Clan War Matchmaking Improvements

[Swizzie2000]

Darian,

With all due respect, when the opponents #15 can 3 star the opponents 2 top bases with their totally lopsided offense / defense base...

It seems like cheating. I really hope your team addresses engineered bases, because it's not fair, it's not balanced, and it's not in the spirit of competition.

Hope y'all can figure it out.

[shielded]

I disagree th11 should be able to 3 star most th10 most of the time with Max troops. It's a mismatch and it happens way too often and now sc will beef up th11 with the next update awesome...

Absolutely agree most th11 will smoke a TH10 I've seen many matches where a engineer th11 at rank 18 out of 20 took down are #1 and we knew it before war started it was over. On a brighter not this is are first some what even match after 5 straight times. I hope the ratio improves but at least we have hope this war. Just been a tough go in matchaking as I've said in previous post this is what I want and I believe the community wants. More than builder base content etc. Just a fair shot in war match making

[Krudler02]

New war.

We have no engineered bases.

Us - them
Th11 1-5 and their top 3 are strong defense and all are strong offense. Heroes and wardens.
Th10 3 - 1
Th9 5 - 2

For what it's worth - I cannot keep my clan mates interested in war while this nonsense is going on.

[Jcman]

No one would disagree what most are asking for is that Th11 with Th11 offense to match other Th11’s.

I don’t even agree with Th-1 weight structure. Match the Town Halls the slight disadvantage you have as a fresh TH level is less then 30 days

It does not have to be the first check but overall there should be effort put in the algorithm to say team 1 3 th11, 5 th10, 14 th9. Team 2 7 Th11, 8 th10, 5 th9 no match

It should not matter what the defense/ offense levels are if a match shows up like this.

As I said my last war was 4 th11 v 10th11 that’s a no match in my opinion

The thing is, going with the TH-1 max weight structure is not just adding weight to a Townhall. It is changing the starting war weight of a war base, focusing on war weighting and ability to wage war. A fresh Townhall 11 would weigh the same as a Max TH10, that is no significant encumbrance. If it was just a flat 20,000 extra weight just for a TH 11 no matter the rest of the base I would agree that would be either excessive or NOT enou weight and just promotes more extreme engineering.

Imagine a maxed th10 going to 11 all of a sudden is punished and paired with mid level th11s, obvious mismatch. That is something my system would avoid entirely because it is addressing the war weight of the ENTIRE BASE, not just the Townhall.

War Weight of a Warbase = TH-1 max weight + any new buildings/levels/troop levels/new hero levels beyond previous max townhall could make.

Done. simple, effective way to fairly weigh a war base. It still allows tweaking within a townhall for .5s and fairly accounts for any offensive advantage. IT is not simply adding a bunch of weight to a townhall.

[njr2801]

New war.

We have no engineered bases.

Us - them
Th11 1-5 and their top 3 are strong defense and all are strong offense. Heroes and wardens.
Th10 3 - 1
Th9 5 - 2

For what it's worth - I cannot keep my clan mates interested in war while this nonsense is going on.

agreed it is awful, it is now two months since we faced the same number of th11s. Our worst is 5 th11s for us vs 12 for them in a 20vs20 complete joke

[PapaTroll]

New war.

We have no engineered bases.

Us - them
Th11 1-5 and their top 3 are strong defense and all are strong offense. Heroes and wardens.
Th10 3 - 1
Th9 5 - 2

For what it's worth - I cannot keep my clan mates interested in war while this nonsense is going on.

Get some engineers. Stop going to war with one hand tied behind your back.

[Krudler02]

Get some engineers. Stop going to war with one hand tied behind your back.

We have engineered accounts. We have been getting horrible matches and attributing it to them so we dropped them this time. No matter what we do we are pulling horrible matches.

[BZ1]

So it has been 3 days. About 8 to 12 hours each day of search times and no matches. Good job supercell.

I am running a maxer th8 war with 2 engineered bases at th9. Because, we would frequently draw a th9 with a queen and or an xbow with maxer 8 bases. So we had to engineer because of the really bad match making. Good job supercell.

Now we cant find a match....Goo job supercell.

And the reality, supercell encouraged and permitted engineering for at least 2 years. Who keeps drinking the supercell kool aid. Cuz this game is down right horrible.

Just find a new game guys.

[galgadot2]

So it has been 3 days. About 8 to 12 hours each day of search times and no matches. Good job supercell.

I am running a maxer th8 war with 2 engineered bases at th9. Because, we would frequently draw a th9 with a queen and or an xbow with maxer 8 bases. So we had to engineer because of the really bad match making. Good job supercell.

Now we cant find a match....Goo job supercell.

And the reality, supercell encouraged and permitted engineering for at least 2 years. Who keeps drinking the supercell kool aid. Cuz this game is down right horrible.

Just find a new game guys.

You find new game yourself, I'm not interested.

I play other games already, but sticking with CoC as well for the time being. I'm not THAT weak-hearted.

[BZ1]

You find new game yourself, I'm not interested.

I play other games already, but sticking with CoC as well for the time being. I'm not THAT weak-hearted.

Good for u.