Originally Posted by 2222
While the announcement on social media doesn't tell us anything, it at least tells us that they are proactively looking at the data post the recent MM changes, and are considering 'more refinements'. Lets hope they are looking at individual weights.
Hope springs eternal!
Clan Name : SOUTH WEST 45, Clan Tag : #90LP2PL. Highest Win Streak 12!
Clan Details : Established 2012! Adult, English speaking International Level 18 War Clan (twice a week). Recruitment Thread : https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...10-s-to-TH12-s My Spec : TH13.
Our match last night actually appears fairly even at first glance:While the announcement on social media doesn't tell us anything, it at least tells us that they are proactively looking at the data post the recent MM changes, and are considering 'more refinements'. Lets hope they are looking at individual weights.
Hope springs eternal!
Us: 0/7/11/ 7/4/1
Them: 0/7/ 9/10/4/0
Hero levels are about the same, with a slight advantage to them.
25v25, our clan got matched to a clan with 6 th11s to our 3 (all legit th11s with eagles).
All of their th11s are maxed or near maxed with eagles maxed offenses and heroes. They have sandbagged their bottom with 4 defenseless th3 accounts, a defenseless th7.
We have no engineered accounts. Even number of th10s, but we have Three 9.5s (new th10s without infernos) to their two 9.5s (near max th10s without infernos).
This is lame. Sandbagging is lame. Fix this ♥♥♥♥ supercell.
Last edited by Jdub12; September 15th, 2017 at 11:08 PM.
Have they tweak the mm???
Our wars are 10v10, lately the other clans usually have 1 or 2 more th11 than us, which I figure isn't too bad,
In our latest war it's 6 th11 vs our 2 th11. Really supercell?
We are a clan with 8.5s, 9.5s, and 10.5s and typically win 2/3 of wars. Since the update we have had horrendous matchups with many highly engineered clans with multiple th11s with th7 defenses for example. We have been perfect warred 4 times in a row after not getting perfect warred for months. Please change it back to the way it was otherwise I fear my classmates clanmates will all quit.
Another very close and even war. Final score was 59 to 5. Why was this even? They would of gotten 59 but lost on pct since the war came down to the #1 spot. Ours was a 66% 2* theirs a 65% 2*. They completely gave up after that attack.
Overall excellent match up.
If you're not smarter than the guy you're dealing with you lose.
You failed to utilize the most effective strategy by not using the most available resources to affect your outcome.
I play to win. You play to see how tough you are.
Defeat the enemy anyway you can.
Hi,maxer clan here since the update our wars have been evenly matched,our current one in favour of oppo,but defo winnable.hopefully the clans who quit wars will try clan wars again,plus this update will make it easier to opt in new players which every game needsHi everyone!
As you know, last week we deployed some changes to Clan Wars matchmaking, as well as some balancing adjustments to the Cannon Cart in the Builder Base.
For those who have been able to experience the new War Matchmaking and try the re-balanced Cannon Cart, we would love to hear from you! Share your feedback and comments below please!
We have been experimenting since the change putting in different lineups
cant draw any conclusions from such a small data sample but to add to the mix
on the ones where we have just used 'balanced' bases with a mix of th10,9,8,7 we have had a remarkable good matchup, the last one the th level and quantity were the same on both sides. This does include a couple of natural 8.5s
on the ones where we have experimented with defenceless, th3 padding, minimaxs - we have got our trousers pulled down with unwinnable wars
one other thing to note is that our lineup could be considered top heavy with 6 late th9 (max def 25+) in a 15vs
so from our testing at least, a nice balanced roster equals a nice balanced matchup
(so far at least!)
Last edited by c0mical; September 16th, 2017 at 10:44 AM.
Result : 71 (80.4) v 66 (83.57) WIN for Us
War #11 (30v30)
Us
1-12 TH11 with EA.
13-23 TH10 with inferno.
24-26 TH10 no inferno
27-30 TH9
Them
1-12 TH11 with EA
13-14 TH11 no EA, Max Heroes & Troops
15 TH11 no EA, Max K&Q, 13 GW, Bowlers, Valks, Healer, Rage, Jump, Heal Maxed.
16-18 TH10 with inferno
19 TH11 no EA, lv8 GW, Maxed Witch, Bowler, Valk, Jump, Heal, Rage.
20-26 TH10 with inferno
27 TH10 no inferno
28-29 TH9
30 TH8
So, yet another mis match, atleast this time we are only outnumbered by 4 TH11s.
C'mon Darian, this is getting ridiculous. Out of 11 Wars under the new algorithm, we have been matched against Engineers a total of 9 times, and the lowest number of TH11s we have been down is 4. We've even had a TH11 with Max heroes and Troops mirrored against a TH9.
Our matches have been far worse under the new MM.
War #12
Us
1-11 TH11 with EA
12-19 TH10 with inferno
20-22 TH10 no inferno
23-25 TH9
Them
1-14 TH11 with EA
15 TH10 with inferno
16 TH11 no inferno or EA, Max Heroes + most troops maxed
17 TH11 no inferno or EA, Max Q+W + most troops maxed
18 TH11 no inferno or EA, lv2 W, only valks maxed
19 TH10 no inferno
20 TH11 (th9 defences), Max Heroes + most troops maxed
21 TH10 no inferno
22 TH9
23 TH11 (TH7 defences except 1 inferno), Max loons, lv3 hound, lv6 warden lv5 k+Q
24 TH8
25 TH7
Clearly Engineered Clan (both individually and roster)
They have 3 extra EAs. 8 extra Wardens, 6+ lots of maxed troops.
OK, we have a defence advantage lower down, but they have advantage at top, and offence advantage.
So this is 10 out of 12 on the new MM where we have been out numbered on TH11 bases.
Last edited by Bigtone2001; September 16th, 2017 at 12:12 PM.
War match making getting worse, we have consecutive losses because of engineered bases with high troops. This is not fair play we have 3 straight losses and now the 4th will be loss too because it is unfair obviously mismatch!!! Please do something about this because this is not fun anymore.
Posting Permissions
