Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[GrudgeTaker]

Clan ID: #Y9LJC2Y9
Clan name: Clan Warriors!
War Start Date: 23/01/18
War Start Time (GMT): 18:20
Comments: 5 vs 5 war, we have two th11s, two th10s and a th9, the enemy are all th11s. Absolute joke of a match up, they all have max troops. THIS SHOULD NOT HAPPEN.

[wotanwaton]

opponent clan: #PU29R80C
war start: 2018/01/21 11:30p.m. EET
war size: 40vs40

we: no engineered (some rushed)
12 - th 11
14 - th 10
8 - th 9
2 - th 8
1 - th 7
1 - th 5
1 - th 4
1 - th 3


oponent:
12 - th 11
12 - th 10
5 - th 9
2 - th 8

2 - th 11 - no eagle
7 - th 11 - no eagle no inferno and some other buildings left

[HalfBloodPrince]

Clan ID: #YYQQ09
Clan name: PHi
War Start Date: 23 Jan, 2018
War Start Time (GMT): 10:37AM (GMT)
Comment: They got 11 TH11s against our 4 TH11s. Do you call it justice?

[Pluribus]

#PQ9992RJ
War start 1/22 @ 900 pm EST
War end 1/23 @ 900 pm EST

10v10 war
We have one TH11 they have two. The second one is in the 6th position and three starred our 2 and 77%our 1.

When is this cheap play going to end?

[MadSkeletor]

Clan ID: #9VYURJ8R
Clan name: Twisted Ronin
War Start Date: 01/22/18
War Start Time (GMT): 10:40 CST
Comment:
Our breakdown: 21 TH11 (18 with Eagle Artillery, all with infernos), 3 TH10 (2 with infernos, 1 new), 1 TH9
Their breakdown: 25 TH11 (all with Eagle Artillery, all with infernos)

Yeah, we have no chance with that matchup unless they don't attack (spoiler: they attacked)

[NikhilThakrani]

Hi,My Name Is Nikhil Thakrani and I am Co leader of clan name "COC TeamWork"

MY TAG: #9G20V02Y9

CLAN TAG: #RQ8CCJ00

Check the base of our Opponent Clan War

The opponent's clan has always been townhall 11 of 1nd and 2nd base and our townhall 9 base

If we have a townhall 9 then how can we hit the tohall 10 and townhall 11?

We are losing the war for this reason and our player leaving to play this game..

Why is this injustice happening with us?
we are not able to play?

This happens to us so often But this time enough is enough

First clan of our clan War opponents Townhall 11 Max and our 1st player is towhall 9 max.


Opponent's 2nd player is towhall 10 and our 2nd player is towhall 9..

Why is this injustice happening with us?

we are not able to play?

You check our War Base and Opponent War Base

Please fix it soon else we are all leaving to playing this game

[Poonbe]

Clan ID: #99PCR2QL
Clan name: The Melting Pot
War Start Date:22/Jan/2018
War Start Time (GMT): 11pm
Comment:

2hrs to find match and ended up against engineered base Opponent #20-11 x th11 engineered, 2xth9, 3xth10 and remainder th11 at top.

our lower th was out done by the clan castle (35 spaces) so hard to kill off.

We have noticed that, the longer it takes to search for a match the more unbalance the opponent becomes, mostly against us.

[StormHeart]

Clan ID: #8LJ0CV98
Clan name: Stormy Knights
War Start Date: 1-25-18
War Start Time (Manila Time): approx 7:15 pm

Engineers, TH10 with max camps and level 3 miners and hounds, TH9 at the bottom of the map with max pentalaloon and dragons

The TH10 should EASILY kill our top two 9s. We have no chance of winning this war. We will be playing for a tie.

[jimzaxspeed]

Clan Id: #Y9CP92PO
Name:Milk Bandits
War Start Date: War Starts 25th Jan 2018
War Start Time: GMT 13:29 GMT


Opposition clan
Id: #8RRRRG29
Name: SniperPH


We are a regular no-rush clan.
20 vs 20 war
4 x TH 11
7 x TH 10
7 x TH 9
2 x TH 8


Our opponents are well matched from roster 1 to 13.
They have 5x TH11 at the top of their roster - one more than us - but that's OK.
Then the TH10's more or less balance and the top couple of TH9's.


Then comes the kick in the guts.
Their no 14 is a th11 with one cannon no archer towers - none at all, no eagle etc... of course they do have grand warden.
Their no 15 is a th11 with no infernos, no eagle, level 7 archer towers, level 5 air defenses, and of course they also have a grand warden.


Here is the problem. These two TH11 bases are in the middle of the "TH9" section of our roster.
Our TH9s will crush them easily - two boring no challenge attacks for someone on our team.
Then our opponents get 4 TH 11 attacks on us - plus the extra one they have at the top of the roster.
In otherwords we have 8 TH11 attacks and they have 14. Yes 8 v 14 is considered a good match up???


Sort it out Supercell - penalize the engineers or else the future of clash wars will be engineers.

[Thegreatpuma]

I kinda feel bad for the clan we're about to attack. Here's the matchup:

Clan ID US - #9UQCYLCO, them - #J8JGJLGR8
Clan name: us - Newbie Klan them - <foreign>
War Start Date: 1/24/18
War Start Time (GMT): 22:39
Comment:

Where to start...we have some engineered bases but we're pretty much scratch level engineers. we have a max TH9 that just turned 10 and a TH9 nearly maxed as our top two bases (and 8 down to base 5). They have a couple maxed TH8 as their top two (and 8 down to base 8). We both have some engineered bases, for engineers they have:

1 - TH11 with all three heroes, although they are low level 5/2/4. Best troop combo is lava loon 6/2, but has crappy rage and no haste
1 - TH10 heroes 8/10, l5 drag, l6 loon, l2 lava, has access to all troops (so can use the max potion to its fullest)
1 - TH9 heroes 6/3, l4 drag, l5 loon, not much else to speak of.

our engineers:

1 - TH10 l4 drag l6 loon heroes 10/0
1 - TH10 l4 drag l6 loon and all dark troops open, but no normal troops past TH8.
1 - TH8 maxed troops.

I really don't see how this is fair for them. They can kinda make it fair if there TH10 has a troop maximizer potion.


I have to say though, that most of our matchups have been better. it seems to match us consistently with other clans with engineered bases. Where we get killed is when we get matched up with the extreme engineers - the ones who know what they're doing. We don't really know what we're doing, hence the "scratch" term I used to describe us, heh. I'll update this post with the results.



We ended up winning 45-43. Their two major engineers couldn't 3* our top base, only got one star. We had little trouble burying them and had their top four bases gone quickly.