I'm in two clans and one match up was not so extremely off but the other one was the worst I've seen so far. We've had our share of engineering opponents but nothing like this. I'd take the old matchmaking system over this anyday
I'm in two clans and one match up was not so extremely off but the other one was the worst I've seen so far. We've had our share of engineering opponents but nothing like this. I'd take the old matchmaking system over this anyday
Searched for 25 minutes to find the most engineered clan I've ever seen. Top 3 are .5 style other 7 full blown lopsided. I wouldn't call it unwinable but the top is better both on offense and defense while there are plenty of th9s (5 of them) to take out my single 9. Rest are 8s easily stomped but all those 9s won't help much on my top base (10.5). Everything bought except eagle.
I have posted a few times in this thread about the poor MM system. I would be remissed if i didn't report on this latest war search as well. This was our 4th search under the new algorithm and probably the most fair yet although it is still a slightly uphill battle but one that we can overcome unlike the first 3 searches.Originally Posted by Summermilk
I had to scrub the lineup down to a 10v10 from our usual of 20v20 or 25v25. This was due to half the clan tires of being overmatched as well as I wasn't gonna put any people who had just made it to a new town hall but hadn't gotten all the defenses. I wanted to eliminate any possibility of a base being considered "engineered". Having said that this war search took only 20 min and came out as follows:
US: 2th11s one just recently to 11 but with all defenses and one almost max. 3 th9s, 3 th8s, a 7 and a 6.
THEM: 2 TH11S(WE HAVE ADVANTAGE ON HEROES), 6 TH9s and 2 th8s.
Although they have a few more 9s than we do, a couple of those 9s are rushed and easily 3 starred by an 8.
This may not be the most fair matchup but it's the best we have had since the latest change in the algorithm.
On another note, I feel the need to get rhis off my chest and it is aimed at the SC hierarchy. I am "Twisted" player #2LGYRU9C leader of a lvl11 clan, Gorillas, clan #PLRYU20U. I speak on behalf of the millions of disheartened fans of this game who have spent countless hours climbing the town hall ladder to get where we are only to have that ladder pushed out from under us. What you have done to this game over the last few updates is mind boggling.
What was the purpose of the giant taking a hiatus??? That was a complete waste of time and energy to even push that out to the masses. Could it be that Supercell recognizes the fault of their ways and is trying to divert our attention in other directions, i.e. builder hall?
We are all avid lovers and players of this game but with any relationship, too much take and not enough give leads to a disenchantment in that relationship. When is enough going to be enough? You have taken enough and I refuse to sit here anymore while you take, take take.
As players, it's time we stand up and organize a boycott of all supercell games until SC realizes it's us- the consumer- that makes them a multi million dollar company. When we stop playing, Supercell ceases to exist and maybe then our voices will be heard.
You can ban my account if you want. By doing so, you'll probably do me a "solid".
We also have got the same results, removing all engineered did found even matches with no engineers.
We tried also leaving one(just one) engineered account, and the MM returned engineered clan.
Remove all engineers if you want fair matches.
Last edited by dumdum2; September 3rd, 2017 at 06:44 PM.
Fyi we dont have 1..still matched against a little extreme .5 clan...We also have got the same results, removing all engineered did found even matches with no engineers.
We tried also leaving one(just one) engineered account, and the MM returned engineered clan.
Remove all engineers if you want fair matches.
Just add 2 to 3 th6 at bottom and you good to go with engineered bases at the middle..
Its ridiculous.
Max GW should weight more than max th10 defenses.
Last edited by shibstorm; September 3rd, 2017 at 07:06 PM.
Lol 'wahhhh so much mismatch.' Has quite a few .5s in their lineup trying to take advantage of MM. get rid of those.
Last edited by Runz; September 3rd, 2017 at 06:58 PM.
What??
1 th10 vs max th11 + 2 th9.5 (3 th6 at bottom)
And the search time was 30+ minutes..
Last edited by shibstorm; September 3rd, 2017 at 07:04 PM.
.5? are those also engineers? please... .5 shouldn't bother anyone
Not exactly .5 its a little bit more..
Us...
Th10 (max)
9 th9 ( mid to max )
10 th8 ( mid to max)
Enemy
Th11 ( max queen max warden max troop th10 defenses + all max xbows)
Th10 (max troop, lvl 2 infernos th9 lvl point defense)
Th10 (all max troop , lvl 1 inferno , th9 lvl point defenses)
6 th9 ( mid to max)
Th10 (engineered)
7 th8
3 th6
Now tell me which side is going to win the war??
And now SC working on some stupid live war where all attacks are going to be th11 vs th10 3* attacks..
Last edited by shibstorm; September 3rd, 2017 at 07:26 PM.
Dear supercell staff, i have an idea and i hope you can take it seriously. The builder base does not allow us to upgrade the builder hall without installing all the defenses so why not implement the same rule into the village base. That would eliminate the problem of engineered bases. As for the existing engineered bases, they should have an indefinite war timer that wont dissapear until they install all the defenses. Think about it.
Posting Permissions
