Collecting Clan War matchups...for science...and stuff!

[HulaGirl]

Meant I would participate in a few .

Sure thing, you are welcome any time!

[MrJackrabbit]

	TH	BK	AQ	GW	EA	IT	XB	WT(K)		TH	BK	AQ	GW	EA	IT	XB	WT(K)
1	11	45	45	20	2	5,5	5,5,5,5	109		11	45	45	20	0	3,3	4,4,4,4	93
2	11	42	45	13	0	0,0	1,1,1,1	75		10	40	40	X	X	3,3	4,4,4	89
3	8	10	X	X	X	X	X	51		9	15	25	X	X	x	3,3	69
4	7	5	X	X	X	X	X	39		8	8	X	X	X	X	X	53
5	6	X	X	X	X	X	X	30		9	1	0	X	X	X	0,0	13
6	5	X	X	X	X	X	X	20		5	X	X	X	X	X	X	4
7	4	X	X	X	X	X	X	12		3	X	X	X	X	X	X	1
8	4	X	X	X	X	X	X	11		3	X	X	X	X	X	X	1
9	3	X	X	X	X	X	X	6		3	X	X	X	X	X	X	1
10	2	X	X	X	X	X	X	2		3	X	X	X	X	X	X	1
T	61	102	90	33	1/2	2/4	8/8	355		64	109	110	20	0/1	4/4	9/11	323
WS	0									0
SC	29	98%								27	93.9

Current war was able to get 29 fairly early. They have always attacked but none so far. Yes that is a th2 at the bottom. Will update score at the end.

[SuperStorm103]

Engineered clan we are currently facing has only won 3 of their last 12 wars. Will be 3 of their last 13 in an hour .

All our 9's, except for ONE! are matched to 9.5's. Oh, but they do have 4 th8's at the bottom of their roster.

[SuperStorm103]

So funny thing, I started war search before driving home, and was waiting for the notification to pop up. Apparent we matched after 11 minutes and I missed it. An hour later I was thinking they lengthened searches again. Logged in to restart war timer and saw we matched.

Hers the funny thing. Not really sure we can call this a match maker anymore. At the top of the roster we have 2 th11's on our side (one missing an eagle) and a 10. On their side, they have 3 full th11's. At the bottom of the map we are showing all th9's (one just literally got a paint job). At the bottom of their roster, they have 3 th7's a th8, and a th11 (the non threatening type).

So to recap, top doesn't match, bottom doesn't match, offense doesn't match, they have 5 th11's to our 3 and defenses do not match. 3 full th11's to 1. So why do we call this a matchmaker exactly?

Anyways, they don't appear to be great attackers. Won't know if it's a good "not a match" for 47 hours :/.

[jerdiya]

I'm too lazy to enter all these, here's our current war matchup, this is not the 1st time we are facing engineered clans, last match was worse & looks like this 1 also gonna be the same.
We are not 3* specialist/ base builders/gasp, we are just casual players within our friends circle.

Our #1,3,5,6 & 7 almost everything maxed, others near to max/half way
Enemy #4 almost everything maxed (xbow n IT not maxed), others ONLY WARDEN/LAVA/LOON/MINERS/DRAG maxed, all other troops/defense low level

By this, looks like maxing our hero's is a punishment.

http://tinypic.com/r/2nuksqr/9

[GrudgeTaker]

It would be useful if you collected data on troops levels too.

My clan have a 10v10 match up, we have 2 th11s, 5 th10s and 3 th9s.

Our opponents (Pangeran Goblin #YGJU89YV) have 6 th11s, 1 th10, 2 th9s and a virtually defenceless th8.

My concern is their attacking strength, every one of the enemy th11s has max troops (not all, but war troops), they have a massive advantage.

[Frogged]

It would be useful if you collected data on troops levels too.

My clan have a 10v10 match up, we have 2 th11s, 5 th10s and 3 th9s.

Our opponents (Pangeran Goblin #YGJU89YV) have 6 th11s, 1 th10, 2 th9s and a virtually defenceless th8.

My concern is their attacking strength, every one of the enemy th11s has max troops (not all, but war troops), they have a massive advantage.

The very fact that they don't want offensive troop data shows that it has a minimal effect on matchmaking. This is an obvious problem that everyone but supercell sees.

[Vikingchief]

I struggle to see the point of these reports if troop levels are not compared?

[SuperStorm103]

I struggle to see the point of these reports if troop levels are not compared?

I think it's because they don't care to match them. All they care about are the totals. If that is made up of 10 maxed th11 offenses and 10 th3 offenses, you can match a clan with the same total, regardless of how they get it. There had been less emphasis on whatever lane matching they used to do. I documented over 50 matches, and most of the time (talking about defense weights) the lanes matches were within 1K or 2K. Now I am seeing 1K-7K Lane variations. A few matches have been 6K+ across the entire roster. except our #1 slot.

[Vikingchief]

I think it's because they don't care to match them. All they care about are the totals. If that is made up of 10 maxed th11 offenses and 10 th3 offenses, you can match a clan with the same total, regardless of how they get it. There had been less emphasis on whatever lane matching they used to do. I documented over 50 matches, and most of the time (talking about defense weights) the lanes matches were within 1K or 2K. Now I am seeing 1K-7K Lane variations. A few matches have been 6K+ across the entire roster. except our #1 slot.

To get the totals for the sake of comparison as is the idea here, you need the base offensive strength to detemine overall strength. so iether troop levels or if able base offence weights would add a lot of value.

The larger in lane discrepancies are to be expected if there is an effort to match Clans of similar playtyle together, its a necessary side effect.