Prior to MM changes War Log - 34W / 5L / 0T
After MM changes (2 rounds) - 6W / 5L / 0T
Seems legit.
Prior to MM changes War Log - 34W / 5L / 0T
After MM changes (2 rounds) - 6W / 5L / 0T
Seems legit.
TH12.5 - BK60 / AQ60 / GW30
War Hero: 2205 All Time Trophies: 5992
It's not working, our last 3 wars have been against engineered clans and my members are fast losing patience. Our present war is, on the map from the top, us: 14 th11's , 10 th10's, 6 th9's against 15 th 11s, 3 th10s, 4 th11's, 1 th10, 2 th 11s, 1 th10, 1 th 11, 1 th 9, 2 th 11s. Yes, we got battered, it's so demoralising and so not fun. My members are asking not to war.
I'm just going to drop this and go. Can we stop calling engineer bases cheap and call them cheaters! If Your manipulating the system or looking for a unfair advantage it's cheating! So sick of my team dealing with Dirty th11 bases with the weight of a th9. I believe the t. Halls should have weight. Give the cheaters exactly what they deserve a base in there town hall. Why compromise the entire game for people that cheat! Or cover it up with words like cheap, or let them build the way the want. Ok sure let them build a th9 with the weight of a 8. BUT GIVE THEM A TH9 TO DEAL WITH!! DONT COMPROMISE FOR CHEATERS! And before u cry hater ( some will) we take on all teams even cheaters and beat a lot of them not all but a lot. We're in another unfair match up. We are out gunned we should lose. But will take every turn. Will empty the clip. Super Cell help us!
I know others have said it but this las 15 man war we have 4 th11 they had 8 all with eagle and warden +2 th9 d 11’s was enough for me to take a break from wars. Others have said it and I thought to my self well go pout in the corner but now I understand they were letting the community broken match’s caused another casualty.
Well add my name to the list I’ll revisit wars in a couple weeks/ months see if it changes
All I have left is farming as I pushed to legend last month that’s a horrible experience
What is the big problem for SC in correcting the algorithm to simply take the TH level as one of the measurements for war weight... if you have TH11 you should weigh in at least as a TH9 - because of the advantages like bigger CC and traps/bombs upgrades alone... For our clans (I have accounts in three) every 'tweak' leads to ridiculous matches and yes, people are quitting. People who were always 'maxers' are now thinking of going lopsided as well, to at least stand a chance... This suggestion has been done over and over and over again ... people still have a choice in what they want to do with their buildings, how they want to play... in regular attacks your TH level counts (as in loot penalties for lower th's)...
Our last war we had 2 of our TH6 and two of our TH7 up against lopsided TH9 (and not surprisingly with large CC'ss, high level bombs and tesla's and such - not even speaking of the troop levels)
Current war - 20v20 (us : them)
TH11 - 2 : 6
TH10 - 3 : 4
TH9 - 9 : 8
The rest TH8/7 - 6 : 2
Admittedly, every TH11 on both sides is engineered. We have 2 engineered TH9s. None of our TH10s are engineered. Also my 2 TH11s are recovering, building defenses and have all buildings at some stage.
I let in anyone who wanted to play since the loot is doubled. It was a mistake. but still....
Lvl 200 AQ: 60 BK: 60 GW: 27 FIN(consolidated): 700k
Night Warriors - Leader: Clan Tag: #2PCCRLYP - LVL 15
We're ALWAYS recruiting. Core together ~6+ years. War participation optional. 2 or 3 wars per week. PM to join
We have kinda the same deal going on, the TH8 and TH7 having to go up against the modified TH9 and even TH10 if mirroring which we don't usually do. The bases have just enough of the higher defenses to leave us at 2 start 90%s and make others dip.Originally Posted by JusMe
Also, maybe as a minimum, a Th11 could be a TH9, but as soon as the warden drops, the base matchup for a TH11 should be a TH11 imo. Same with the eagle.
Lvl 200 AQ: 60 BK: 60 GW: 27 FIN(consolidated): 700k
Night Warriors - Leader: Clan Tag: #2PCCRLYP - LVL 15
We're ALWAYS recruiting. Core together ~6+ years. War participation optional. 2 or 3 wars per week. PM to join
This update does not kill engineered bases or make them ineffective, it simply tries to match them up with other engineered bases.
SAVE THE CLASH ROYALE FORUMS! SUPERCELL, PLEASE!
#WeAreForumersNotRedditers
I'm not saying SC should 'kill' anything, they have made it abundantly clear they see engineering as a play style, a form of tactics, and who am I to tell them different.
I'm not posting much on the subject anyway because by now it makes my head hurt... It's just no fun at all to see people leaving altogether or not warring anymore because sometimes half the people can't go up against any of the bases against us (and they aren't engineered on our side...)
Matchups seem to get worse for two of our three clans. In one clan the last two wars are only th8, 9 and 10 and those are 'reasonable'... (and no, we don't expect to win every war... hehe)
I can see how that would be a logical conclusion, and if that were indeed the case I would be fully supportive of such an initiative. Unfortunately though, we haven't seen that it's completely true. I've tried wars with only our maxers and wars with a few low weight engineered bases, and in both situations we've been still matched with engineers.
In the last 3 weeks, we've had 3 really good matches. REALLY good fun war matches. Won 2 and lost 1, right down at the wire. The stuff that makes war so great.
The other 6 or so, in our favour and not in our favour, were obviously predictable right away because the match was so bad. Mostly not in our favour.
Lvl 200 AQ: 60 BK: 60 GW: 27 FIN(consolidated): 700k
Night Warriors - Leader: Clan Tag: #2PCCRLYP - LVL 15
We're ALWAYS recruiting. Core together ~6+ years. War participation optional. 2 or 3 wars per week. PM to join
