Clan War Matchmaking Improvements

[Bigtone2001]

1st war on updated MM
us
1-14 TH11 with EA
15 TH11 no EA
16-26 TH10 with inferno
27-28 TH10 no inferno (new)
29-30 TH9

them
1-15 TH11 with EA
16-17 TH11 no EA
18-25 TH10 with Inferno
26 TH10 no inferno
27 TH11 no inferno or EA. GW lv5 Max bowlers and valks
28-30 TH9

2nd War on new MM
us
1-13 TH11 with EA
14-16 TH11 no EA
17-27 TH10 with infernos
28 TH10 no inferno
29-30 TH9

them
1-16 TH11 with EA
17 TH11 no EA Max Heroes & Troops
18-26 TH10 with inferno
27 TH11 no inferno or ea, GW lv 12, Max bowler, witch, valk
28 TH10 no inferno
29-30 TH9

3rd War on new MM
us
1-11 TH11 with EA
12-13 TH11 no EA
14-22 TH10 with inferno
23 TH10 no inferno
24-25 TH9

them
1-13 TH11 with EA
14-15 TH11 no EA
16 TH10 with inferno
17 TH11 no EA, lv3 GW, valks only maxed
18-20 TH10 with inferno
21-23 TH9
24 TH8
25 TH9 (defenceless)




1st war, only 1 EA down, and 3 TH11s. Best match we've had for a while. We won 75-70
2nd war, 3 EAs down and 2 TH11s. We've had a lot worse.. We Won 72-71, we got lucky, they had unused TH11 attacks, and we had a couple of missed opportunities (96%+)
3rd war, 2 EAs down and 2 TH11s (not counting #17), could be close, will come down to attacks against EAs.

So far, it's not perfect, but matches have been closer since latest update. (Atleast we aren't 5+ TH11s down)
We aren't engineered, a few recently upgraded THs, so a few weeks and all TH11s will have EAs.

[shielded]

Good for you ( and not trying to be smart either ) Were a non rushed team also. Has not worked well including current war. Badly out gunned. In my opinion it needs work big time. But glad it's going well. Are war record is solid. Nearly 100 plus wins than losses. But we would have fewer losses if not for engineering...And lately last 10 match ups have been awful!.

[Squibis]

The only disadvantage an engineered base does, is make the matchmaking take 10-24hrs.

Minimax Savage has had a couple resets cause if it goes 24hrs it resets. Lololololz

[Krudler02]

So we just spun again.

Us : them
Th11 - 1 : 6
Th10 - 2 : 3
Th9 - 9 : 2
Th8 and lower - 8 - 9

Th11s are all engineered. We have 2 engineered 9s.

[cjsteve]

We had a hundred more wins than losses but that has dwindled. We fought hard but we lost a lot in the early days with the problem with third-party apps now it's the same thing over again with the engineering matchmaking issues. We are a totally fair play Clan have been from the beginning and quite frankly it seems it's no longer worth it. I doubt I will ever compromise my values I simply do not like overwhelming my opponent by virtue of being sneaky and having some th11 at the bottom of the war map ready to pounce on the top. After 4 years and I can't tell you how much money I have invested but it's ridiculous as I hate farming but what I could have done with all the time that I've wasted on this game. Feel most sorry for all the friends that I've gained they're sick of it too and I can do nothing to help them as a leader I've tried so hard changing our lineup running small Wars bigger Wars just everything and everyone is burnt out.

[Krudler02]

I can't help but think this all could have been prevented with a simple dialogue box whenever someone hit upgrade on their th level. Something to the effect of - "are you sure you want to upgrade your town hall? Doing so will match you against your new th level most often in war. Continue to upgrade? Yes / no".

[Lunaticfringe]

Well, my hopes for a reasonable MM just went out the window.

I'm so irritated, I shouldn't even be posting, but whatever.

No TH11s in our clan, mostly TH10s and TH9s in a 15v15 war

Engineered enemy "players"?

6 TH11s, and all TH10s (save for the bottom base which is a defenseless TH9).

Further, their 6 (a TH11) is so lopsided, a TH8 could 3* it. I kid you not. You can then imagine what 7-15 are. My God...

But their top 4 are extremely strong defensively.

Seriously, SC, I would literally swear at you right now.

Your MM is a JOKE and a pathetic one at that

[Champi192837465]

Before matchmaking was bad, but still coherent. We are about to lose second war in a row because of matchups. 10v10 war. Their 9 3 starred myself (1). Th11 defensless base max heroes... They 100%ed us. Now again they are going to 98% or more our bases. Absurd

[cul8er73]

Feel that the last update have made things even worse. Current war their number 11 (a TH11, engineered base) three stared our number 2. My clan is giving up. Have a hard time even finding 10 clan mates willing to engage in CW with current matchmaking system. Since the last upgrades we as a none engineered clan are matched constantly with engineered clans where they have almost twice as many TH11 as us.

[whit3beard]

Hey you mouth breathers.
We have 3 x TH11
The enemy has 11 x TH11

72-72 in a 25v25 and we lose on %. I'm sick of competing as an absolute underdog. No war should EVER be so lopsided.

Why should I have 9 players with totally maxed heroes and maxed troops against me? We had 3 x TH10 and they had 4 x TH10

The matchmaking was fine until this latest absolutely pathetic update. Total garbage. Do any of you actually have a clue what you're doing? Feel free to hire me so I can come to Helsinki and fix it for you nerds.