Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[enderchar]

Clan ID: #QJVRUGGY
Clan name: LOSTERRANOS
War Start Date: 27-12-2017
War Start Time (GMT): 12:00 P.M.
Enemy Clan ID: #UC8LVCC0
Comment: The enemy clan is a Multi-Accounts Clan. All accounts have the same name and are TH9 except 2 accounts that are TH11. Our clan did not have much opportunity because we have very varied accounts. The only ones that could attack were the TH7, TH8 and TH9 that were more or less improved their defenses. The lowest accounts (TH6, TH5 and TH4) could not participate in the war because it was really hard to get them a star.
You can see much better how the clan is composed in these captures: https://imgur.com/a/TnEtZ

[enderchar]

Clan ID: #QJVRUGGY
Clan name: LOSTERRANOS
War Start Date: 29-12-2017
War Start Time (GMT): 12:00 P.M.
Enemy Clan ID: #J9JR9JLR
Comment: The clan is also a multi-accounts. The clan has a TH11 account, two TH10 accounts, fourteen TH9 accounts, thirty two TH8 accounts and one TH5 account. With this clan we have no chance to win either. These last two wars the balance has been disastrous. With the previous wars the balance was more or less bearable but the algorithm is not working very well. The truth is that all members of the clan are very astonished with these last two wars because they do not match almost anything with what we normally see. Hopefully they will improve the algorithm because practically we can not do more wars like that under these conditions. We will always lose if this abrupt swing continues like this.
We hope the engineers can perfect this matter a bit. Thank you very much.

[Himewad]

Clan ID: #8PJYRVCL
Clan name: HeroesLand
War Start Date: 12/29/2017
War Start Time (GMT): GMT -6:00 (Central Time USA)
Comment: 15v15 war ... we have 4 th11s, 6 th10s, 5 th9s ... they have 8 th11s and 7 th10s. ‘Nuff said.

[neon0007]

Clan I'D: #P8YOJ2P2
Name: British Adults
Start Date: 30.12.17
Start Time: 12:41pm

It's almost every war now we've got a ridiculous match up. Members have now began to quit the clan and the game. Something needs to be done..

All clans are now doing is maxing troops at th11 whilst having th9 defences. it's now gone so far our th7 and 8 bases are all facing th11s with th9 max defenses whilst they've also got th11 troops. How can we compete with that? Again all our bottom guys can do nothing and out top guys are stretched too far to compete.


Supercell as usual have left the game lose it's original purpose. Just like when CCs were left outside. Supercell left it so long they nearly destroyed the game. Again they're allowing unfair base building to punish those who play by the game design. Either the old school players will all have to just quit or Supercell will have to change something quick.

The game is been totally destroyed by the war match-ups..Why not make troops count towards match ups? th11 troops you face th11 defences etc?

[WichitaScott]

Lol!!! Latest 20v20, we have one town hall 11 to their 6, and 2 of theirs with eagles, the other 4 have max troops. They have one more town hall 9 and 10 than us too. Had one clan mate last war, severe mismatch as we are a nonrushed clan, who just simply said, “Sorry guys. This just isn’t fun like it used to be. And quit. Quit his game too.” You banned players using mod software, because it’s unfair, and violates your rules. Now, within the rules, it’s just unfair, but that’s ok we assume. Don’t rush was always the thing, so we didn’t rush, and now it’s too late. Pretty miffed. Very frustrated. Tired of deaf ears. Peace!

[Razz42]

Clan ID:#L2C2QLGR
Clan name:30 & Up Friends
War Start Date:12/29/2017
War Start Time (GMT): around 1AM (7PM CST: US)
Comment: 15 man war
30 & Up Friends Vs CREW KHONG HOU
2-TH11s 6-TH11s
7-TH10s (9.5s) 2-TH10s
6-TH9s 6-TH9s
1-TH8

Every Th11 on the CREW KHONG HOU has max loons and Lavas as well as other troops. So essentially it is 4:12 th11 attacks with some max th11 troops. Makes the war pointless with the overwhelming advantage.
last War was 2th11 for us against 5 th11s, 3 of the th11s being at the bottom matched with th8s.

[Saulosi]

Clan name: War Coalition #LVRQRR8Q
Opponent: d'Chosen One #QPGQCLC0

War starts in 22.5 hours

Comments: 15v15. We have 2 th11, they have 8! Yes 8! All with at least max lavaloon attack and extremely low heroes. Do the rest of the bases really matter?! No they shouldn't. Will they be bad attackers? Should that matter?! It shouldn't.... Most of them have more than 1000 war stars.

BTW, to Supercell.... I got $75 of gift cards for Christmas. In previous years I would have bought gems. Not now.

[TheNightHawkx]

BTW, to Supercell.... I got $75 of gift cards for Christmas. In previous years I would have bought gems. Not now.

I got Google Play gift cards as well and just re-gifted them. I have been known to put thousands of dollars into games but I will not spend another cent on any Supercell game until they fix clan wars.

One of the easiest fixes Supercell could possibly implement is to match the number of the max TH level bases the same as the opposition. So if TH11 is the highest base in the war and we have 5 x TH11 then we are matched to another clan with 5 x TH11. The other bases won't matter so much as most wars come down to the top guys anyway. This is such a simple fix that will make so many people happy and may even bring back some of the old big spenders who have quit. But of course Supercell will just feed us more ♥♥ that they are working on this when nothing is being done and war matches are worse now than when this post was created.

[WichitaScott]

I thought this was supposed to be fun.

[WayneP]

Clan ID #CJR20GC

Enemy Clan #9U8V2G9C
War starts in 10 hours
Search Time 11pm GMT

We are lvl 14 they are lvl 15

They have 5 Eagle, we have 4 Eagle

They have 21/30 TH11 ........we have 13

Our 24/25/26/28/29/30 are TH8 or less. Their number 24 has xbows, none of our smaller bases can attack their number 30 even.

So we lose out on 12 attacks out of 60.
They have 42/60 TH11 attacks.........

This is just one of a mismatch every war since the update. We are a clan who did not rush town halls, we built TH9 slowly adding xbows last etc. It would appear now that we are being severely punished for this!

Clan wars are actually becoming a CHORE, it used to be fun.......you have killed matchmaking!

Look forward to a reply if one is even possible!
This war is like most we have, we never ever get a mismatch weighted in our favour! Never...........we have maybe a5% chance to win this war......and I am being positive.

Wayne