War MM & Cannon Cart changes - the FEEDBACK thread!

[TheWarDictator]

Second war 15 v 15

US (387-112-2)
1: TH 11, 45 BK, 45 AQ, 20 GW, 109K
2: TH 11, 45 BK, 45 AQ, 20 GW, 109K
3: TH 10.5, 38 BK, 41 AQ, 16 GW, 92K
4: TH 10.5, 45 BK, 45 AQ, 20 GW, 91K
5: TH 10.5, 44 BK, 45 AQ, 20 GW, 91K
6: TH 9.5, 30 BK, 33 AQ, 73K
7: TH 9.5, 22 BK, 25 BK, 70K
8: TH 9, 30 BK, 30 AQ, 70K
9: Eng 11, 45 BK, 45 AQ, 20 GW, 60K
10: TH 8.5, 10 BK, 12 AQ, 60K
11: Eng 10, 17 BK, 20 AQ, 58K
12: TH 8, 10 BK, 55K
13: TH 8, 9 BK, 40K
14: TH 6, 21K
15: Defenseless 9, 6 BK, 5 AQ, 10K

THEM (190-104-1)
1: TH 11, 42 BK, 44 AQ, 20 GW, 108K
2: TH 11, 35 BK, 42 AQ, 20 GW, 107K
3: TH 10.5, 40 BK, 40 AQ, 20 GW, 90K
4: TH 10.5, 31 BK, 40 AQ, 8 GW, 89K
5: TH 10, 25 BK, 25 AQ, 87K
6: TH 10, 25 BK, 25 AQ, 87K
7: TH 10, 28 BK, 30 AQ, 87K
8: TH 9.5, 24 BK, 25 AQ, 74K
9: TH 9.5, 21 BK, 24 AQ, 70K
10: TH 9, 19 BK, 19 AQ, 67K
11: TH 9, 18 BK, 19 AQ, 66K
12: TH 9, 21 BK, 21 BK, 66K
13: TH 8, 6 BK, 50K
14: TH 7, 4 BK, 38K
15: TH 6, 29K

Going to be a rough war for them. 80/20 in our favor.

[Summermilk]

why do I feel that you wouldn't be here giving your feedback if your engineering had worked

If you see my roster closely, you know that our clan is not giving a bad lineup. We dont have th11 sneaking between th 9's or anything like that. The defenseless th9 is prety much what we have, and that was the result of meeting some defenseless th11 at the bottom of our opponents from time to time, which frustrated us.

We have always came up with quite a balanced matchups, the same amount of th11 at the top, almost the same amount of th 9-10s. We were never really on an advantage, war was hard enough, we win or lose depending on strategy n some luck, meeting the same kind of clans with some th 10,5 and th9,5, which I have no problem with. But the last 3 matcup was really the worst. I'm talking about 5 th11s against 15 th11s. That's why I am here, giving a feedback, that the matcups lately has gone wayyy off.

[TheWarDictator]

The one thing that seems to be consistent is that townhall 10s with heavy defense and weak offense are hurting your clan.

They add a lot of war weight without much value.

[STRIKER44]

Ok just did another war search.....3 for 3.....another th 11 max war troops with us having no th 11. They also have another th11 that has max dragons and grand warden. Not sure how much tje dragon will hurt us but their top player should easily 3 star our top 2. it's another very bad match. Guess having a th 10 with higher heros is something now a disadvantage.

[bigdogdigs]

Judging by our latest match this balancing has only worked to favour engineered clans it was terrible before but now disastrous. .. turn back the clock

[Coyle]

Yeah so I thought this change was meant to give better matches?! Every war since the changes have seen us come up against engineered clans with more TH11s than us at the top whilst them still havingTH10/11s mixed through the 8/9s as well.

The last system chucked up the odd bad match for us, but this system seems to stick it to us every time. We managed to win one, but lost the last two by %. Last one would have been a win if I'd had a few more seconds versus their 11s which a
ways hurts. This current matchup is going to be a loss IMO cos they just have way too much firepower to even compete.

Nonsense.

[BAR917]

We are a mixed clan of th levels and engineers and maxers. Our 1st 2 wars we have we been out matched on max th11 hits and it seems worse then before. We are a decent war clan so the wars always come down to the end even when outmatched but when down on max th11 hits its just hard to win unless the other clan is not that good or just blows it some how. Our problem is that we seem to rarely get the advantage the other way not that we want an advantage but it seems we would have it 50% of the time right? Well hope with some tweaks on the fly they can get it worked out. In the end everyone deserves to play the game the way they see fit and get even war matches. Is this possible? I have no idea but hope so.

Well we have finished both the wars and just wanted to give an update. We lost our 1st match by 1 star we were out matched but as I stated above we are almost always in our wars no matter the match. How ever we won the 2nd war and therefore its hard to say we were outmatched even though we were when it comes to th11 v th11 max troop attacks. We have spun our 3rd war now and this one looks fairly even but we have a 2 th11 hit advantage at 1st look I think we will take this war but you never know. In my opinion I was to rushed to give an opinion the 1st time. We just need more searches and more wars to really know that outcome of the changes.

[Troythethird]

We are two wars into the so called "War matchmaking improvement". And both wars we got screwed royally, max th11s out the wazoo. I liked it better under the old system. I know SC is trying really hard, but jeeze, give us a break!

[llams28]

2nd matchup with this system was worse than the 1st. (Both of which were worse than what we normally saw under the old system.)

We have:
2, 11s (1 max, 1 mid)
5, 10s (2 high, 1 mid, 2 lower)

They have:
6, 11s (2 high, 1 mid, 3 engineered)
3, 10s (1 high, 1 mid, 1 lower)

By high, mid, and low I'm referring to their relative progress at being a TH of that lvl. "Low" TH10 would be 25/25 heros, no infernos, not much upgraded D beyond TH9 lvl.

[Colin94]

Third war: Both have a max th11 at the top. We have a th10.5 and a rushed th11, they have two th10. Both have a few .5 and engineers. We have three defenseless th9 with weak heroes and no th9 troops at the bottom and they have two th3.

A good match for us again.