, they have a 10 sitting midway on the map with th 8 defenses and one lvl 2 inferno. I can’t see how supercell can not match top bases, with max troops, wardens and eagles. As a clan we are just about done. We have an excellent war log but hate losing before we even drop a troop. Note we are running no engineered bases.

[rootrider]

Clan ID: #RR2RPYQ
Clan name: Die Halunken
War Start Date: 20.03.2018
War Start Time (GMT): 20:22

Comment: warweight mismatch. One TH11 and two TH10 (them) against two TH10 and one TH9 (us). The opponents TH11 was almost maxed, also the troops he played only the eagle was missing. They gained an easy 45 Stars in a 15 vs 15 battle, we could do only 39. No chance on opponents TH11.

[Flatwing]

15v15

Ours

1- Maxed 11
3- maxed 10s
2 maxed 9 s 22/27, 20/20
1- 9 maxed except walls, 15/16
1- new th 9
2 maxed th 8s
2 maxed 7 s
1 maxed 6
1 maxed 5

Theirs

1 Th 11 maxed except walls 37/42/20 maxed troops
1 Th 11 mid level defenses 40/42/20 maxed troops
1 Th 10 maxed defenses except walls 29/30
1 th 10 almost maxed defenses except walls ( mostly LEGO) 20/28
1 th 9 maxed 10/28
1 th 10 with one inferno, Th 8 defenses 7/10 , maxed th 9 troops
2 8.5
2 maxed 8 s
3 new 8
2 new 7 s

[Starwars9877]

Clan tag - #POCLLCY2
Name - Hurricane 2
start time approx - March 20 2018 9:00 pm
time zone - CST

War matchmaking - They are little stronger at top - but that is not a huge deal. The issue is their #13 base - engineered base 3 starring our #3 and our #4 base. Engineering has been a problem for a while, but now they can use the new spell to maximize troops for their town hall .... as this player did against our #3 base. I see this as a huge issue going foward. It will get even worse when th12 is added. War was the best part of the game. Clan games are okay ... but are too long and for a working adult ... they tend to wear you out and seem like an additional job. Just want to play the game and have a little fun.

[KatCanada]

It seemed up to the last update, that the mismatching was fixed. The last two wars we are getting engineered idiots again. Last war defenseless from 10 to 15, extra engineered 11 sitting at number 4 with a level 10 warden. This one has an extra th 11 with maxed troops , mid level defenses, 40/41/20, so they have an extra warden/ eagle . None of their 9 s have xbows, they have a 10 sitting midway on the map with th 8 defenses and one lvl 2 inferno. I can’t see how supercell can not match top bases, with max troops, wardens and eagles. As a clan we are just about done. We have an excellent war log but hate losing before we even drop a troop. Note we are running no engineered bases.

I 100% agree with Flatwing...past 2 wars, engi clans again with low th11s and everyone dips accordingly and bulldozes a base one th below them. Before that was actually good matchmaking for a bit.

[Flatwing]

It seemed we were getting our exact mirror with maybe one unfair one thrown in for about 10 wars. We also searched for two hours, which is fine if the war is fair. Now it seems like we are right back to where we started. I know the talent pool in lower level wars ain't so hot but I hate getting beat by people who dip on every attack. Give them an extra 9 or even mid level 10 but seeing a th 11 with low defenses midway on the map with a maxed warden is stupid.