Collecting Clan War matchups...for science...and stuff!

[TheAaTeam]

If this is an attempt to get people to consider the full picture and reflect thoughtfully on the match


and guys, i am suspicious of supercell as the next guys, but you guys are being a bit hostile to what is really a good idea, with some improvments a great one, and we should jump at the chance to offer better suggestions, help him help us, and try get a better understanding of the performance of the matchmaker.

we have a supercell contact wanting our feedback and willing to discuss it with us, Its a step foward, come on, lets give it a go.

Didn't I and SS offer a suggestion? and we heard nothing.

and Darian, please get defence data into he API data so we can really help you.

Cricket.....

[Vikingchief]

Didn't I and SS offer a suggestion? and we heard nothing.


Cricket.....

yeah, some people were awseome, others were not.

[WH7DX]

Didn't I and SS offer a suggestion? and we heard nothing.




Cricket.....

Negative... they have high frequency trading algorythms that make millions a day and were to believe SC cant match quasi fair wars? Buahahahahaha

[Jrod55426]

Related to this: Why do we see a quantified defensive war weight (in the gold storages) but not offensive war weight anywhere? Either see both or none at all.

[Warios]

Related to this: Why do we see a quantified defensive war weight (in the gold storages) but not offensive war weight anywhere? Either see both or none at all.

No thanks, would just make it easier to manipulate the system then it already is.

[SumoSloth]

The current war match-up (still ongoing). Probably is another L (4 losses in a row). Admittedly, we are already defeated mentally.

We took out all 0.5 bases. The TH spread is still there. I will remove that in the next war. There is no way our bottom three can take theirs. That means this makes it a 7vs10 war. That means no room for error. So, regardless if you say "we could have, should have, would have", it doesn't matter. If the match-up leaves you with 'no room for error' (four in a row!), there is something wrong with the match-ups.

By the way, our 8 is a new TH9. He maxed all TH8 troops, spells, and defs (except for poison).

No	TH	BK	AQ	GW	EA	IT	XB	Loot Entry	Def Weight	Def Diff	Def Weight	Loot Entry	TH	BK	AQ	GW	EA	IT	XB
1	11	45	45	20	1	3,4	4,4,4,4	21200	106	1	105	21000	11	25	30	11	2	5,5	5,5,5,5
2	10	30	40			3,3	4,4,4	17400	87	0	87	17400	10	27	25			3,3	4,4,4
3	10	31	41			2,2,	3,3,3	17200	86	4	82	16400	10	19	20			1,1	3,3,3
4	9	30	30				3,3	14000	70	1	69	13800	9	26	26				3,3
5	9	18	20				3,3	13600	68	-1	69	13800	9	22	24				3,3
6	9	14	16				3,3	13400	67	-1	68	13600	9	23	20				3,3
7	9	16	22				3,3	13200	66	-2	68	13600	9	18	17				3,3
8	9	10	3					11800	59	-8	67	13400	9	11	11				3,3
9	8	10						13000	52	-12	64	12800	9	10	8				2,2
10	6							8334	25	-34	59	11800	9	10	3				1,3
Total		204	217	20	1					-52				191	184	11	1
		BK	AQ	GW	EA					-5.2				BK	AQ	GW	EA

Am I missing something? You are already defeated mentally? Where is this war a mismatch? If anywhere it is an advantage for your clan Honestly it's posts like this that have me thinking that it's the perception of the public as to whats fair and what is not that has to change more than the matchmaker itself.

This one has left me scratching my head.



To follow up… Surprise, surprise, you won lol. Go figure. People need to learn to recognize what actually matters in a war.

[SuperStorm103]

Honestly it's posts like this that have me thinking that it's the perception of the public as to whats fair and what is not that has to change more than the matchmaker itself.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure the average clan would have thrown in the towel when faced with our current match up. 5 th11 us to 12 th11 them. Though 3 of their wardens are not effective and the rest are all under level 10. And their AQ/BK levels are mostly really really low. They do have some max troops to go with those wardens, but only on a hand full of the 11's. The rest are still working with th10 troop levels. They have en extremely beefier lower 65% of their roster, where as we are slightly better defended towards the top.

It's a 30/30 war, current score (5 hours left) is 80 us 70 them. We still have 4 th11 hits left and some th10's. I'm guessing we will get to 86 or 87 stars. There were really clipping along while they were doing good dipping and double dipping our th9 and under. Then the lavaloon spam started on our top bases (9.5+) resulting in 1 star after 1 star after 1 star, maybe a lucky 2 star here and there, and now they have stopped @ 45/60 attacks used. Most of the bigger 11's on their roster have gone.

A small part of me jumps for joy when I think about making a bunch of roster manipulators throw in the towel. All things considered, it was a decent matchup. Their down fall was bad attacking (lavaloon spam). They even hit one of our weak th10's (with infernos) 6 times and have only managed 1 star from it. I was tempted to help them out in our clan description and tell them to try some other then lavaloon spam on our #8. Then realized the rest of their troops were pretty junky.

[WH7DX]

Post the defense levels, hero/warden level, eagles or missing infernos, th lvs and then we can tell

[SuperStorm103]

Post the defense levels, hero/warden level, eagles or missing infernos, th lvs and then we can tell

Are you talking to me?

[SuperStorm103]

Under the Assumption you are:

US/Them

Eagle 1:1

Inferno 14:13

Xbow 50:60

Us:
45/45/20
45/45/20
16/18/8
23/30/9
20/30/7

Them:

26/30/6
21/22/5
11/13/2
16/15/7
12/16/8
5/5/7
11/10/5
10/13/7
27/29/5
7/12/7
15/16/6
8/10/5

Our #22:



Thier #22:



@ #14 base weight is 66K (us) and 70K (them)

That should be enough to tell you the story of the match, or at least the accuracy of my description. And they are bad attackers (when not double dipping)