War MM & Cannon Cart changes - the FEEDBACK thread!

[CHANDRIANO]

Our current war was reasonable fair. 2 th10s for each side. We have an advantage of 2 early th9 (with xbows) on our side, but they have more th8 on the middle. There is one heavily lopsided base for each clan (1 defenseless th10 with lvl4 dragons and no queen for us and one defenseless th11 with lvl 2 miners and no warder for them).
We have 4 th6 at the bottom and they have some th8 with low defense at their bottom. So we are a little stronger at defenses and they are a little stronger at offense. But it's a good match, both clans have similar win chances.

[Refuse]

In our current war we have 1 th11, 10 th10, 3 th9 and 1 th8

And are matched against 4 th11, 2 th10, 1 th11, 1 th10, 1 th11, 1 th9, 3 th11, 1 th9 and 1 th5


In that order 👎👎

I like the initiative to fix the engineering. But why don't you just match th lvl against the same th lvl?

[strandwolfza]

I like the initiative to fix the engineering. But why don't you just match th lvl against the same th lvl?

as a maxer I support this suggestion

[MazerFromAbove]

I've seen a lot of posts on here saying if you have engineered bases in your clan, you are going to get an engineered matchup. You get what you deserve!

Well, a lot of clans were tired of getting their butts kicked by unfair matchmaking and encouraged their members to stop building defenses at all. Why? Because the matchmaking algorithm that has been in place basically penalized you for building and upgrading defenses when it comes to wars. They found only offense mattered in your war matchup.

So if now you can only actually get a fair matchup when you have zero engineered bases as defined in the current MM algorithm (a claim that I don't believe is necessarily true), can SuperCell come out and define what an engineered base is to them? I'd be happy to keep out any bases from our war until they are "un-engineered" and give my clan instructions on how to get them up to par if I knew what the criteria was.

We're just looking for a matchup in war where skill determines the winner. The matches were awful half of the time before this update and even worse both times we've warred since the MM. So tired of having matching clans with 5 TH11s in the middle of the order with max air troops that can wipe out our early TH10s and TH9s when we are mostly a TH10 and below clan.

[HwrdII]

Amen Pete. Amen. --H

Hi, current war is not a fair matchup at all, so the new system didn't work for this one. 15vs15. Opponent is 4x11, 5x10, 3x9, 2x8 ans 1x7. We are 0x11, 6x10, 4x9, 5x8. We need to match up th levels better, no way we should have to take on 4 th11 when we have zero.

[Summermilk]

3rd war in the new MM. Still really bad
Us
4 th 11 mid max with max heroes.
1 th10,5 with lvl 40/40/5 heroes
7 th 10 with (various level of defense, with lvl 1 infernos mostly)
3 th 9,5
6 th 9
2 th 8
1 th7
1 defenseless th9.


Theirs
5 th11 max with max heroes and walls
3 th 11 with no ea
1 th 9,5
4 th 11 with no inferno
1 th 10 with 1 xbow
1 th 11 with no xbow
3 th 9
The rest are th8's and some th10 wifh no xbow
1 defenseless th 11 at the bottom.

Look at how many Wardens and maxed lavaloon they have against ours.

Please teach us how the new algorithm works because I don't see how those matchup can be BALANCED.

[strandwolfza]

3rd war in the new MM. Still really bad
Us
4 th 11 mid max with max heroes.
1 th10,5 with lvl 40/40/5 heroes
7 th 10 with (various level of defense, with lvl 1 infernos mostly)
3 th 9,5
6 th 9
2 th 8
1 th7
1 defenseless th9.


Theirs
5 th11 max with max heroes and walls
3 th 11 with no ea
1 th 9,5
4 th 11 with no inferno
1 th 10 with 1 xbow
1 th 11 with no xbow
3 th 9
The rest are th8's and some th10 wifh no xbow
1 defenseless th 11 at the bottom.

Look at how many Wardens and maxed lavaloon they have against ours.

Please teach us how the new algorithm works because I don't see how those matchup can be BALANCED.

were you expecting a fair match when you decided to take that defeseless and those engineered bases to war? you weren't, I don't know, trying to get an.... hmm.... advantage over the opponent by engineering your clan, were you?


I guess it backfired
#engineerbetternexttime

[MazerFromAbove]

were you expecting a fair match when you decided to take that defeseless and those engineered bases to war? you weren't, I don't know, trying to get an.... hmm.... advantage over the opponent by engineering your clan, were you?


I guess it backfired
#engineerbetternexttime

Please just leave this thread. You add nothing to the conversation repeatedly posting the same type of comments.

[Brenna]

last three matches we have been overwhelmed with th11s. We have none

last match us 7 th10 9 th9s them 10 th11 7 th10 9 th9

Never seen it this bad. Much like a lot of others facing the same issue we will prob stop doing wars soon. There is simply no point. We lost every war. This is not a case of them being bad fighters, they three starred out inferno bases. We could not three star their maxed th11 including infernos but no warden.

So many saying this is due to having engineered accounts but if you have read this whole thread and the ones in the war sub forum you will see its happening to ALL types of clan. Seems the only ones that are getting decent matches are guys running small wars... but not all small wars. I've seen some pretty bad matches for them too.

Fact is if you dont have a bunch of th11s in war then there is no point having a war. GW has killed this game for anyone other than other th11s.

[strandwolfza]

Please just leave this thread. You add nothing to the conversation repeatedly posting the same type of comments.

you can add me to your ignore list if you want

just click on my name, then click on 'view profile'. below my profile picture there's 'add to ignore list', click on it and then confirm