War MM & Cannon Cart changes - the FEEDBACK thread!

[brittanymorgan256]

we had a war matchup right after the latest update. & were extremely outmatched, our war weight was actually higher than theirs, BUT they had FOUR TH11's with a lot of maxed troops, we had only ONE TH11 with only 3 maxed troops. so there was NO way we could begin to compete, they had no problem clearing every single base of ours, so even though we tried our absolute best (all the while knowing we would lose) we lost of course! how in the world can ONE TH11 get matched up with 4 TH11's when they have so many maxed troops??????!!!!!! it's beyond ridiculous. below is the table, not that it will help much because it doesnt account for the maxed troops that the enemy team had.

	TH	AQ	BK	GW	EA	IT	XB	WT(K)		TH	AQ	BK	GW	EA	IT	XB	WT(K)
1	10	40	40			3,3	4,4,4	89	1	11	25	25	11		3,3	4,4,4	89
2	10	33	30			2,2	4,4,2	85	2	11	23	19	12			5,5,4,3	76
3	10	25	25			2,1	2,2,2	83	3	11	20	16	12			4,4	72
4	10	22	20				3,3	70	4	11	16	13	6			3,3,3	71
5	9	25	27				3,3	69	5	10	12	10				3,3	67
6	11	25	22	13				66	6	9	12	12				3,3	67
7	9	18	17					63	7	10	11	10					61
8	9	8	10				3,3	63	8	9	6	10					61
9	10	20	19					62	9	9	5	10					60
10	10	38	32					61	10	9	5	10					59
11	9	15	12					61	11	10	6	10					55
12	9	16	15					59	12	8		10					55
13	9	8	10					58	13	8		8					54
14	9	9	10					50	14	8		9					47
15	8		8					49	15	10	1	9					47
16	8		7					47	16	8		7					46
17	9	6	6					32	17	9		7					36
18	9	5	5					28	18	9		3					27
19	8		3					26	19	9		3					24
20	5							20	20	3							5
								1141									1079

[Rocket404]

The clan war matchmaking system is far worse than before. We seem to always get 5 th 11's versus our 4 th 11's. What makes it even worse is we have 2 th 8's matched against a th 9 and a th 10. While the th 10 is engineered, they have a level 25 AQ, and 26 BK, along with 2 level 3 xbows, and 1 level 2 xbow...Please tell me what th 8 you know of can expect to do well against that?

[SuperStorm103]

The MMA algorithm seems to be glitchy the last few wars.

It cannot seem to count numbers correctly. It appears that thinks 6 = 12 in wardens department, multiple max th11 offense cancel each other out (only for the opposing clan who is on a win streak of 0) so they can have 24 max hits vs 12 for the good guys. And since their offense cancels out, they get to make up our offensive weight in their defense weight.

At least that is how it looks to me when all our 9's are maxed against infernoless 10's with upgraded points and AD's (and of course max offense for th10).

you guys were going good, I was happy with the forward steps. It was improving I could see it! My match data (in the clan wars sub forum was showing it!) Now it seems you guys are going backwards again and we are in another downward spiral.......

[Ak7lives]

Before the change, we got about a 50/50 ratio of matches in our favor. My only complaint was that there weren’t more close matches. Since the change we haven’t had a match in our favor. There must be clans out there that have gained an advantage. They’re just not posting because they’re happy. We just got matched in a 20v20 war against a clan that has 3 TH11s with max offense & defense, and then are defenseless from 11-20. It’s already over. (their record shows they’re competent attackers) I don’t know when the next adjustment is due, but we were a clan of 45-50 who are already down to 30-35 and 20 in war. And I’m a couple wars away from taking a COC break. Maybe I’ve been playing for way too long and it’s time to move on.

[RocketPackBlaster]

Our TH10 members didn't want to play last weekend or this as they are tired of being matched against TH11's they get 3 starred by and can only 2 star. It sounds like things haven't improved and they are losing interest in fighting lopsided wars. It does seem the only way to truly fix this is match based on TH level first, then potentially on Eagles, Inferno's, Xbows and troop strength. However this may break engineering in the game if an engineered TH has to meet an equivalent TH with proper defenses dropped. Sounds like I won't be warring for a while but will be watching this thread for improvements to hopefully sell our TH10's on to come back.

[GrudgeTaker]

We just did a 20 v 20 war, we have 1 th11; our opponents have 6 th11s, their top 3 are near max; they even have a defenceless th11 at the bottom with max dragons. Worst match I’ve ever seen, and I’ve seen some bad ones.

[SalisburyHogs]

Since the MM update we're getting matched against more "engineered" bases than ever, but also clans 4 levels above us. As a combined result out of the last 7 wars we've won 1. Previously we would win at least 1 in 3, please sort the MM out! Why not make TH upgrades similar to the BB upgrades. No moving on till all items are built for that level. If TH sniping was made un-gamely like, why not treat engineered bases in the same way?

[SalisburyHogs]

Or match TH in wars to TH levels to allow engineered bases!

[GrudgeTaker]

Our latest match is 20 v 20; we have 16 th10s, 4 th9s.... wait for it....

...they have 8 th11s, 7 th10s, 4 th9s and a th8.

Their no1 has maxed infernos, maxed eagle, lvl11 warden, all defences higher than max th10 level, lvl24 queen, lvl22 king.
Their no2 has lvl4 infernos, maxed eagle, lvl8 warden, high defences and lvl18 king and queen
Their no3 has maxed infernos, all defences at th10 level or higher, lvl13 warden, lvl17 queen, lvl13 king
Their no4 has lvl4 infernos, lvl6 warden, all defences at max th10 level or higher, lvl27 queen, lvl25 king...

...their no7 and no10 have max bowlers and max laloon. This is beyond a joke.

[MaximusMinimus]

The "New War MM Algorithm" was theoretically supposed to pit engineered clans versus other engineered clans, and non-engineered clans versus other non-engineered clans, am I correct? Please do correct me if I am wrong, but if that was not the intention then why any change at all. Anyway to my point... My clan is ZERO engineered and getting paired just about every war with heavily engineered clans?? I am not talking about 1 or two bases that may be engineered, I am talking TH 11s sitting at the bottom slot with maxed heros, and majority of the rest of the people in the clan following suit. We have a TH 7 at our bottom slot. Our number 1 base is a fully maxed out TH 11 defense, offense, heros and spells. We ran a 10 vs. 10 war last time with bases ranging as follows: 11,11,10,10,10,10,9,9,8,7, and their number 6 base attacked our number 1 base because he had maxed troops and heros... I'm just thoroughly confused at what is going on with this game at the moment, and would like a little transparency from the people at Supercell. The very least you can do is explain what is going on.