New forum pumpkin pie group?

[SP50]

Hi
I have not completed the personal goals. I have contributed 31 pies and the next target is 48.
I had to interrupt pumpkin pie production to load a boat.

i have received 5 diamonds for participation when the global goal was reached - thing is I am not sure it is worth tying up the machines for the next two days to complete the personal goal ( still struggling for coins).
can anyone tell me what the last 3 rewards are . Apologies if this is somewhere deep in this thread already.

If there are still pies going a begging I could use some - just don,t want to tie up resources.

Any advice...?

[Glynkoko]

I am replying to some of the posts offering pies.. I have not yet completed my personal goal and would love to receive the spooky tree. If anyone still has any pies I would greatly appreciate it.

I still have 3 pies looking for a home. I don't think we're already neighbors. Friend me through Game Center - my player name is glynkoko.

After i receive and accept your friend request, I'll place wheat in the last stall of my roadside stand and give you pies after you pick up the wheat.

[PerkyCox]

Hi
I have not completed the personal goals. I have contributed 31 pies and the next target is 48.
I had to interrupt pumpkin pie production to load a boat.

i have received 5 diamonds for participation when the global goal was reached - thing is I am not sure it is worth tying up the machines for the next two days to complete the personal goal ( still struggling for coins).
can anyone tell me what the last 3 rewards are . Apologies if this is somewhere deep in this thread already.

If there are still pies going a begging I could use some - just don,t want to tie up resources.

Any advice...?

You get to be eligible for the diamonds once you achieve the first goal.

Our rewards were fairly typical --

1 -- 5 axes
2 -- Pumpkin on a pedestal
3 -- Tombstone
4 -- 10 axes
5 -- Spider tree

Decide if you want to pursue the rest of your goals and let us know. There are still a few pies waiting around --

[SP50]

You get to be eligible for the diamonds once you achieve the first goal.

Our rewards were fairly typical --

1 -- 5 axes
2 -- Pumpkin on a pedestal
3 -- Tombstone
4 -- 10 axes
5 -- Spider tree

Decide if you want to pursue the rest of your goals and let us know. There are still a few pies waiting around --

I would like the spider tree!!

Any spare pies would be appreciated.

[PerkyCox]

I would like the spider tree!!

Any spare pies would be appreciated.

How many do you need? Add me on GC

[Glynkoko]

To those helpers who have been helped and who have helped others here, and who have been part of the thread, a question:

Does it seem to you that the purpose of this thread has been overcome by events at this point?

By that I mean, is it our collective opinion that most players have now achieved their personal goals, so this thread has kind of run its course?

Unlike Woozle's gifting thread, I always expected that at some point here the supply of pies to donate would outstrip the number of players needing pies. I have posted pies to gift twice, and have had no nibbles in 24 hours. So my question is, do you think we are we there?

If so, I propose that we should start winding up this thread, perhaps by directing folks over to Woozle's more permanent gifting thread.

I do like the idea of a specific dedicated gifting thread to help with global goals. I think it has done a lot of good and spread a lot of Hay Day good karma around the world. If everyone agrees that we should try this idea again in the future, I think this is a good model to use.

What do YOU think????

Well done Perky! With the help of this group, I finished early and had fun baking for others. Although I will admit, its been a relief to bake a casserole or two this morning. Hehe

Looks like the pace has slowed, so I'll defer to your judgement on moving the pies to Woozie's thread. I do agree with you that people should claim the pies publicly, not by PM. I would like to see people publicly claim the goods and be on record to come back and help as they can.

This thread adds to the fun of the community challenges. I look forward to the next one!

[CheddarLimbo]

yeah, I think it's mostly done. I've moved on to baking other pies, had to! thank you for organizing this Perky. A splendid effort on all our parts helping each other get our goals. It was fun to be a part of it. Thank you.

I also agree that the thread got cluttered at times. I see your point Perky, perhaps it could be achieved, like Cheddar and Spaniel said, by editing the post after the giveaway naming who they went to.....? That could be part of the guidelines...? I've noticed those who like to take advantage just PM anyway. Otherwise, I think it went smoothly and look forward to gifting with you all again!

This seems like a step in the right direction... but that would still require other people keep track of who else is donating, and to whom...

I think each contributor is going to have different ideas about who is "worthy" of the gift. I'm not sure the best way to reconcile that universally.

[bear199311]

Nobody needing any pies?? I've got 9 to give away now

EDIT: COMPLETED

[SP50]

How many do you need? Add me on GC

Ok have sent all I have . Total of 43. So in total I need 34 to complete , so if you have a available I would
appreciate.

I don't know how to pay back for you help.

[BubblesGem]

I currently have 3 pies up for donating if anyone is still in need of them?