Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[TheNightHawkx]

Clan ID: #90QQJ8PU
Clan name: AUS 300
War Start Date: Friday 8th December
War Start Time (GMT): Approx 10:30 am GMT
Comment: This was a 20 vs 20 war and they scored 58/60. Every single one of our players had every defense placed so there were no .5 or engineered accounts and we were once again matched to an engineered clan.


We had 3 TH11 and they had 5 at the top and another at #9 along with a completely engineered TH11 at #15 with no defenses and max troops plus a TH10 at #16 with no defenses and max troops.


They added 2 TH5's at #18 & #19 + a TH4 at #20 to lower their war weight and then used the TH5's to scout our TH11 bases. Their TH5's and TH4 looked like they had just been built as burner accounts to deliberately be used for scouting (which I thought was meant to be banned).


We used to have a load of .5 bases and we no longer allow them in war but it seems it doesn't matter. These engineered clans will be the death of COC.

[Negativa]

#Q9GUJOC, MikeAls Vs Devil Tail 09-12-2017, 1445 hrs.
last 5 wars our opponents their top 5 player all have max heroes and eagle artillery max defences we have have no eagles, takes the ♥♥♥♥ a bit guys... Reija K is decent GM cheers dude

[Shadowythecat]

I am amazed that Supercell have still done nothing about this. War after war we are being matched against engineered TH11s when we don't have any TH11s. People are also leaving my clan in their droves now after being loyal members for years. Shame on you Supercell!!!! What is Darian doing apart from making up stupid noise words and bragging about being involved in some or other films. Try doing ur job pal ��

[shreyasbela2233]

Clan tag: #PQ8RLPVC
Clan name: Greenmavens
Start Date: Dec 9
Start Time: About 8:04pm PT

Comment:
We are having a 5vs5 clan war..our breakdown is 3 th10 with 2 th9 and hear what our opponent consist of 4 nearly max th10 and a th10.5 with max defences(max xbows and air defences)
The top four opponent have max infernoes and mortars...and the fifth one a th 11 (10.5 basically) has max defence (max x bow, wiztower, mortars)

Our one th9 (who still doesn't have max xbows) has a th 10.5 as his mirror and the other th9 has a th10 with infernoes as his mirror..!!
This matchup was really ridiculous..the th10.5 will cut through our th9 in no time...

The moment we were thinking that the matchmaking in working alright... HERE we are placed against a one sided war..the dev team plz look into the matchmaking algorithm more seriously..😠😠😡

[goofiedk]

#22U80QYP
Acesoverkings
9'th of December 2017
set in motion at 23.00 hours gmt -1 (danish time)
a 10 vs 10 war we got matched with 8 out of 10 th 11 - we had 1 th 11, 7 th 10 ...didn't seem fair its just about impossible for our th 10's to get through those big bases ... Most of them highly engineered...

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

[Altron5]

Clan ID: 2QR2C2YY
Clan name: Crooked Smiles
War start date: Dec 10
War start time: 9:38pm EST

We have 7 full th11 defences (some max, some close to max), 1 th10.25 (with th9 number of defences), 1 full max th10 defence, 1 full max th9 defence.
Our opponent has 10 fully maxed th11 defences except for their #10. They have all max heroes except for 1 th11 with 37/38/17.

We have max th11 heroes from 1-6, 1 th11 with 30/36/20 and 1 th10.25 with 20/25/16.
Our th10 has 25/28 and our th9 has 25/26.

Probably the worst matchup we got to date. Is the matchmaking algorithm improving or getting worse?

[SrVampiro]

Clan ID: Q8J929Y9
Clan name: Devils of Spain
War start date: 10/12/2017
War start time: about 06:00/07:00 am GTM

My colleagues and I, we have been playing for a long time, and almost always we have been happy, we love the game, and in each change we try to adapt and improve.

However, for some time some wars don't go well, we tried different villages in war to improve the match without any satisfactory results.

This war of 25 players:

My team.

Two th10 without th10 defenses, no infernal towers, and without half th10 troops unlocked (no miners, no bowlers). The rest players, some th9, th8 and th7 (normal bases), and two th7 with troops th9 (engineers by necessity).

Enemy team:
Two th10 with full defenses (infernal towers level 3). 5 engineering bases (one with full troops th11) and some bases without defenses of any kind.

Result:

In less than 6 hours the enemy team has destroyed all our bases, and we do not have troops to attack these th10 with infernal towers level 3.

War lost from minute 1.

Something is wrong...

Thanks

[Ak7lives]

Clan ID: #2UPG8YYR
Clan name: Wisconsin
War Start Date: 12/10/17
War Start Time (GMT): 2:51 AM (GMT)
Comment: Defense: Us: (Eagles-1 lvl2, 4 lvl1) (Villages with Infernos- 3 lvl5, 1 lvl4, 1 lvl2, 1 lvl1 (6 inferno villages))
Them: (Eagles- 5 lvl 2) (Villages with Infernos- 5 lvl5, 3 lvl3 (8 inferno villages))
Offense: Us: 5 bases with TH11 troops(10 attacks)
Them: 8 bases with TH11 troops(16 attacks)
They have the advantage on both offense and defense. Our th11s will have to be perfect to make this close, which they probably will be. But this does not seem like an even start.

[DRUSSW]

Clan id#pyj92luu
Clan name UK adults
War start 20.00 hours GMT
War date 10/12/17
Us one th11 with eagle one lvl 4 inferno
4 th10
8 th9
1 th8
1 th3
Them
5 TH11 all with wardens top acc lvl 1 eagle all have strong attacks
3 th10 ,,1 th6 rest th9
Not getting any better folks,first war for an age we have put a lower acc in last few match ups were bad so tried something different,running out of ideas n motivation 😒

[krayj]

Clan ID: #PRORLLQU
Name: SBOK
War Start Date: 20171210 1710 (UTC -8)
War Start Time (GMT): 20171211 0110 GMT

15v15

Our #1 guy is a brand new TH10; doesn't even have camps done, no TH10 war troops done yet, his base is a max TH9 with a few of the new defenses started. After him we have 3 TH9s, 3 TH8s, 2 TH7s, 1 TH6, an engineered new TH10, 2 TH5, and 1 TH4.

Enemy #1 is a completely defensively max TH10 with L3 infernos, 40/40 heroes, and all war troops and camps maxed. Enemy #2 is a mid TH10 with L1 infernos and 28/30 heroes (this base is on par with our #1). Enemy #3 is an engineered TH11 with 8/8/6 heroes, max miners, max drags, max lightning. Enemy #4 is an engineered TH11 with 7/6/5 heroes, max drags, max lightning.

We don't even have the firepower to 2 star their #1. We will be lucky to 2 star their #2. Meanwhile, Their Th11s alone will rip through our top 4 blindfolded (a 2 town hall level dip for them). Their TH10s will be hitting our TH8s (a 2 town hall level dip for them). This ripples down through the rest of the match.

You have basically given them a match they cannot lose, and you've given us a match we cannot win.

Have a look at their 11-war win streak (all 100% victories). They have learned how to beat the system. Why not just make how matchmaking works become public knowledge so at least other clans have a fighting chance to be competitive?