Clan War Mismatch - Gathering new infoz (again for science)

[Ak7lives]

Clan ID: #2UPG8YYR
Clan name: Wisconsin
War Start Date: 11/21/17
War Start Time (GMT): 10:38 PM
Comment: We have 4 TH11s with no Eagles. They have 8 Th11s with one Eagle and all have max attack troops and wardens.

[Altron5]

Clan ID: #2QR2C2YY
Clan name: Crooked Smiles
War start date: Nov 22, 2017
War start time: 9:20pm eastern standard time (EST)
Comment:
10v10
Their th11s have average stronger heroes than ours and one more full th11 defense and one more full th10 defense, and no th9

Us:
7 th11s
1 th10
1 th10.5 (without infernos but 3 heroes)
1 th9 (not full defences)

Them:
8 th11
2 th10

We're still gathering information on how the matchmaking changes are impacting everyone. While we can and do review these data, it's difficult to monitor millions of records trying to find specific results. If you feel you were mismatched in your Clan War, then we'll require some information from you.

To make things much simpler than before, there are only 4 bits of information we'll need:

Clan ID:
Clan name:
War Start Date:
War Start Time (GMT):
Comment:

Make sure the time zone is noted, though we prefer GMT.

The start time is largely to make sure we're looking at the right war. Once a week I'll be giving this report to the engineers to review.

Feel free to include a comment of what was mismatched. Though we can see the War results, we also want to get your perspective as well as it's important to understand your point of view too.

If you're not comfortable sharing any of the above information on the forums, feel free to PM me the information with the subject line [Clan Mismatch] so I know to review the message.

[RagnarFurias]

Clan ID: #U2Q0GUL
Clan name: Benfleet Union
War Start Date: 22 November
War Start Time (GMT): 20:00 gmt
Comment:

Second bad MM in a row
War size: 25x25

we:
6 TH11 max +
4 TH10 max +
rest Th9

them:
6 th11 max +
2 TH11 no eagle +
2 th10 max +
1 TH11 no eagle, no inferno +
2 th10 no infernos
rest th9 and 2 th8s

no rushed bases there, since they are engineers and pureposely upgrade only offense/heroes. All TH11s have good wardens, and so on

[BarryAmc]

Clan wars suck. We dont get match up top and our lower bases r matched with weak ♥♥♥ th11 but . this is madning part. Th11 with max troops. Wow. Ur match up system is messed up. Were in a 15 man war. There 7 and 9 r th11 with max troops . i bet u that there 7 and 9 will 3 star our top 3. How hell is this fair?

[hammer]

Clan wars suck. We dont get match up top and our lower bases r matched with weak ♥♥♥ th11 but . this is madning part. Th11 with max troops. Wow. Ur match up system is messed up. Were in a 15 man war. There 7 and 9 r th11 with max troops . i bet u that there 7 and 9 will 3 star our top 3. How hell is this fair?

Gotta love new spawns that just complain without any detail. Read the original post, put your details in - that's the only way SC will be able to fix this issue.

Yes, it's maddening when the engineered bases are the difference, but geez. We've matched to plenty of clans with engineered bases where the war looked bad "initially", but when you take a look at ALL the details, it's not so bad. And then it turns out they can't even attack well designed bases and we win even with the mismatch.

[Fleabag]

Clan id : #YPPV88Q8
Clan name: clan dozers
War start: 23 Nov
Another unfair mis match

Us: 6/1/6/2. Th11- th8
Them: 6/5/4 th11 - th9
Their #15 is an engineered th11 with max lvl def a GW and max troops. They have 5 X th10 to our 1 some have infernos and all have lvl 4 xbows and ug def. Our th9's wont 3 star them and cleaning them up will mean our th11 only get 1 attack on each of their th11
We're all getting fed up with the bad matchups which are never in our favour

[RajaShukla]

Clan ID: #pu2vjp2c
Clan name: India Clashon!!
War Start Date:20-November-2017
War Start Time (GMT): 7:00 PM
Comment: We were th9s and below.. no .5s no rushers, no engineers.. Still got a Th10, and more no. of th9s than us...


Clan ID: #pu2vjp2c
Clan name:India Clashon!!
War Start Date:22-November-2017
War Start Time (GMT): 8:00 PM
Comment: We are th9s and below, non-rushed, non-engineered, no .5s etc.... And we are now matched against many engineered th9s and even one th11

Hope thinks helps in fixing things up.
Thanks

[orosev]

Clan ID:#LQ0QUU9R
Clan name: Lyckliga Gatan
War start: 22.11 at 21.53 Norwegian Time
War ends: 23.11 at 21.53 Norwegian time

40vs40. Th 11: we: 13, they 14. We have 3 maxed and 3 more with eagle.
They have 11 maxed. And 3 defenceless at 38-40 with everything Else maxed. The rest of their are maxed th9.

[Warmatchmaking]

Clan ID: #YYYJLQQ
Clan name: WarKings 2
War Start Date: November 22, 2017
War Start Time (GMT): 17:20
Comment:
Third match after warden weight update, 20vs20:
Our: 16 TH11, 4 TH9
Them: 20 TH11
Why enemy always have more TH11, not us? Do we have too much wins? Do we have too strong upgraded TH11‘s? That’s why we upgrading our bases to max – to have advantage! Unfortunately we have opposite – enemy, who have upgraded less defenses, now actually have advantage with more TH11 and max troops.
Build and upgrade less – get more advantage!

[Roscoe8888]

How about this. Throw a rock at your matching system and the first match that falls out will be unfair. Analyze that! ANY MATCH WITH MAX 11 TROOPS MATCHING A BASE BELOW 11 IS UNFAIR.

It doesn't matter if they are good players or not. The fact is those troops were given that level to match the defenses associated with the same townhall they are available at.

Stop playing stupid like you don't know what's wrong with the matches. Get your ♥♥♥♥ together.