After a 5 war win streak my clan (who have not engineered bases at all), have a 15 v 15 war match.
We have 8 th10s, 6 th9s and a th8; they have 5 th11s, 5 th10s, 4 th9s and a th8.
It’s fair to say that Supercell’s weak stance on engineering isn’t going down well in my clan at the moment.
the new matchmaking is beyond a joke. We're a lvl14 clan who have significant war experience. Current spin, 30v we are running 1 th11, no eagle. Rest are th10, th9, th8. We pull 11 th11s, yep eleven, 4 of which have eagle defence. Do I expect perfection, no. This however is ridiculous and is in danger of turning people off of the game.
Where is the incentive for me not to engineer my maxed th9 to th11?
The algorithm is not learning. From a starting point of the above, it's broken. Well and truly "friar tucked"!
Thanks for the try, I guess...
We're an L13 clan. We're maxers and, like many, we've been matched against a lot of engineered clans. We typically win, but the real trouble comes in when we run our single TH11 against engineers with several engineered TH11s who actually know how to attack and use their troops. Since the matchmaking improvement four weeks ago, more of our matches have been against engineered clans.
Our current war is a 15x15 and that match was found in 23 minutes. We have one TH11 to their four TH11s, including their #15 who sits at the bottom with his L4 drags....doesn't get much more egngineerd than that! We have three TH10s to their four TH10s. We have seven TH9s to their six th9s. We have three TH8s to their one TH8. (We don't like the th8-11 TH spread in such small wars, but have a lot out for hero ugs atm). We're one a two war win streak and they're on a three war win streak. These guys are good, too. How do I know, you might ask? We were matched against them 35 days ago and lost bc of their abundance of 11s.
I feel kind of foolish for posting the same kind of stuff on the forums in hopes that substantial changes will actually be made to the matchmaking system to restore it to its once former glory. Hope is a powerful motivator, though!
Thanks for taking the time to read another one of these posts...I know there are many stories similar to the one I've reported. Just wish they'd be taken seriously enough to effect serious change.
Originally Posted by Huarty
Wow!!!! That is insane. I really hope your opponent can't attack like so many of the engineers we see. I agree.....new matchmaking is ridiculous.
A little feedback, just matched 30v30. BD for us (random spin, whoever is opted in) 6 TH 11's/6 TH 10's/14 TH 9's/4 TH 8's, not a single .5 or engineered base. We found 9 TH 11's (all almost maxed defensively)/2 9.9's (TH 11 offense TH 9 defense)/12 TH 9's (almost all completely maxed)/1 9.5 with maxed heros/1 TH 11 with TH 7 defenses with maxed Lalo and hero's. But it's all balanced because they have 5 TH 3's at the bottom, Ridiculous.
So to be clear, in a 30 man war they have 3 more TH 11's (9 total), all with EAs (all maxed defensively or very close) to our 6. They ALSO have 24 GW attacks to our 12 (All GW's are maxed on both sides). We are in a casual clan to just have fun and joke around. Most are in the MLCW and are just relaxing atm. Absolutely a joke, and some wonder why the game is going downhill. I'm just posting feedback as asked, not looking for pity.
Search took about 30 minutes for anyone interested.
Last edited by Millerman78; September 27th, 2017 at 01:50 AM.
hi,
i think the best solution for the clan wars MatchMaking is to set the max number of top opponnents town hall according to the max number of our clans.
if i have 3 town hall 11 in my clan, i should get at max 3 th 11 in opponnent clan, in this way the war will be more equal despite the rest of the opponnent town halls.
We haven't faced a non-engineered clan since the new match making came out. We finally came across a clan where almost every base is TH11 ranging from defenseless to a full TH11. #9QP0V0Q
Last edited by Swoness; September 27th, 2017 at 07:19 PM. Reason: Title cut off
Its so bad its almost like it was intentional lol
*sigh* as mentioned before we are not an engineered clan, meet our matchup after the “newest” MM changes:
We have 3 th11's, a th10, 5 th9's, 3 th8s, 3 th7s and a th3
they have 3 th11's, a th10, 10 th9's and all the way at #15 another th11
all their th9's have xbows, so none of our bottom 6 bases can kill anything except 15
it actually looks like it got worse again.
oh search took 25 mins to find this “fair” matchup and we aren’t on a streak since it got broken on our last matchup (which was actually an even match, beats me how they can do it one time and screw us royally the next search)
Last edited by Daralight; September 28th, 2017 at 04:43 AM.
friends and fun (est dec 10th 2014)thx terminus for the amazing sig
what the bottom 15 look like? Max drags? How do your TH 11s compare with theirs? Heroes, eagle offense?
Posting Permissions
