Darian, the big question is "when?"Originally Posted by Darian[Supercell]
Some information before changes are actually made would be very favorable, as it would give us hope.
Darian, the big question is "when?"
Some information before changes are actually made would be very favorable, as it would give us hope.
Flying blind in Clash because the new update has crashed my phone.Thank goodness for my ancient tablet!
Thanks for listening Darian, appreciate the more sensible approach to us providing information versus the original data gathering attempt that put the onus on us, keep listening please, I am happy to contribute under the new way:
Clan ID: #LQLQ228J
Clan name: A New Hope
War Start Date: 10/11/2017 (dd/mm/yyyy in the UK way!)
War Start Time (GMT): 01:51 (I think!)
Comment: Why are we continually matched against engineering clans? We are playing fair, no .5, no engineered, yet we get matched almost exclusively against engineering clans? Please see their 23 machete 1.2, a TH10 with minimal defence so below th7s in war list, but with lvl 5 dragons and th10 spells. Please see their 13 ChinO AnthraX5.7, a th10 with c.TH8 defence but 4 air def below other th8s in war list, but with lvl 6 loons and lvl5 dragons, aq and th10 spells. This is just one of many examples. It destroys the fun of war, and we all know war means gems spent as people late on gem war armies, now how much more incentive does Supercell need to get war matchmaking right? ;-)
I suppose I should add the breakdown, they roster engineer too:
Us: th11 x4, th10 x2, th9 x5, th8 x14
Them: th11 x3, th10 x8, th9 x2, th8 x7, th7 x3, th5 x2
I don't complain it isn't winable, I do complain it is fair play (us) versus engineered and roster engineered (them). Not what any of us thought the new matchmaking was supposed to throw up, yet it does all the time.
Last edited by nobeone; November 10th, 2017 at 09:37 AM.
We just got matched up again with 11 th 11s we only have 4 how can we stand a chance with that kind of matchup. These engineered bases max 1 or 2 troops that there good with and run all over our th 10s. They have all the extra troops and don't even need maxed hero's. our th 10s don't have a chance. So if clan has more th 11s it's a no brainer.. They have the advantage.
clan #82RJJRQ8
GrampsWarriors
war start time 4 pm EST
date 11/9/2017
You see these th 11s as low bases they are not low bases in war they pull 6 stars every war not hard to figure it out... One raid didn't even need heros against our th 10s You need to fix this fast....
Every war I watched that you people did on line was never mismatched like your giving us, this is ridiculous...
Last edited by Gramp50; November 10th, 2017 at 02:51 PM.
Clan ID: #292LQGJ8
Clan Name: ABC COMMANDOS
War Start Date: Thursday November 8
Time (GMT): 7:00 pm
Comment: 2 Th11 for us against 8 th11, 5 of them engineered and 3 max. We have 4 th10 max and they have 4, maxed, as well. How we can win: three star a max th11. How they can: clear th10 with th11 and two star our top 2 with ease. I thought engineering was placed with other engineered clans?
Clan ID: #2PJLJLCU
Clan name: American Tigers
Comment: Our war roster typically includes no more than 1 TH11, 2-3 TH10
War Start Date: November 9, 2017 EST (November 10, 2017 GMT) – current war
War Start Time (GMT): 20:54 EST (01:54 GMT)
Comment: 4 TH11, 3 TH10, 5 TH9, 4 TH8, 2 TH7 – in a 20v20, this clan has 14 TH11/10 caliber hits to our 6. Result: we have been swept, but still have hits left. Not too confident that we will tie.
War Start Date: November 7, 2017
War Start Time (GMT): ~21:00 EST (02:00 GMT)
Comment: 3 TH11, 1 TH10, 6 TH9, 4 TH8, 4 TH7 – in a 20v20, this clan had 8 TH11/10 caliber hits to our 6. Result: We lost.
War Start Date: November 5, 2017
War Start Time (GMT): ~21:00 EST (02:00 GMT)
Comment: 4 TH11, 2 TH10, 7 TH9, 2 TH8, 5 TH7 – in a 20v20, this clan had 12 TH11/10 caliber hits to our 4. Result: we won
The record for last 15 wars: 5-9-1 with one win gain against a clan that didn't bother to take a hit. Swept by opposing clan 7 times with 3 more wars lost where the clan scored one less star than a complete sweep.
The historical record for the clan is 311-122-9.
Prior to the update, our win % was approximately 63%. It has dropped precipitously since the matchmaking update.
Last edited by Pete416; November 10th, 2017 at 10:42 PM.
We’ve had a relatively decent run of even, or mostly even, matchups since the MM change, but our latest one is a stinker and worthy of checking out.
The basic gist is we have two th11s (in a 10man war), they have four (at the 1,2, 5, and 10 spot below a th8). Their #5 is 45/45/20, and their #10 is 32/32/17 with max hounds/loons/bowlers/witch (and that’s it). Definitely some solidly engineered bases, whereas we’re non engineered and pretty much balanced/maxers.
Clan ID: #9R20VJGL
Name: Big P.E.K.K.A.S
Start Date: Nov 9th, 2017
Start Time: 6:00 pm EST (11pm GMT)
Note: we’re currently in battle day.
Last edited by nerfedname; November 11th, 2017 at 12:18 AM.
TH12 - Lvl 218 - AQ60 - BK60 - GW30
Click HERE to find out more about "Nerfedname's 'weight tax'" for war MM
Signature by Gutodh
*sigh* I really hope they fix this. We will keep fighting through it
Clan name: 7.0 abv or up
Clan tag: 9V2RGQL
War start date: nov 11 2017
War start time: ~1224am GMT
Comments: Simply put 15v15
Opponent: 4 Th11, 7 Th10, 4 Th9
Us: 0 Th11, 5 Th10, 8 Th9, 2 Th8
Two wars ago opponent in 25v25 had 10 Th11s to our 2. Just a crazy time.
Clan ID: #2QPQGJ8V
Clan name: Air Poland
War Start Date: 9.10.2017
War Start Time (GMT): 20:11
Comment: 6 TH11 (us) vs 19 TH11 in 40vs40
In my opinion TH11 in war (as rest of TH also) should stand against another TH11, what’s the point of play game for fun when opponent have so big advantage?
Another question, giving that you are unable(or don't want) to get rid of engineering how much time do you spend to balance attack’s eq., th10 vs th11 with max defense but without IT and Eagle, or th9 vs th11 with max point defense without big weight stuff?
After many drawing I clearly do not understood why you don’t make matchmaking by TH lvl,, or make penalty for diping (but this will also affect maxers clans).
Feels really great and fun to be 3starred (when I’m almost max th10, number 8 in my clan) by number 15 with 45/45/20. In this war almost every our base will be defending against dip. How is this possible in tower defense game.
I want to notice that we do not mid losing war(s) but we want winning wars fair and losing them fair. Repair the game because it’s great( but MM sucks ☹)
Last edited by doginfog; November 11th, 2017 at 01:46 AM.
Clan Name - Bad Rabbits EDU
Clan Tag- #UUCY2J2
War Start Time ~ 8pm Eastern Standard
War Start Date 11/10
Clan ID: #PU8QQCQ2
Clan name: DISCO 2 party
War Start Date: 11/11
War Start Time (GMT): 18:23
Comment:
20v20
5 TH11 vs 10 TH11
#19 is a TH9 with heroes 19/23 and 1 small canon as defense
#9 is a TH11 with max heroes and most troops, could probably take on our #1
Reduce your signatures.
