Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[penguin3d]

Clan ID: #20R2URL
Clan Name: G-Mac
War Start Date: December 18, 2017
War Start Time(GMT): 04:47am (I think . . .)

Note: if you want war start information, make it available in the "War Stats" page for the war in question so you don't have to rely on our translation skills

Problem: We have 3 th11 8 th10, th9 and below may count, but that is auto 3* territory for both sides. They have 11 th11. Our th10 vary from max th9 armies up to max th10 armies/heroes. Our opponent has 11 wardens, and every one of their th11 has some form of max army, whether it be lavaloon, bowlers, miners, whatever. Many of their lower th11 villages have max xbows and/or higher level infernos making it difficult for the appropriate attackers at the bottom to 3*. All in all, offensively, they have us out gunned, and defensively it is fairly even, if not tilted slightly in their favor. Doing the math, this was an uphill war. looking like it will end 51 - 55. When things are evenly matched, we come within 1* or it comes down to %, so this was a stomping.

I had started and stopped the search several times to avoid this very issue, but lost track of time during the last search. TBH, I would rather war search fail to find a match than hand us a match like this.

[KatCanada]

Clan ID: #89L9J89C
Clan name: Canada
War Start Date: Monday December 18, 2017
War Start Time (GMT): 0200 GMT approximately
Comment:
Our clan: 3 TH11s in positions 1,2,3
Enemy clan: 8 TH11s in positions 1,2,3,4,7,16,20,21

Their 16 three starred our 3 and a TH9, their 21 three starred two of our TH9s, their 7 three starred two of our TH9s, their 4 three starred our TH10s...one even attack, 7 dips

War ends in an hour...of course we will lose...by one point or so cause we are decent attackers, but we can't compete with straight up uneven numbers.

We had a 46 war win streak back in the day...earned with mostly decent attack strategies, no engineering. We can't stand the look of our red lined war log these days...

[MalletTombstone]

Hi all,

I guess the valuation of the inferno is the problem. We have one maxed out th10 and two maxed out th11 without inferno and eagle, but maxed out other def, walls and troops.
The two th11 are rankend BEHIND the th11 in the clan wars. even they easily 3 star every th10 and never get 3 stared by a th10.

if sc changes this evaluation and the engineered th11 would be above th10 it would get more fair. In my opinion the offense power has to be considered more, infernos even after the great update considered less.


regards,

Mallet

[DhazarOzrax]

Clan ID: CRJG8PRP
Clan name: Lit
War Start Date: 20/12/2017
War Start Time (GMT): 18:11 GMT
Comment:

They are using Minimax bases to massively lower their war weight

15v15
their players 6-15 are all minimax
player 3 is TH11 with no infernos and xbows

this allows them to have player 1 to be TH10 with 40/40 heroes
and player 3 to have 45/45/20 heroes
their attack power compared to our clan's defences is completely insane
every player they have has max troops for their TH lvl for their attack strategies
we on the other hand do not have max defences do not have max troops do not have max heroes

player1 and 2 have near max defenses for TH10 so they are a big challenge to attack one that i relish getting 2*s would be great
yet when they attack us they 100% us nearly every attack with over half their army to spare

In conclusion I believe that more war weight should be placed on troops/ army camp space to stop these minimax base players
these bases and accounts have been made with the specific function of fooling the matchmaking system and is in my opinion is unsporting behaviour

[Surfco123]

Hi guys I need help to retrieve old clash of clans Off I pad 1 first gen won’t load with new update any help 👍

[David1937]

Sorry but this is a joke, how long are supercell going to take the #### out of its loyal players. This war matchmaking is a complete and utter disaster. How many times do people need to complain, how many mis matched wars do we need to suffer, how long do we need to wait for supercell to take action? This thread is nothing more than a placating measure, either do something to fix the matchmaking or at least tell us you're not so I can then put the game down.

not worth the time but the latest war is us 1 x brand new th11 with no th11 defences or troops yet. Opposing 6 x th11 with max troops, 3 of them near max defences without eagle, 3 of them are low defences with max troops.

this has been going on for 3 months now and it's not acceptable.

[angry72drgn]

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

I see no Date/Time stamp on the war... : /
Could Supercell add that please?

[angry72drgn]

Clan ID: 20CQ2V2L
Clan Name: Titans
vs
Clan ID: 99LCRVQL
Clan Name: Dragon's Nest
Start Date:. I see no Date/time stamp : /
Start Time: "18h ago" per War Log

Not sure what to say. Should speak for itself.

Seems like you are giving "respect" to rushed/engineered bases.

Seems like there should be NO reason for a TH11 to show up below a TH10, etc, on the war map. NO reason for a TH8 to be matched up against anything other than a TH7,8,9. If a TH11 is not as strong as a TH10 in position #1 on the map, then you should just hit it with some "hard added" strength points so that the TH11, does in fact show up above the "stronger" TH10.

Not sure why it is taking so long for Supercell to figure out how to stop people from gaming the system through the engineering of their bases???

But glad to see you are making efforts to take it seriously...

[Siberio]

Clan ID: #29RRVV2L
Clan name: NeoGenesis
War Start Date: 21 dec 2017
War Start Time (GMT): 01:10 a.m. (found match, preparation day starts)
Comment:
TL;DR Opponent has 3 th10, 12 th9 MAX, we have 3 th10, 2 th9 max, 3 regular th9, 2 th8.5, 3 th8, 1 th7. 1/3 of my clan can't even attack successfully

Today's match is a bit weird. It's the same rooster we have used in last 3 wars:
1 Max TH 10 (missing some walls)
2 Regular TH 10 (most troops, guns done; 30/33 heroes, all lvl10 walls)
3 Max TH 10 (only missing Infernos)
4-5 Max TH9
6 Regular TH9 (only missing couple of troops, 21/30)
7 Regular TH9 (max except 27/25)
8 Regular TH9 (23/23)
9 Regular TH9 (18/25)
10 Mild engi TH9 (previous max TH8, only missing xbows, walls, some troops, 15/14)
11 Mild engi TH9 (previous max TH8, missing xbows, newguns, walls, some troops, 10/8)
12 Max TH8
13 Regular TH8
14 TH7.5
15 Max TH7

Our enemy's lineup, LVL14, most of them with 1000+ war stars (cannot say about tesla and traps)
1-2 Max TH10
3 TH10 (max TH9, only ADs maxed, 35/35, missing some troops)
4-13 Max TH9 (some have also geared up Archer Tower, some have not)
14 Max TH9 (25/29)
15 Mild engi TH9 (missing xbows, mortar and wizard towers maxed for TH8, missing some spells in lab, 25/29)

https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...war-match-ever

[AnakNgTeteng79]

Clan ID: #LC2JR9PL
Clan name: THE SETTLER'S
War Start Date: 12/22 - (Preparation)
War Start Time (GMT): 02:30
Comment:
Details - 20v20
Opponent as has th 11 placed on 4. Troops consist of lv5 GW, Maxed lavahound and lv6 ballons that can take down our top player easily since is a th10 w/o inferno. And their 1 has maxed th10 defense. Their th11 doesnt have much weight in offense since he focused on maxing out 1 type of attack (which is Lavaloons) and with a skilled GW, he can easily wipe out our 1 & 2. While on the other hand, we have a slim chance of taking down a maxed out th10 with our players not able to match up in offense.

I wanna add that this player who wiped our no.1 and no.2 (#8UV0RU0UV - Blast Wave)
Doesnt carry much weight in offense since most of his troops are still at the TH9 bracket. SC mentioned on the update that they will focus more on offense. This aint affecting this player coz he only focused on Lavaloons attack. So technically his offense is only comparable to a th9 if you sum it all up.