Page 64 of 102 FirstFirst ... 1454626364656674 ... LastLast
Results 631 to 640 of 1012

  Click here to go to the first staff post in this thread.   Thread: Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

  1. #631
    Pro Member nobeone's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2015
    Location
    Deepest darkest Devon
    Posts
    535
    Clan ID: #LQLQ228J
    Clan name: A New Hope
    War start: 12/01/2018 c.01:00 UK time
    Comment: we are balanced all defences placed:

    3 x TH11
    3 x TH10
    3 x TH9
    11 x TH8 in a 20v20.

    They are:

    4 x TH11 all defences placed
    1 x TH10 all defences placed
    1 x TH11 with eagle, 1 inferno, 3 x bows and reduced defence
    1 x TH11 with no eagle, 1 inferno, 3 x bows and reduced defence
    3 x TH9 with all defences placed
    2 x TH9 with no x bows
    1 x TH9 with 1 x bow
    3 x TH8 all defences placed
    1 x TH9 low defences
    2 x TH7 all defences placed

    This is not even close to matching builds, not even near, nowhere infact. We are down several eagles, several TH11, a huge number of TH9, they have a crazy huge advantage on offence. Why do you think they rushed a couple of bases to TH11? It's the power potion stupid! Please stop it being used in war, preferably before this war starts

  2. #632
    New Bloke/Chick
    Join Date
    Sep 2014
    Posts
    47
    Here we go again.
    2x wars in a row.
    Clan Id: #Y9CP92PO
    Name:Milk Bandits
    War Start Date: 12th January 2018 - prep starts. War Starts 12th Jan 2018
    War Start Time: GMT 16:51

    Opposition clan
    Id: #9QGCPOQP
    Name: brutust
    Lvl 14 clan (engineering works)

    Us
    1-3 TH 11 (eagles)
    4-9 TH 10 – no rush
    10-17 TH 9 – no rush
    18-20 TH 8/7

    Them
    1-3TH 11 (eagles)
    4-10 TH 10
    11-12 TH 11 (engineered, strong troops and warden, no Eagle, no inferno, #12 has no x-bows)
    13-14 TH10 – rushed weak troops and defences, but will use the blue potion on war day.
    15-19 TH9 –with weak air defences.
    20 TH8

    So once again the war matching process gives us the following:
    - A war we are unlikely to win.
    - A boring war for the TH9’s in our clan who will crush the rushed opposition bases at the bottom of their roster.
    - Lots of easy overpowered TH11 attacks for our lazy opponents who don’t want to grind and update walls and defences.’
    Some in our clan are complaining – but others are saying if we can’t beat ‘em join ‘em and let us make some engineers – particularly with the builder books and blue potions from clan games making it easier than ever to engineer a base.
    This is a disaster for clash. War is by far the most interesting part of the game – can you design an anti-three star base? Can you attack one? Engineered rosters are taking this away. Can you design a TH9 base that will keep out a TH11? No you cannot, doesn’t matter how hard you try. Can you as a TH9 beat a rushed base with no x-bows and low level air defences – yes every time, easy. Then you lose the war.

    Supercell it is time to penalize attacks on the TH below you in war (unless it is your roster mirror) - two stars max available.

  3. #633
    Fresh Spawn
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Posts
    4
    Has there been any conclusions on this 'study'? Any responces? Aren't SuperCell monitoring and evaluating automatically? Do you still want our crazy mismatches, or is posting here a waste of time?

  4. #634
    Millennial Club Colin94's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,310
    Clan ID: #PJ8Q00QJ
    Clan name: Muskie Tears
    War Start Date: 13.01.18
    War Start Time (GMT): 10:00 pm
    Comment: Our new th11s matched max th11s again. All of our top 4 bases have weaker defense and offense.

    Can't you see the difference between those two bases??? You don't want people to make engineered accounts but you match new th11 against maxed th11 ... your developers are probably still th9
    It's much harder to 3 star a maxed th11 than to 3 star a new th11! How many times do I need to repeat this?!

    (Ali, you don't need to copy this base. It's a decoy base. )

    Last edited by Colin94; January 12th, 2018 at 11:45 PM.


  5. #635
    Centennial Club
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Posts
    143
    Quote Originally Posted by Colin94 View Post
    Clan ID: #PJ8Q00QJ
    Clan name: Muskie Tears
    War Start Date: 13.01.18
    War Start Time (GMT): 10:00 pm
    Comment: Our new th11s matched max th11s again. All of our top 4 bases have weaker defense and offense.

    Can't you see the difference between those two bases??? You don't want people to make engineered accounts but you match new th11 against maxed th11 ... your developers are probably still th9
    It's much harder to 3 star a maxed th11 than to 3 star a new th11! How many times do I need to repeat this?!

    (Ali, you don't need to copy this base. It's a decoy base. )

    And this is what happens when you place all the new defenses and don't go the .5 route after upgrading your townhall.

  6. #636

    Mismatch save us

    Id: 9PJO8YCO
    CLAN NAME: 301 SPARTANS
    START TIME: 9.30AM ,13 january,2017(5.30+gmt)

  7. #637
    Millennial Club Colin94's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    1,310
    Quote Originally Posted by urulaia View Post
    And this is what happens when you place all the new defenses and don't go the .5 route after upgrading your townhall.
    Yeah ... I believed Darian when he said that SC is going to fix wars. Nothing happened. Engineers and .5 are still much better for wars than bases that upgrade without trying to exploit the poor matchmaking algorithm.


  8. #638
    Clan name: Murcianicos War
    Clan ID: #YOQUO280
    Start: Friday 12-01-2018

    Our bases:
    4 th11
    8 th10
    5 th9
    1 th8
    1 th7
    1 th5

    Their bases:
    12 th11 (!!!)
    3 th10
    5 th9

    Pretty much sucks the fun out of warring...

  9. #639
    I've noticed it's seemed worse lately. Pretty much the worse it's been since wars started.

    Clan name: Demigods
    Clan ID: #9J0RLRQG
    Start: Friday 01/12/2018 3:03PM (PST) (10:03PM GMT)
    Comment:

    Us:
    11s - 9
    10s - 8
    9s - 8

    Them:
    11s - 15
    10s - 7
    9s - 0
    8s - 3

    Intersting no 9's vs 8... going be rough.

  10. #640
    War mismatch-
    our clan name: Critical-Error
    clan ID: #CRJLC8C
    War start date: Jan 12
    War start time: about 9 pm Pacific Time
    comment: opposing clan had 12 TH11s to our 5 and they were engineered - pretty frustrating to have no chance...

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •