Collecting Clan War matchups...for science...and stuff!

[666REAPER999]

We just finished another war against a bunch of muppets with a engineered line up and for the icing on the cake we are a level 5 clan and we got matched with a level 10. I just wanted to ask why are rushed players supported by the game? Its pathetic the lengths some people go to do this. You should not even be able to progress a town hall if you havent A: made all the buildings and B: upgraded them!! I believe the matchmaking process is overdone with this 'attack strength' garbage and needs to be simplified. For example this would be much better: no war opposition will have a higher level top player than your own and from there down use a simple average of base levels. If you are a rushed muppet then its tough cookies... Anyone care to discuss or explain this?

Are there no real gamers left anymore?

[OnyxDS]

In the interest of cooperation I've been trying to record some data as you want it. I have to say it takes AGES.

I've added 4 columns below for troops - because often this is what we perceive to be the problem. These relate to the number of significant troops maxed for TH11 or 10. By significant I mean all except barch, wb, goblin, minion. The first column is the number of max TH11 troops. The second is the same, but excluding those which are available at TH10 (ie valks). 3rd column is the number of max TH10 (or better) troops. 4th is the same but excludes any at TH9 levels. I've highlighted the 2 columns of TH11/10 max troops excluding those available at lower levels.

Us:

#	TH	AQ	BK	GW	Sig Max troop	… Exc valks	Sig TH10 max troop	...Exc TH9 witch, loon, healer	EA	IT	Xbow	Can	Mort	Wiz	AT	AD	Tesla	BT	Air S	Walls
1	11	45	41	20	12	11	13	13	2	2x4	4x5	7x15	4x10	5x10	8x15	4x9	4x9	2x5	2x6	40% 11, 60% 10
2	11 (new)	40	40	5	1		14	11	0	2x3	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x4	2x6	Level 11, about 10 lvl 12
3	10	31	28		1		14	11		2x3	3x4	6x13	3x7, 1x8	4x8	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x3	2x5	30% 11, 70% 10
4	10	35	30		1		14	11		0	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	1x2,1x3	2x6	90% 11, 10% 10
5	10	40	40		1		13	10		0	3x4	6x13	4x7	3x8,1x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x2	1x6,1x5	75% 11, 20% 10, 5% 1
6	10	33	23		1		11	8		0	3x3	6x12	4x8	4x8	2x13,5x12	4x8	4x8	1x3?	2x6	80% 10, 20% 9
7	10	35	23		1		10	7		0	2x3	5x13	4x7	4x7	6x13	4x8	4x8	1x3	2x5	50% 10, 50% 9, 1% 11
8	9	12	10				3				2x2	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	95% 9, 5% 8
9	9	6	10				2				2x2	5x11	4x7	4x6	2x11,4x10	4x7	2x7,1x5,1x5	1x2	1x2,1x1	20% 9, 80% 8
10	9	11	10				3				1x1?	5x11	4x6	1x7,3x6	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x4	30% 9, 70% 8
11	9	15	15				2				0	5x11	4x7	3x7?	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	30% 10, 70% 9
12	9	17	15				3				0	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x2	2x4	10% 10, 90% 9
13	9	30	19				2				0	5x10	4x6	1x7,3x6	2x11,4x10	4x6	4x6?	1x2	2x4	All 10
14	9	3	10				1				0	1x11,4x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	4x7	3x7,1x3	1x2	1x4	All 8
15	9	17	18				2				0	5x11	0	4x3	6x11	4x7	4x7	0	2x4	Various
16	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	1x2	1x4	All 8
17	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	1x2	1x4	75% 8, 25% 7
18	8		5									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x5	1x2	1x3	All 7
19	8		6									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	0	1x4	55% 8, 45% 7
20	8		7									5x9	1x6,2x5?	2x4	4x10	3x5	2x3	0	1x3	Max TH7 + new @ 5

(Apparently the post with both tables in is too long, so I'll need to continue this in another post)...

[OnyxDS]

Them:

#	TH	AQ	BK	GW	Sig Max troop	… Exc valks	Sig TH10 max troop	...Exc TH9 witch, loon, healer	EA	IT	Xbow	Can	Mort	Wiz	AT	AD	Tesla	BT	Air S	Walls
1	11	30	30	20	9	8	13	13	2	2x3	4x4	7x14	4x10	3x10,2x9	8x14	4x9	4x9	2x5	2x6	90% 9, 10% 8
2	11	41	45	15	6	5	14	14		2x3	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	1x14,6x13,1x10	4x9	4x9	2x4	2x6	97% 11, 3% 10
3	10	40	40		1		14	11		2x3	3x4	6x12	4x8	2x8,2x7	1x13,5x12,1x11	4x8	4x8	2x2	2x5	60% 11, 40% 10
4	10	24	21		1		6	3		1x2,1x1	1x4,2x3	4x12,2x11	4x7	4x7	3x12,4x11	1x8,3x7	2x8,2x7?	2x3	2x5	90% 10, 9% 11, 1% lower
5	11	27	28	9	1		11	8	0	0	2x4	5x13	4x8	4x9	6x13	1x9,3x8	4x8	1x3	2x6	Max TH11
6	10	25	21		0		4	2		0	3x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	1x8,3x7	1x3	2x5	95% 10, 5% 9
7	10	26	27		0		10	7		0	2x3	2x12,3x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x8	4x8	1x3	2x5	15% 11, 85% 9
8	9	23	22				3				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	95% 10, 5% 9
9	9	14	14				2				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	25% 9, 75% 8
10	9	13	10				2				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	15% 9, 85% 8
11	9	10	12				3				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	20% 9, 80% 8
12	9	11	12				2				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x2	1x4,1x3	40% 9, 60% 8
13	9	12	13				2				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x2	2x3	All 9
14	9	10	11				2				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x1	2x3	60% 9, 40% 8
15	11	14	13	5	1 (dragons)	1	1 (dragons)	1	0	0	1x2	5x6	4x5	3x3	4x6	2x9,2x8	2x9,2x8	1x2	2x5	No walls
16	10	10	10				1 (dragons)	1		0	0	5x9	3x6	2x7	4x10	3x8,1x7	4x7	1x2	2x4	All 7, about TH7/8 number
17	11	4	7	2	0		1 (dragons)	1		0	0	5x8	4x5	2x4	4x8	3x5	2x3?	0?	1x2,1x1	All 7, about TH7/8 number
18	7		0									3x8	2x4	2x3	3x7	2x4	2x1		1x2	85% 6, 15% 1
19	6											3x6	2x3	1x2,1x1	3x6	1x3,1x2			1x1	75% 6, 25% 5
20	10	3	5				1 (dragons)	1				1 Mighty Cannon								No walls

Our win streak at start:0. Their unknown, but I think it was either 0 or 1.
Result was a 56-56 win to us. I wouldn't say the score is particularly informative as neither side achieved the score they should/could have.
Our impression: defence is similar, albeit a bit lumpy. They have an extra inferno base; but their 9.5s were weaker. They were then MUCH stronger at TH9 (all our decent TH9s were opted out and we were very weak there), and then they had some junk at the bottom - which is irrelevant.
We have slightly better total royals (about 370 vs 340 on each), but not a huge difference. However they have an extra big TH11 attack. And an extra account with warden and level 6 dragons. In total they have 5 wardens: you could disregard the level 2, and their warden at #5 sort of matches our #2 (lower warden with TH10 troop levels).
So we have 1 TH11 attacker and 4 inferno targets; they have 2 big TH11s and just 3 inferno targets, and a TH11 dragon only account that gives them essentially 2 free hits on any base #4 downwards. Plus numerous TH10 engineered dragon accounts to take out any TH9s on our side.

This was by no means an awful match - but is absolutely characteristic of what we are seeing every war: the enemy has similar defences, and somewhat similar offence, except for a few extra TH11 attacks thrown in apparently for free. With few TH11s and plenty of TH10s these can be devastating.

I also recorded the war before this, which I'll put in another (pair of) posts...

[OnyxDS]

This is actually the previous war which I recorded at the time but didn't get round to tidying up and posting.

Us:

#	TH	AQ	BK	GW	Sig Max troop	… Exc valks	Sig TH10 max troop	...Exc TH9 witch, loon, healer	EA	IT	Xbow	Can	Mort	Wiz	AT	AD	Tesla	BT	Air S	Walls
1	11	45	41	20	12	11	13	13	2	2x4	4x5	7x15	4x10	5x10	8x15	4x9	4x9	2x5	2x6	40% 11, 60% 10
2	11	45	45	20	11	10	13	13	0	2x3	3x4, 1x2	6x13, 1x12	4x8	4x9,1x7	7x13,1x11	4x8	4x9	2x5	2x6	Max
3	11 (new)	40	40	4	1		14	11	0	2x3	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x4	2x6	All 11
4	10	31	28		1		14	11		2x3	3x4	6x13	3x7, 1x8	4x8	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x3	2x5	30% 11, 70% 10
5	10	35	30		1		14	11		0	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	1x2,1x3	2x6	90% 11, 10% 10
6	10	40	40		1		13	10		0	3x4	6x13	4x7	3x8,1x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x2	1x6,1x5	75% 11, 20% 10, 5% 1
7	10	40	40		1		12	9		0	2x3,1x1	6x13	4x7	4x8	7x13	4x8	4x8	1x3?	2x5	All 11
8	10	36	34		1		10	7		0	2x3	5x13,1x12	4x7	4x8	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x2	2x5	48% 11, 48% 10, 4% 6
9	10	30	25		1		8	5		0	2x3	6x11	4x7	4x7	4x12,3x11	2x8,2x7	1x8,3x7	1x3	2x5	1% 11, 99% 10
10	10	25	25		1		8	5		0	2x4	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	All 10
11	9	21	25				3				2x2	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	50% 10, 50% 9
12	10	21	19		0		4	1		0	2x1	5x12	4x6	4x6	6x13	4x7	4x8	1x1	2x4	20% 9, 80% 8
13	9	12	10				3				2x2	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	95% 9, 5% 8
14	9	11	10				3				1x1?	5x11	4x6	1x7,3x6	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x4	30% 9, 70% 8
15	9	17	15				3				0	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x2	2x4	10% 10, 90% 9
16	9	15	15				2				0	5x11	4x7	3x7?	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	30% 10, 70% 9
17	9	5	6				0				1x2,1x1	3x10,3x9	4x5	1x6,3x5	3x10,3x9	2x6,2x5	1x4,3x3	1x1	1x1?	Approx all 7
18	9	3	10				1				0	1x11,4x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	4x7	3x7,1x3	1x2	1x4	All 8
19	9	17	18				2				0	5x11	0	4x3	6x11	4x7	4x7	0	2x4	Various
20	9	16	17				2				0	5x11	0	4x3	6x11	4x7	4x7	0	1x4?	Various
21	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	1x2	1x4	75% 8, 25% 7
22	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x5	1x2	1x4	70% 8, 30% 7
23	8		5									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x5	1x2	1x3	All 7
24	8		6									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	0	1x4	55% 8, 45% 7
25	8		7									5x9	1x6,2x5?	2x4	4x10	3x5	2x3	0	1x3	Max TH7 + new @ 5

(to be continued due to character limit)

[OnyxDS]

Them:

#	TH	AQ	BK	GW	Sig Max troop	… Exc valks	Sig TH10 max troop	...Exc TH9 witch, loon, healer	EA	IT	Xbow	Can	Mort	Wiz	AT	AD	Tesla	BT	Air S	Walls
1	11	40	40	20	9	8	13	13	0	2x5	4x5	7x14	4x8	4x9,1x8	8x15	4x8	4x9	2x4	2x5	All 10
2	11	39	31	20	8	7	10	10	0	2x5	4x5	7x14	4x7	2x10,3x9	8x15	4x9	4x9	2x3	2x5	95% 10, 5% 11
3	11	30	28	12	7	6	11	11	0	0	4x5	1x14,6x13	4x8	5x9	8x13	3x9,1x8	4x9	2x4	2x5	75% 10, 20% 11, 5% 9
4	11	19	15	10	5	4	9	8	0	0	4x4	4x12,3x11	4x7	1x8,4x7	1x13,6x12,1x11	4x8	4x9	2x2	2x5	All 9
5	11	28	30	12	6	5	8	8	0	0	2x5,1x2,1x1	1x12,4x11,1x10,1x7	4x7	1x9,3x8,1x3	1x15,6x14,1x7	4x9	4x9	1x3?	2x5	Max TH9 + level 6 for new walls
6	10	34	20		1		9	6		0	3x4	6x13	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x4	2x6	65% 11, 35% 10
7	10	38	33		1		9	6		0	3x4	6x12	4x8	2x9,2x8	7x12	4x8	4x8	1x4,1x1	2x6	65% 11, 35% 10
8	11	12	8	10	3	2	5	4	0	0	2x5,2x4	5x11,1x7,1x5	4x7	4x7,1x4	6x12,2x7	4x8	4x7	1x3,1x1	2x5	95% 9, 5% 8
9	10	31	14		1		9	7		0	3x4	5x13,1x12	4x8	4x9	7x13	4x8	4x8	2x4	2x5	65% 11, 30% 10, 5% 9
10	11	10	10	5	2	1	9	7	0	0	3x4	5x13,1x12,1x5	4x8	4x9	7x12,1x6	4x8	4x8	2x2	2x5	80% 9, 20% 8
11	10	27	18		1		8	6		0	3x4	5x12,1x11	4x7	4x7	7x12	4x8	4x8	1x3?	2x5	95% 10, 5% 11
12	10	20	16		1		5	3		0	3x4	6x12	4x7	4x7	1x12,6x11	4x8	4x8	2x2	2x4	95% 9, 5% 10
13	10	16	11		1		6	4		0	3x4	1x13,5x12	4x7	4x8	7x12	4x7	4x8	1x2	2x4	90% 9, 10% 8
14	9	18	12				3				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	75% 10, 25% 9
15	9	18	12				3				2x3	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	75% 10, 25% 9
16	9	11	10				3				2x2	5x11	4x6	1x7,3x6	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x2	2x4	20% 9, 80% 8
17	11	15	10	15	2	2	4	4	0	0	1x1?	5x10	4x6	1x7,3x6	6x10	4x6	4x5	1x1	2x1	50% 9, 50% 8
18	9	12	10				1				2x3	2x11,3x10	4x6	3x7,1x3	5x10,1x6	3x6,1x2	2x7,1x6,1x?	1x2	2x4	50% 9, 50% 8
19	9	13	10				1				2x2	5x10	4x6	4x7	1x11,5x10	4x6	3x6?	1x2	2x4	25% 9, 75% 8
20	9	8	8				1				2x3	5x11	4x7	3x6	5x11	3x5	3x5?	0	1x1?	30% 8, 65% 7, 5% 1
21	9	10	10				2				0	5x11	4x7	4x7	6x11	4x7	4x7	1x3	2x5	25% 9, 75% 8
22	11	8	9	5	1	1	2	2	0	0	0	5x10	1x5,3x5	2x6,2x5	2x11,3x10	4x7	2x7,1x6,1x5	0	2x3	10% 8, 90% 7
23	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	3x6	3x6	1x2	1x4	30% 8, 70% 7
24	10	10	10				3	2		0	0	5x8	3x5	2x4	4x8	3x5	1x7,2x6?	0	1x4	95% 8, 5% higher
25	8		10									5x10	4x6	3x6	5x10	2x6,1x5	3x6	1x1	1x2	25% 8, 75% 7

We started this on a WS of 2, and I think they were similar, and we lost this one.

Our impressions: defences are again not far off equivalent, but lumpy. We have an extra eagle on #1, although it's not relevant as neither clan was really in a position to try to 3*. We have 2 extra sets of infernos at #3&4 - however their point defences were substantially stronger on some upper bases negating much of the advantage. They also had several extra "9.5" defensive bases - ie infernoless but well in excess of a TH9, so requiring a TH10 attack, and ultimately that's what sank us. I don't remember how the TH9 defences compared but neither side had any problem clearing those (10 down our side, 14 down their side), so they were basically irrelevant.

The big problem is again on offence. We had 2 big TH11 attacks, plus a new one that's effectively TH10 still. So 2 bases with TH11 troops and wardens; and 8 more with at least 1 TH10 max troop, totalling 10. Whereas they had 9 bases with 1 or more max TH11 troops, all with GW 5+; and a total of 16 bases with some TH10-max troops.

The total number of TH10 max troops listed in my table isn't very much higher for them. But they have upgraded 2, 3 or 4 troops on numerous bases, which they could then spam. Whereas all our TH10s were upgrading all troops, so apart from the bottom few had fairly complete sets. The enemy are only spamming 2 or 3 troops each, so any further upgrades would have no effect on their war strength - are our extra troops counting against us? Ie is the system still counting extra troops too much and not focussing enough on the first 2 or 3?

Overall it left us with about 20 possible attacks on 13 bases; whereas they had something like 30 viable attacks on our top 10 bases. We were attacking similar targets (9.5s our side, 9.11s their side), but we were using TH10 troops, they had TH11, and we required a much higher success rate. It wasn't impossible to win the war: they only killed 1 of our 4 inferno bases despite multiple big TH11 attacks; but we failed on some of their lower bases - especially the 9.11s with 4 xbows, not least due to time. They could just spam the score they got; to match we needed a lot of successes on attacks that were certainly possible, but by no means automatic.

[SuperStorm103]

Good posts Onyx. Did you see mine above? It's not really a horrible match for us, but experiencing the same thing with opposing clan have more wardens and higher offense. We are a bit beefier on defense. As you can see 3 of them have 3 th11 troops only (Healers/Hounds/Loons). I am in the same boat as my labs on both my 10's are maxed (no selective upgrades).

I fail to see why there is such a discrepancy in offense numbers. Especially since our war the other clan has 5 additional max/almost max wardens.

[OnyxDS]

Good posts Onyx. Did you see mine above? It's not really a horrible match for us, but experiencing the same thing with opposing clan have more wardens and higher offense. We are a bit beefier on defense. As you can see 3 of them have 3 th11 troops only (Healers/Hounds/Loons). I am in the same boat as my labs on both my 10's are maxed (no selective upgrades).

I fail to see why there is such a discrepancy in offense numbers. Especially since our war the other clan has 5 additional max/almost max wardens.

It's what we've been seeing every war since update #1. Literally every single war the enemy has had a few extra TH11 attacks thrown in for free. I think it got better with the second update. But that's better, not fixed. Before it was completely crazy: at one point 3 wardens 45 levels to us against 15 totalling 240+ for them (and many of them full 45/45/20s). It's not a completely new thing - the low weighting of the warden was notorious enough that there's been comments about the "free warden effect" and such for months.

[Rebecca00]

#

Our impressions:

The big problem is again on offence. We had 2 big TH11 attacks, plus a new one that's effectively TH10 still. So 2 bases with TH11 troops and wardens; and 8 more with at least 1 TH10 max troop, totalling 10. Whereas they had 9 bases with 1 or more max TH11 troops, all with GW 5+; and a total of 16 bases with some TH10-max troops.

The total number of TH10 max troops listed in my table isn't very much higher for them. But they have upgraded 2, 3 or 4 troops on numerous bases, which they could then spam. Whereas all our TH10s were upgrading all troops, so apart from the bottom few had fairly complete sets. The enemy are only spamming 2 or 3 troops each, so any further upgrades would have no effect on their war strength - are our extra troops counting against us? Ie is the system still counting extra troops too much and not focussing enough on the first 2 or 3?

Overall it left us with about 20 possible attacks on 13 bases; whereas they had something like 30 viable attacks on our top 10 bases. We were attacking similar targets (9.5s our side, 9.11s their side), but we were using TH10 troops, they had TH11, and we required a much higher success rate. It wasn't impossible to win the war: they only killed 1 of our 4 inferno bases despite multiple big TH11 attacks; but we failed on some of their lower bases - especially the 9.11s with 4 xbows, not least due to time. They could just spam the score they got; to match we needed a lot of successes on attacks that were certainly possible, but by no means automatic.

A great post and your impressions about offense are exactly what we’re seeing. It all comes down to offensive troops; an effective matchmaking system really must take this into account.

[Rebecca00]

Good posts Onyx. Did you see mine above? It's not really a horrible match for us, but experiencing the same thing with opposing clan have more wardens and higher offense. We are a bit beefier on defense. As you can see 3 of them have 3 th11 troops only (Healers/Hounds/Loons). I am in the same boat as my labs on both my 10's are maxed (no selective upgrades).

I fail to see why there is such a discrepancy in offense numbers. Especially since our war the other clan has 5 additional max/almost max wardens.

YES! We’re in the same boat...again. We’re in a 20x20 and their 16 is a .1 TH11 with maxed offense and heroes. We have one 11 to their five. Like virtually every war we’re in, this will come down to a battle of who gets the most off of the 1. I’m our 11– fairly new 11, high heroes because we’re maxers, TH10 defenses except for 2 ads and five troop/spell ugs. Their 1 is a nearly maxed 11 (only an L2 EA). I’m pretty confident about my base and I’m pretty confident about attacking him. Only problem is that they’ll have at least 3 11s hit me and scout before they unleash the Big Dog (their 16). It ALL comes down to offense and the best predictor of that is TH level...nothing else.

[Tomville]

Another spin here and a worse mismatch than the last, again in our favour. Details to follow. It’s our 9 th11 and 1 th10 vs 7 th11 and 3 th9, all maxer style bases, all their th11 max except some hero levels and some bad walls. Their th9s are probably minis, near max defences but mostly single digit heros.

It is sad to think of the poor war experience this clan and our last match had. My only comfort is that looking at us they will know that it’s not happened because we set out to get any unfair advantage over them, but rather from a matchmaker that’s not yet avoiding th11 mismatching.

As promised, full match details:

TH

Q

K

W

EA

IT

XB

CN

M

WT

AT

AD

T

BT

AS

WALLS

US

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

282x11 18x10

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

1x12 21x11 268x10 10x9

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

6x13 1x11

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

295x11 5x10

11

45

40

20

1

2x4

3x4 1x2

6x13

4x7

4x9 1x7

8x13

4x8

4x8

2x2

2x6

9x12 291x11

11

45

40

20

1

2x4

3x4 1x2

6x13

4x7

4x9 1x7

8x13

4x8

4x8

2x2

2x6

7x12 293x11

10

25

23

X

X

2x3

3x4

6x13

4x8

4x9 1x7

7x13

4x8

4x8

2x4

2x6

85x10 190x9

THEM

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

75x12 225x11

11

45

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

220x11 80x10

11

44

45

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x15

4x10

5x10

8x15

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

90x11 110x10

11

41

35

20

2

2x5

4x5

5x15 2x13

4x10

5x10

3x15 4x14 1x13

4x9

4x9

2x5

2x6

250x10 50x9

11

41

40

20

2

2x5

4x5

7x13

4x10

5x10

6x14 2x13

4x9

4x9

2x4

2x6

30x10 240x9 2x5 28x4

9

12

14

X

X

X

2x3

5x11

4x7

4x7

3x11 3x10

1x7 3x6

4x7

1x3

2x5

40 x 10 210x9

9

13

11

X

X

X

2x3

5x10

1x7 3x6

4x6

6x10

3x6 1x2

4x6

1x2

1x4 1x1

50x9 200x8

9

7

5

X

X

X

2x2

5x11

4x7

1x7 3x6

4x10 2x9

2x7 2x6

4x6

1x1

1x1 (1 missing)

40x9 60x8 150x7

Result to follow, war is not over yet. (Well no more over than it was on prep day, anyhow.)

Edit: unsurprising result is we won 23-20, they gave up near the end when they realised that it could not be won with 2 th11 attacks left and left our smallest th11 only 1 starred.