#1401
The video tells us nothing of any value.Originally Posted by Krishnasing9
In a 30v30, the fact they have one TH13 and you don't most certainly does NOT make the war a mismatch.
You had already shared screenshots showing the whole roster (though not showing how rushed or otherwise any bases might be), and it diod not look like a significant mismatch at all.
Thanks TerMinus Prime for the sig pic
Clan ID: #YCL9PVY
Clan name: Green Lightning
War Start Date: 10/15/2020
War Start Time: 10:03 GMT
Comment: For several wars in a row, my clan has faced max TH13 at the top of enemy rooster. We have been running 15v15 and 20v20 wars only. For the current war, we have 3 TH12 on top. All three only have 2 infernoes and a level 2 eagle. We have 2 5 star THs and a 3 star TH12. Enemy clan has 2 TH13 on top that are basically maxed out (just missing a few level 14 walls). They also have 2 TH12s that have 3 infernoes built. TH range spread is 4-12 for my clan and 5-13 for enemy clan. I am wondering as to why this matchup is so bad? It isn't the first time we have had a screwed up regular war, this has been going on for several weeks as of late. Thanks!
https://cocp.it/clan/YCL9PVY
Latest war - 0/3/2/1/7/4/0/0/1/0/2
1. Close your TH spread, I would drop anything below 9 if you are going to run with 12s at the top.
2. Maxing at 12 is a bad idea unless you're running with 13s at the top. With the current war matchmaker, as your accounts cross over from low to mid 12s, you will almost immediately start matching 13s. This is due to the lack of weight differential between 12 and 13.
3. I would get some more 10s. Have some of your higher 9s upgrade.
TMBG War Clan always recruiting - Wars with TH9-13
TMBG Discord server: https://discord.gg/byNR2xZ
Completely agree with everything puma said, I wanted to add a couple of things based on my own experiences.
This is most important. When you run unusual lineups, you are more likely to get mismatched or not matched at all. I had the same problem with mismatches running TH13-TH6 spread wars. I eventually split us up and ran back-to-back wars, one for TH9-TH6, and then right after one for TH13-TH10. This worked much better for my clan.
One caveat - eventually my clanmates started levelling up. I thought the split would be more even running TH10-TH8, and then TH13-TH11. I couldn't find a match for the TH10-TH8 group. I ended up re-combining our wars, but I ran only TH13-TH9. (Our TH8s have since levelled up) Matchups have been tough, but fair.
Thanks to TerMinus Prime for the awesome sig/avatar!
Ignore Trolls | Forum Titles | About Reputation | Reputation Dots | War Base Order
Agree. Seems odd that you couldn't get TH8-10 to match.
I will say though that I don't think the spread is causing him to pull 13s. Low to Mid level 12s pulling heavy 13s opposite has been going on for some time. We got so fed up with it I had our 12s go ahead and upgrade. No one in our clan maxes 12 anymore, it's just not worth it. Once we get enough 13s we will likely start allowing accounts to max 12 before upgrade but we just don't have enough 13s right now.
This happens to some extent at all levels when accounts get closer to max, but 12=>13 is the worst I have seen.
TMBG War Clan always recruiting - Wars with TH9-13
TMBG Discord server: https://discord.gg/byNR2xZ
Clan ID:#G22C89RV
Clan name:MOST WANTED
War Start Date:20/10/2020
War Start Time (GMT):11:30 AM
Comment: IM TH 11 AND I HAVE BEEN MATCHED WITH A CLAN HAVE TH 12
Looked you up on cocp.it: https://cocp.it/clan/G22C89RV
First, you're running huge TH ranges. Second, you often match 12s and 13s that you 3* so just the fact that you have 11 at the top and they have a 12 does not mean this is a mismatch. Further I see you occasionally carry sandbagged Th11s in your lineup. Don't do this.
TMBG War Clan always recruiting - Wars with TH9-13
TMBG Discord server: https://discord.gg/byNR2xZ
You haven't been matched with anything. The MMA matches clans as best it can depending on the rosters presented to it. Individual "matches" don't figure & I don't see any Commandment that says thou shalt always attack thy mirror.
From puma's comment, it's clear you need to stop throwing the entire clan at every war. Narrow your TH range & leave out any lopsided bases if you're looking for reasonable matches.
And turn off the caps lock; all majiscule or uppercase is considered SHOUTING!
Last edited by Kaledonian; October 22nd, 2020 at 04:36 PM.
Been getting a lot of mismatches lately and it is getting frustrating. I really think supercell needs to weight the townhall more in the formula.
This last war is just ridiculous. Opposing clan - TWO TH 10 and THREE TH9 versus my clan - One TH10, One th9, TWO th8 and one th7.
We have still been winning some wars with these mismatches, but it makes the game not very enjoyable when you have to be perfect to just have a chance to win. This last one was just too much.
Clan ID: CL9992GL
Clan Name: Fire Spectrum
War Start Date: 10/22/2020
War Start Time: About 8:45 PM Central Time
The Number 5 in their clan easily gained three stars against our number 5. Our Number three barely three stared their number 5. Just not fair.
By weighting the hall more, do you mean giving it some weight? As of right now, those lower halls don't have weight. Th12 has weight because of the defense that is included inside it, that is what has weight.
With just hall levels, it is hard to say whether it was a mismatch.
You're running a spread of th10-th7 in only 5v5 wars. That makes a bit hard on the matchmaker.
Last edited by 2222; October 24th, 2020 at 12:14 AM.
Contact SC here. Click here for how trophies are calculated. An idea to improve legends here. I wish max players had a separate loot bank as described here. Caution, I often discuss for the sake of discussion and enjoy having my opinion challenged (or approved of) even when I care little about the actual issue. My balance wish: get rid of tornado trap, make it a decoration.
